Technologies, techniques and practices for producing alternative fertilising products from secondary raw materials in Europe and beyond Technologies, techniques and practices for producing alternative fertilising products from secondary raw materials in Europe and beyond
Code | Technology/Technique/Practice short/commercial name | Technology/Technique/Practice full title/name | Main resource stream | Secondary resource stream | Secondary resource stream 2 | Main raw materials | Secondary raw materials | Component Material Categories (CMC) | Component Material Categories (CMC) 2 | Component Material Categories (CMC) 3 | Quantity of secondary raw materials processed [t/day, t/month, t/year] | Technology/Technique/Practice main production stages | Technology/Technique/Practice description | General diagram graphic diagram of the Technology/Technique/Practice | Fertilizer product(s) commertial name/common name | Other by-products Energy/heat/waste water/soild waste/etc. | Main Product Function Categories (PFC)/Type of fertilizer product | Secondary Product Function Categories (PFC)/Type of fertilizer product | Secondary Product Function Categories (PFC)/Type of fertilizer product O | Nutrient content Main nutrient content [%], Dry Matter Basis | OM | Corg | N | P | K | Ca | Mg | S | Physical properties | Dry matter content [%] | Density [kg/m3] | Visual examples of final product | Technology/technique/practice production capacity [t/day, t/month, t/year] | Technology/Technique/Practice mobility Static - Mobile | TRL | Operating/existing installation | Environmental impact and LCA data availability | Level of complexity Low - Medium - High | Replication potencial Low -Medium - High | Region of implementation | Country of implementation | Statistical location NUTS | Limitations/challenges | Relevant stakeholders | Data source(s) Literature/websites/databases | Ongoing/completed project | Additional information and comments | Responsible Project Partner/editor |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
T1 | Ammonium nitrate or ammonium sulphate from liquid fraction of manure, digestate or other waste stream by "Detricon" process | Technology for N recovery as inorganic fertilizer starting from liquid fraction of manure, digestate or other waste streams with "Detricon" stripping and scrubbing process | Agricultural Biomasses | Municipal Biowaste | Urban Wastewater | Agricultural Biomasses: liquid fraction of manure Urban Wastewater: landfill leachate, liquid waste streams with more than 0,1% ammonia nitrogen | Agricultural Biomasses: liquid fraction digestate Municipal Biowaste: liquid fraction digestate | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | Separation of the liquid fraction of manure or other liquid waste streams; transfer of the liquid fraction to a stripper; recovery of nitrogen in the stripper by removing volatile ammonia from the liquid fraction by blowing air and adjusting pH and temperature; the ammonia-enriched air from the stripper is chemically bound with nitric acid or sulfuric acid to ammonium nitrate or ammonium sulfate in the scrubber. | In the Detricon stripping/scrubbing process, ammonia is recovered from liquid fraction of manure, digestate or other liquid waste streams andconcentrated into a single fertilizer product. First, the manure needs to be mechanically separated, then the liquid fraction is transferred to the stripper/scrubber. Under the influence of pH and temperature, the ratio ammonia/ammonium can be increased so that the ammoniacal nitrogen can volatilize more quickly. By blowing in air, the volatile ammonia is removed from the liquid fraction and the nitrogen can be recovered. The air from the stripper, enriched with ammonia, is chemically bound to ammonium nitrate by nitric acid or ammonium sulphate by sulfuric acid in the scrubber. The concentration of ammonium nitrate (or sulphate) is determined by the initial amount of water in the scrubber and the amount of nitric acid (or sulphuric acid) added during the production process. The technology produces a technical pure-end product, ammonium nitrate or ammonium sulphate. In the Detricon process the concentration is set to 52 mass% ammonium nitrate which corresponds to 18 mass% N or 40 mass% ammonium sulphate which corresponds to 8,5 mass% N and 9,5 mass% S. After the ammonia in the scrubber is chemically bound, the ammonia-poor (<20 ppm NH3) air goes back to the stripper. Detricon's technology is an energy efficient and economic interesting technology to produce locally a pure nitrogen fertilizer without other nutrients. It is an example of circular economy. | https://www.detricon.eu/_files/ugd/3dfe50_d30200ab07de466d992eca1ae0c3ab46.pdf https://nutriman.net/sites/default/files/2020-10/296_INFO%20SHEET-Technology%20-%20Detricon.pdf | Liquid ammonium nitrate or liquid ammonium sulphate | solid fraction | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | Liquid ammonium sulphate | 8.5 | 9.5 | 1230 | https://www.detricon.eu/_files/ugd/3dfe50_d30200ab07de466d992eca1ae0c3ab46.pdf | 100-5.000 ton/year (scale up options: 200.000 ton/year) | Static | 9 | Yes | No | High | Low | EU Southwest | Belgium / Flemish Region | 1) Detricon has a EU patent pending of their stripping/scrubbing technology. 2) The cost is 300.000 euro for 3 m³/h stripping/scrubbing and 550.000 euro for 8 m³/h stripping/scrubbing; operational: 0,9-1,2 euro/ton depending on the market value of the produced liquid ammonium nitrate. | DETRICON BVBA https://www.detricon.eu/ | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_296 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_295 https://www.detricon.eu/ | NUTRIMAN / project completed | IUNG | |||||||||||||
T2 | Ammonium nitrate or ammonium sulphate from liquid fraction of manure, digestate or other waste stream by "Detricon" process | Technology for N recovery as inorganic fertilizer starting from liquid fraction of manure, digestate or other waste streams with "Detricon" stripping and scrubbing process | Agricultural Biomasses | Municipal Biowaste | Urban Wastewater | Agricultural Biomasses: liquid fraction of manure Urban Wastewater: landfill leachate, liquid waste streams with more than 0,1% ammonia nitrogen | Agricultural Biomasses: liquid fraction digestate Municipal Biowaste: liquid fraction digestate | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | Separation of the liquid fraction of manure or other liquid waste streams; transfer of the liquid fraction to a stripper; recovery of nitrogen in the stripper by removing volatile ammonia from the liquid fraction by blowing air and adjusting pH and temperature; the ammonia-enriched air from the stripper is chemically bound with nitric acid or sulfuric acid to ammonium nitrate or ammonium sulfate in the scrubber. | In the Detricon stripping/scrubbing process, ammonia is recovered from liquid fraction of manure, digestate or other liquid waste streams andconcentrated into a single fertilizer product. First, the manure needs to be mechanically separated, then the liquid fraction is transferred to the stripper/scrubber. Under the influence of pH and temperature, the ratio ammonia/ammonium can be increased so that the ammoniacal nitrogen can volatilize more quickly. By blowing in air, the volatile ammonia is removed from the liquid fraction and the nitrogen can be recovered. The air from the stripper, enriched with ammonia, is chemically bound to ammonium nitrate by nitric acid or ammonium sulphate by sulfuric acid in the scrubber. The concentration of ammonium nitrate (or sulphate) is determined by the initial amount of water in the scrubber and the amount of nitric acid (or sulphuric acid) added during the production process. The technology produces a technical pure-end product, ammonium nitrate or ammonium sulphate. In the Detricon process the concentration is set to 52 mass% ammonium nitrate which corresponds to 18 mass% N or 40 mass% ammonium sulphate which corresponds to 8,5 mass% N and 9,5 mass% S. After the ammonia in the scrubber is chemically bound, the ammonia-poor (<20 ppm NH3) air goes back to the stripper. Detricon's technology is an energy efficient and economic interesting technology to produce locally a pure nitrogen fertilizer without other nutrients. It is an example of circular economy. | https://www.detricon.eu/_files/ugd/3dfe50_d30200ab07de466d992eca1ae0c3ab46.pdf https://nutriman.net/sites/default/files/2020-10/296_INFO%20SHEET-Technology%20-%20Detricon.pdf | Liquid ammonium nitrate or liquid ammonium sulphate | solid fraction | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | Liquid ammonium nitrate | 18 or 10 | 1250.0 (for 18% N) | https://www.detricon.eu/_files/ugd/3dfe50_d30200ab07de466d992eca1ae0c3ab46.pdf | 100-5.000 ton/year (scale up options: 200.000 ton/year) | Static | 9 | Yes | No | High | Low | EU Southwest | Belgium / Flemish Region | 1) Detricon has a EU patent pending of their stripping/scrubbing technology. 2) The cost is 300.000 euro for 3 m³/h stripping/scrubbing and 550.000 euro for 8 m³/h stripping/scrubbing; operational: 0,9-1,2 euro/ton depending on the market value of the produced liquid ammonium nitrate. | DETRICON BVBA https://www.detricon.eu/ | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_296 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_295 https://www.detricon.eu/ | NUTRIMAN / project completed | IUNG | ||||||||||||||
T3 | Anaerobic digestion | Industrial side-streams | Industrial side-streams | Industrial side-streams: food industry by-products | Industrial side-streams: food industry by-products | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | 20,000t/year | Milk from farmer shareholders is processed to remove milk fat (derived to butter production). • Skimmed milk is used to produce cheese and whey. • Whey proteins are stripped from whey and sold for nutritional ingredients purposes. • The derived waste, whey permeate, is fermented into bioethanol (12 million L/year). • A co-product of said fermentation is stillage waste. This is the feedstock for anaerobic digestion, which produces biogas. • The solid waste from the digester is treated into an organic fertilizer. | Anaerobic digestion is a series of biological process in which micro-organisms break down organic material under oxygen-free conditions. This usually refers to methane fermentation in which the final product is biogas, a mixture of methane and carbon dioxide. Anaerobic digestion therefore is a form of fermentation. The recalcitrant part remains and is called digestate. The process takes place in stirred and heated reactors, often with a volume of more than 1,000 m3, and the conversion of solid organic substances into biogas usually takes one month. There are mainly two different methods for digestion shortly, mono- and co-digestion. With mono-digestion, manure (e.g. cattle or pig) is the sole input stream into the digester. Co-digestion is the digestion of both manure in combination with other input streams like crop residues or grass. In both systems, the aim is to produce biogas. Typical composition of biogas is 60% methane (CH4), 35% carbon dioxide (CO2), 5% other gasses, such as hydrogen sulphide (H2S), ammonia (NH3) and others. Biogas can be used to produce energy by burning it directly (heat) or in a combined heat and power device (heat and electricity combined). Digestate can be used as fertilizer since it contains nutrients such as N, P and K. Digestion of manure has a positive environmental effect. There are basically two subtypes of digestion (next to the already mentioned main types, co- and mono-digestion): namely wet and dry digestion. Wet digestion means that a big basin with a stirring mechanism (mixing the slurry) is filled with a liquid mixture. Dry digestion is suitable for fibrous/stalky materials, that are difficult to digest in a slurry. An example of a feedstock suitable for dry digestion is grass or straw. Dry digestion is done by an airtight device/container with a sprinkler in the roof. Biomass is placed on the floor and liquid (e.g. manure) is sprayed over the biomass. The liquid seeps through the biomass to the floor, which is permeable for the liquid. In the floor, the liquid is collected. | organic fertilizer | Fuel (bioethanol, biogas), Heat, Electrical power | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 15,000t/year | Static/Mobile | 9 | Yes | Yes | High | Low | EU North | Ireland | https://www.carbery.com/sustainability/ https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCdU_43VsPnZ312FS3fIwXAw https://ie.linkedin.com/company/carbery-group | https://mainstreambio-digital-toolkit.eu/catalogue_business_model/1689321866692x730440344117356500?lang=en_us&intro=yes&solution=business_models&business=feedstock&repository=audio_visual&tech=biochemical&technology=products&resources=audio_visual | MAINSTREAMBIO / project completed | Carbery’s Ballineen facility, their most significant emitter of carbon emissions, is now fueled with natural gas, of which 4.6% is produced on-site in their anaerobic digester. Sludge from the anaerobic digestion is used as an energy source for the manufacturing plant and provides 9% of the Ballineen site’s steam power. Carbery has also installed reverse osmosis systems to recover and recycle water contained in whey permeate, reducing water waste. | IUNG | |||||||||||||||||||||
T4 | High temperature pyrolysis for biotech carrier/adsorber production; Liquid fermentation; Solid state fermentation and formulation; Liquid phase adsorption | Industrial side-streams | Industrial side-streams: food industry by-products | Industrial side-streams: food industrial by-products | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | 3R developed a specific liquid/solid state fermentation and adsorber integrated technology where the unexploited food industrial WW (acid whey) will be upcycled as a liquid medium during the fermentation process. If required, additional food industrial by-products will also be added. The liquid fermenter (150 L/batch) will be inoculated by a selected agriculturally beneficial microbial strain (Trichoderma spp) or consortia of microbial strains. The obtained microbial biomass will be used for inoculation of the solid fermentation system, where ABC Animal Bone Char adsorber added. The end-product is P/Ca enriched compound BBF in economical, high nutrient density, microbial plant biostimulant and clean irrigation water for horticultural application or other industrial uses. | The objecve of 3R Zero Emission Pyrolysis & Phosphorus Recovery Technology is the added value upgrading and valorisa on of food grade animal by-products into safe and high value recovered organic Phosphorus fertiliser by integrated thermal and Biotechnological recycling means. The ABC (Animal Bone Char) BioPhosphate product is made of different types of food grade animal bone grist, most importantly cale bones, which basic material is already processed at 133 degree Celsius for 20 minutes under 3 bar processing conditions. The high Phosphorous content animal bone grist input feed streams are low value ulized by-products. In the 3R process the bone grist is heated to as high as 850 degree Celsius material core carbonizaon temperature, that is far higher than usual biomass processing temperatures, but absolute needed to get high quality and safe product. During the advanced pyrolysis (reducve thermal processing) all volale and protein based substances are removed from the mineral frame, and a highly macro-porous hydroxyapate (70-76%), CaCO3 (7-13%) and carbon (8-11%) content apate type mineral material produced. The output products are high quality and safe ABC-BioPhosphate and its wide range of BIO-NPK-C bio- formulated variaons used for organic/low input farming and environmental (adsorbent) applicaons. | BIO-NPK- C ; ABC( Animal Bone Char)-BioPhosphate | water | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 15.28 | 31.43 | 20,800 t/y | Static | 9 | Yes | Yes | High | Low | EU Central | hungary | no limitations | https://walnutproject.eu/news/revolutionizing-waste-management-in-dairy-industry-the-3r-pilot-plant/ | https://biofertilisers.3rbiofarm.com/sites/default/files/attachments/2023-10/3r_biophosphate_fact_sheet.pdf https://biophosphate.net/ https://biophosphate.net/sites/default/files/attachments/2023-07/3r_fact_sheet_2.pdf | WALNUT project completed | REACH certificate number: 01-2119490075-38-0042, Organic cerficated | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||||||
T5 | Ammonia water by VP-Hobe process | Technology for N recovery as mineral concentrate, ammonia water and ammonium sulphate from manure/digestate by VP-Hobe manure and digestate valorisation system | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: livestock manure and slurry | Agricultural Biomasses: digestate of cattle manure, pig manure or co-fermentation | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | The capacity of the technology is scalable: 50.000, 125.000, 250.000 ton input/year | (1) Separation manure in a flotation unit and in a belt filter press to the liquid and solid fraction. (The solid fraction is dried on a belt dryer.) (2) Concentration of the liquid fraction reverse osmosis (RO) process (3) De-watering the RO-concentrate in an evaporator. (4) Removal of ammonia from flowing liquid stream by stripping and concentrated into NH3-water. (5) Futher production of potassium concentrate and ammonium sulphate solution by scrubbing the vapour coming out of the evaporator with sulphuric acid. (6) Cleaning of condensate from the Evaporator/ Stripper/ Scrubber (ESS) unit and RO permeate in the RO water polisher and the ion exchanger (RO-IE) for discharge into surface waters. | The VP-Hobe manure and digestate valorisation system is a robust proven technology operated at own processing plants. Contains the following modules : (1) Solid-Liquid-separation: Separation takes place in a flotation unit and in a belt filter press. The input manure is separated into a solid and a liquid fraction. A flocculant is added. In the flotation system, small air bubbles bring particles to the surface of the tank where it forms a layer of sludge. This layer is scraped off and de-watered in the belt filter press into a solid fraction of 30% dry matter (DM). The solid fraction is dried on a belt dryer to 90% DM. (2) Reverse Osmosis (RO): A RO processes the liquid fraction (1,7% DM) into a retentate concentrated-N/K2O product (3,4% DM) and a permeate product to be processed in the clean water production. (3) Evaporator/ Stripper/ Scrubber (ESS): The RO-concentrate or thin fraction will be further de-watered in an evaporator. The liquid passes through a falling film evaporator with mechanical vapour recompression. Heating the liquid in the evaporator causes water to evaporate. A vacuum lowers the boiling point, less energy is needed than when evaporating at normal atmospheric pressure. The ammonia in the incoming liquid is removed from the product flow by stripping and concentration into NH3-water (14% N). The evaporator further produces a potassium concentrate (25% DM and 6,5% K2O) and ammonium sulphate solution by scrubbing the vapour coming out of the evaporator with sulphuric acid. (4) Clean water production (RO-IE): The condensate from ESS unit and the permeate from the RO is cleaned in the RO water polisher and the ion exchanger (RO-IE) to achieve the right quality for discharge into surface waters. The VP-Hobe process achieves lowest possible operational costs (energy, additives) while produces several fertilizers, e.g. mineral- and potassium-concentrate, NH3-water, Ammonium sulphate, as well as clean dischargeable water. The products are hygienic and free from salmonella and E-coli. | NH3-water (PFC 1(C)), Liquid ammonium sulphate (PFC 1(C)), Liquid mineral concentrate (PFC 3(B)), Liquid K concentrate (PFC 3(A)) | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | PFC 3(B): Inorganic soil improver | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | NH3-water | 14.0 | Static | 9 | Yes | No | High | Low | EU Southwest | The Netherlands also Belgium, Germany and other | 1) Authority permit not necessary for local distribution. This product is a potential RENURE fertilizer which means that application will no longer be defined as livestock manure in the Nitrates Directive. This means application will no longer be limited to 170 kg N/ha. /The nitrogen in liquid K concentrate product is still considered livestock manure as defined in the Nitrates Directive. 2) The presence of sulfur in the product can be limiting aplication on grass. 3) Geographical area: max 30 kms from processing plant (for liquid ammonium sulfate) or 200 kms area around processing plant (for liquid NK concentrate). 4) Due to the organic origin of the fertilizer, nutrient content may vary change if changes the quality of the inputs (for liquid mineral concentrate). | VP-HoBe http://www.vp-hobe.nl/ | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_669 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_1529 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_1527 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_1504 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_1528 | NUTRIMAN / project completed | IUNG | |||||||||||||||||||
T6 | Ammonium nitrate/sulphate from raw digestate with "AMFER" stripping process | Technology for N recovery as ammonium nitrate/sulphate from raw digestate with "AMFER" stripping process | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: manure | Agricultural Biomasses: digestate (liquid fraction, pre-treated manure) | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | no data | Spraying the digestate (or other liquid) into a tank and aerating to remove ammonia from the liquid into the air. Scrubbing the air with acid to produce an ammonium salt (nitrogen fertilizer) - ammonium nitrate or ammonium sulfate. | The AMFER® technology is designed for the treatment of digestate from manure (co) digestion. Digestate (or other liquids) is sprayed in the tank and aerated to strip the ammonia is removed from the liquid to the air. The air is scrubbed with an acid, to produce the nitrogen fertilizer (an ammonium salt), which can be ammonium nitrate or ammonium sulphate. The produced fertilizer has a nitrogen content of 7% (ammonium sulphate, 35%) or 18% (ammonium nitrate, 52%). The AMFER® nitrogen stripper operates as a batch or semi-continuous system. The AMFER process tank is designed to enable the treatment of thicker and more viscous products, up to 10% DM. Therefore any digestate from biogas plants can be treated in the AMFER, without separation up front. A typical removal efficiency is 50% on mineral nitrogen, although removal of > 85% is also possible. The AMFER is available at any size needed, starting from a 10.000 tons/year digestate. There is from a technological point of view no maximum size. The installation is designed to operate at relative low temperatures, typical waste heat can be reused from biogas plants. In proper maintained conditions there are no emissions to the environment, thus using the AMFER reduces nitrogen emission from manure storages. The AMFER can also be used to control the nitrogen levels in the digester, which is required when feeding nitrogen rich streams. The AMFER process can be used as pasteurisation. Farm-scale installations are containerized. | https://nutriman.net/sites/default/files/2021-07/ID-455-Training%20material.pdf | Liquid ammonium nitrate (AN) or liquid ammonium sulphate (AS) | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | 7 | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_454 | from 1 to 500 t/hour | Static | 9 | Yes | No | High | Low | EU Southwest | The Netherlands; EU 27, Africa | 1) These fertilizer products are currently prior to market introduction (TRL 8). These recovered nitrogen products are expected to be listed as ‘mineral fertilizer’ from 2021 for the whole EU. 2) Capital expense (CAPEX): EUR 350.000 for the 10.000 tons/year. Operational expense (OPEX): EUR 50.000/year. 3) The company Colsen owns the IP rights for the AMFER. | Colsen https://www.colsen.nl/ | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_455 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_454 | NUTRIMAN / project completed | Colsen is an innovative company, having been working on innovative solutions in the field of water, energy and the environment for 30 years such as: water purification, manure processing, N-recovery, P-recovery with struvite, digestate treatment, nitrogen stripping. The company has implemented its technologies, among others, in the Netherlands, Spain, South Africa, Italy and Poland. There is no information about fertilizer products. | IUNG | |||||||||||||||||||
T7 | Ammonium sulphate from digestate by "Biogas Bree" process | Summary: Technology for N recovery as dried digestate and ammonium sulphate from solid fraction digestate with "Biogas Bree" chemical scrubbing of exhaust air during drying process | Agricultural Biomasses | Municipal Biowaste | Agricultural Biomasses: animal manure, energy maize Municipal Biowaste: organic waste | Agricultural Biomasses: digestate (solid and liquid fraction) Municipal Biowaste: digestate (solid and liquid fraction) | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | 85.000 tonnes of biomass per year | (1) Post-digestion separation of the solid and liquid fractions and drying of the solid fraction. (2) Capturing ammonia from the exhaust air (from the drying process) by a chemical air scrubber.(3) In the chemical scrubber, sulfuric acid is added to the wash water to remove ammonia from the exhaust air. (4) The acidic wash water (flowing continuously over the filter package) reacts with ammonia in the air - salt (ammonium sulfate) is formed. (5) Wash water saturated with ammonium sulfate is drained from the system - creating space for new water and acid. | Technological elements of the recuperation proces at Biogas Bree site are: belt dryer/fluidized bed dryer, chemical air scrubbe, silo for ammonium sulphate. Post-digestion of the manure-input line consists of separating in a solid and liquid fraction and submission to a drying process solid fraction (with heat from a biogas fueled CHP) in a belt dryer. The end product of the co-digestion and drying of the digestate is dried digestate and exhaust air. This exhaust air is saturated with ammonia which is being captured by a chemical air scrubber. In a chemical scrubber, acid is added to the washing water to remove the ammonia and a part of the odour compounds from the exhaust air. Water, acidified with sulphuric acid (96 % or 98 %), flows continuously over the filter package. This humidifies the filter. The acidic washing water reacts with the ammonia in the air. A salt (ammonium sulphate) is formed. That salt remains in the washing water which means that the outgoing air contains less ammonia. Per kilogram recuperated ammonia 1,5 litres of sulphuric acid is needed. When the washing water is saturated with ammonium sulphate it is discharged - making room for new water and acid to form new washing water. About 30 litres of ammonium sulphate is produced/discharged per kilogram of ammonia that is recuperated from the exhaust air. The specific model Biogas Bree handles is a modified scrubber using the ammonium sulphate solution as a first-step dust washer. Ammonia sulphate has no physical impurities and is free of pathogens, insect larvae and weed seeds, may have a relatively low pH. It is a closed process implying no further emissions occur. As it removes the ammonium the NH3 emission for the digestate or manure is indeed negligible. This technology offers solutions for intensive husbandry and manure/substrate drying in any EU region. | Liquid ammonia sulphate | energy in the form of biogas, digestate | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | 8.0 | 10.0 | 700-900 t/y ammonium sulphate; 5.000 t/y solid fraction; 45.000 t/y liquid fraction digestate; 1.500 t/y dried digestate | Static | 9 | Yes | No | High | Low | EU Southwest | Belgium / Flanders - Flemish Region; EU 27 | 1) At least an environmental license/permit for installing this technology will have to be asked & obtained from the local authorities. This legislation and authority depends on the specific EU region. For example in Flanders an ‘omgevingsvergunning’ will be required from the Department of Environment, taking into account BAT (best available technologies) guidelines and recommendations of other advisory bodies. One important requirement for obtaining the permit (for chemical air scrubber) is the ammonia removal of min 70% from the exhaust air. 2) CAPEX: Dryer 1.200.000 € - Chemical air scrubber 120.000 € - Biobed 100 000 € - Silo ammonium sulphate 10.000 €. Totalling: 7€ cost/ton (waste) (economic industrial scale). 3) In Flanders these ammonia fertilisers require no certification, derogation, nor manure transport documents. In Holland also they can, conditionally, be traded as mineral fertilisers. On a European level the Nitrates Directive defines this product as animal manure and not as mineral N fertiliser yet. Therefore the product has to fulfil requirements of animal manure. A European project Safemanure is ongoing to attempt validation EU-wide as a mineral fertiliser - information from 2021, to be clarified. | Biogas Bree BV https://biogasbree.be/ | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_273 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_274 | NUTRIMAN / project completed | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||||
T8 | Ammonium sulphate by VP-Hobe process | Technology for N recovery as mineral concentrate, ammonia water and ammonium sulphate from manure/digestate by VP-Hobe manure and digestate valorisation system | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: livestock manure and slurry | Agricultural Biomasses: digestate of cattle manure, pig manure or co-fermentation | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | The capacity of the technology is scalable: 50.000, 125.000, 250.000 ton input/year | (1) Separation manure in a flotation unit and in a belt filter press to the liquid and solid fraction. (The solid fraction is dried on a belt dryer.) (2) Concentration of the liquid fraction reverse osmosis (RO) process (3) De-watering the RO-concentrate in an evaporator. (4) Removal of ammonia from flowing liquid stream by stripping and concentrated into NH3-water. (5) Futher production of potassium concentrate and ammonium sulphate solution by scrubbing the vapour coming out of the evaporator with sulphuric acid. (6) Cleaning of condensate from the Evaporator/ Stripper/ Scrubber (ESS) unit and RO permeate in the RO water polisher and the ion exchanger (RO-IE) for discharge into surface waters. | The VP-Hobe manure and digestate valorisation system is a robust proven technology operated at own processing plants. Contains the following modules : (1) Solid-Liquid-separation: Separation takes place in a flotation unit and in a belt filter press. The input manure is separated into a solid and a liquid fraction. A flocculant is added. In the flotation system, small air bubbles bring particles to the surface of the tank where it forms a layer of sludge. This layer is scraped off and de-watered in the belt filter press into a solid fraction of 30% dry matter (DM). The solid fraction is dried on a belt dryer to 90% DM. (2) Reverse Osmosis (RO): A RO processes the liquid fraction (1,7% DM) into a retentate concentrated-N/K2O product (3,4% DM) and a permeate product to be processed in the clean water production. (3) Evaporator/ Stripper/ Scrubber (ESS): The RO-concentrate or thin fraction will be further de-watered in an evaporator. The liquid passes through a falling film evaporator with mechanical vapour recompression. Heating the liquid in the evaporator causes water to evaporate. A vacuum lowers the boiling point, less energy is needed than when evaporating at normal atmospheric pressure. The ammonia in the incoming liquid is removed from the product flow by stripping and concentration into NH3-water (14% N). The evaporator further produces a potassium concentrate (25% DM and 6,5% K2O) and ammonium sulphate solution by scrubbing the vapour coming out of the evaporator with sulphuric acid. (4) Clean water production (RO-IE): The condensate from ESS unit and the permeate from the RO is cleaned in the RO water polisher and the ion exchanger (RO-IE) to achieve the right quality for discharge into surface waters. The VP-Hobe process achieves lowest possible operational costs (energy, additives) while produces several fertilizers, e.g. mineral- and potassium-concentrate, NH3-water, Ammonium sulphate, as well as clean dischargeable water. The products are hygienic and free from salmonella and E-coli. | Liquid ammonium sulphate (PFC 1(C)), NH3-water (PFC 1(C)), Liquid mineral concentrate (PFC 3(B)), Liquid K concentrate (PFC 3(A)) | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | PFC 3(B): Inorganic soil improver | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | Liquid ammonium sulphate | 3.4 | 7.0 | 7.9 | Static | 9 | Yes | No | High | Low | EU Southwest | The Netherlands also Belgium, Germany and other | 1) Authority permit not necessary for local distribution. This product is a potential RENURE fertilizer which means that application will no longer be defined as livestock manure in the Nitrates Directive. This means application will no longer be limited to 170 kg N/ha. /The nitrogen in product liquid K concentrate is still considered livestock manure as defined in the Nitrates Directive. 2) The presence of sulfur in the product can be limiting aplication on grass. 3) Geographical area: max 30 kms from processing plant (for liquid ammonium sulfate) or 200 kms area around processing plant (for liquid NK concentrate). 4) Due to the organic origin of the fertilizer, nutrient content may vary change if changes the quality of the inputs (for liquid mineral concentrate). | VP-HoBe http://www.vp-hobe.nl/ | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_669 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_1529 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_1527 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_1504 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_1528 | NUTRIMAN / project completed | IUNG | |||||||||||||||||
T9 | Liquid ammonium sulphate or ammonium nitrate from digestate or slurries by "Circular Values" process | Technology for N recovery as liquid ammonium sulphate or ammonium nitrate starting from separated liquid slurry with "Circular Values" stripping and scrubbing process with H2SO4 or HNO3 | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: manure slurry | Agricultural Biomasses: digestate | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | Static units are profitable when the farmer has production of 4000 kg N and more (>1000 tons manure/digestate). For lower than 4000 kg a mobile solution can fit. | (1) Separation of the liquid fraction from the slurry or digestate for further treatment, (2) NH3 stripping and mineral nitrogen gasification by blowing air through the liquid fraction of the slurry or digestate while simultaneously increasing the temperature or pH, (3) washing the NH3-filled air with acidified water (HNO3 or H2SO4) (scrubbing) to re-capture ammonium in liquid form (ammonium sulfate with H2SO4 or ammonium nitrate with HNO3). | This technology offers an extraction of nitrogen from a variety of possible waste streams (liquid slurries, liquid fraction digestate, discharged water,..). First the slurry, digestate or discharged water is separated for further treatment of the liquid fraction. Then the stripping is performed by blowing air through the liquid fraction of the slurry or digestate while increasing temperature or pH (e.g. with CaOH) which will gasify the mineral nitrogen (NH3). Afterwards the NH3-filled air will be washed with acidified (HNO3 or H2SO4) water (scrubbing) to capture the ammonium again in liquid form (ammonium sulfate from H2SO4 or ammonium nitrate from HNO3). Both cold and hot stripping (10-70 degrees Celsius) are possible. The process can be remotely monitored and controlled. The recovery capacity is up to 85% of the ammonium-N from the slurry or digestate. Furthermore, since it is a closed process no further emissions occur. As it removes the ammonium the NH3 emission for the digestate or manure is reduced. This process produces a nitrogen fertilizer free from pathogens, insect larvae and weed seeds. | https://nutriman.net/sites/default/files/2020-02/265_INFO%20SHEET-TECHNOLOGY_Circular%20Values.pdf | Liquid ammonium sulphate or liquid ammonium nitrate | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | Liquid ammonium sulphate | ≥7.0 | 7 | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_266 | Static/Mobile | 9 | Yes | No | High | Low | EU Southwest | The Netherlands | 1) In Flanders these ammonia fertilisers require no certification, derogation, nor manure transport documents. In Holland they can, conditionally, be traded as mineral fertilisers. On a European level the Nitrates Directive defines this product as animal manure and not as mineral N fertiliser yet. Therefore the product has to fulfil requirements of animal manure. A European project Safemanure is ongoing to attempt validation EU-wide as a mineral fertiliser. 2) This technology is for intensive husbandry in any EU region. 3) Farmlevel solution or mobile unit for several farmers in the area. 4) Static units can be profitable when the farmer has production of 4000 kg N and more (>1000 tons manure/digestate), for lower than 4000 kg a mobile solution can fit. 5) At least an environmental license/permit for installing this technology will have to be obtained from the local authorities. This legislation and authority depends on the specific EU region. For example in Flanders an ‘omgevingsvergunning’ will be required from the Department of Environment, taking into account BAT (best available technologies) guidelines and recommendations of other advisory bodies. 6) Capital Expenditure for economical industrial scale: 100 000-265 000€. | Circular Values Industries https://circularvalues.eu/ | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_265 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_266 | NUTRIMAN / project completed | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||||
T10 | Liquid ammonium sulphate or ammonium nitrate from digestate or slurries by "Circular Values" process | Technology for N recovery as liquid ammonium sulphate or ammonium nitrate starting from separated liquid slurry with "Circular Values" stripping and scrubbing process with H2SO4 or HNO3 | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: manure slurry | Agricultural Biomasses: digestate | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | Static units are profitable when the farmer has production of 4000 kg N and more (>1000 tons manure/digestate). For lower than 4000 kg a mobile solution can fit. | (1) Separation of the liquid fraction from the slurry or digestate for further treatment, (2) NH3 stripping and mineral nitrogen gasification by blowing air through the liquid fraction of the slurry or digestate while simultaneously increasing the temperature or pH, (3) washing the NH3-filled air with acidified water (HNO3 or H2SO4) (scrubbing) to re-capture ammonium in liquid form (ammonium sulfate with H2SO4 or ammonium nitrate with HNO3). | This technology offers an extraction of nitrogen from a variety of possible waste streams (liquid slurries, liquid fraction digestate, discharged water,..). First the slurry, digestate or discharged water is separated for further treatment of the liquid fraction. Then the stripping is performed by blowing air through the liquid fraction of the slurry or digestate while increasing temperature or pH (e.g. with CaOH) which will gasify the mineral nitrogen (NH3). Afterwards the NH3-filled air will be washed with acidified (HNO3 or H2SO4) water (scrubbing) to capture the ammonium again in liquid form (ammonium sulfate from H2SO4 or ammonium nitrate from HNO3). Both cold and hot stripping (10-70 degrees Celsius) are possible. The process can be remotely monitored and controlled. The recovery capacity is up to 85% of the ammonium-N from the slurry or digestate. Furthermore, since it is a closed process no further emissions occur. As it removes the ammonium the NH3 emission for the digestate or manure is reduced. This process produces a nitrogen fertilizer free from pathogens, insect larvae and weed seeds. | https://nutriman.net/sites/default/files/2020-02/265_INFO%20SHEET-TECHNOLOGY_Circular%20Values.pdf | Liquid ammonium sulphate or liquid ammonium nitrate | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | Liquid ammonium nitrate | ≤ 18.0 | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_266 | Static/Mobile | 9 | Yes | No | High | Low | EU Southwest | The Netherlands | 1) In Flanders these ammonia fertilisers require no certification, derogation, nor manure transport documents. In Holland they can, conditionally, be traded as mineral fertilisers. On a European level the Nitrates Directive defines this product as animal manure and not as mineral N fertiliser yet. Therefore the product has to fulfil requirements of animal manure. A European project Safemanure is ongoing to attempt validation EU-wide as a mineral fertiliser. 2) This technology is for intensive husbandry in any EU region. 3) Farmlevel solution or mobile unit for several farmers in the area. 4) Static units can be profitable when the farmer has production of 4000 kg N and more (>1000 tons manure/digestate), for lower than 4000 kg a mobile solution can fit. 5) At least an environmental license/permit for installing this technology will have to be obtained from the local authorities. This legislation and authority depends on the specific EU region. For example in Flanders an ‘omgevingsvergunning’ will be required from the Department of Environment, taking into account BAT (best available technologies) guidelines and recommendations of other advisory bodies. 6) Capital Expenditure for economical industrial scale: 100.000-265.000€. | Circular Values Industries https://circularvalues.eu/ | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_265 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_266 | NUTRIMAN / project completed | IUNG | |||||||||||||||||||
T11 | PK fertilizer from the ash of poultry manure with "BMC Moerdijk" thermochemical process | Technology for P recovery as PK fertilizer from the ash of poultry manure with "BMC Moerdijk" thermochemical process | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: poultry manure | Agricultural Biomasses: ash from poultry manure | CMC 13: Thermal oxidation materials and their derivatives | 430.000 t/year | Burning poultry manure/poultry litter; hydrated ash of incinerated poultry manure; powder could be milled and pelletized/granulated in further preparation steps. | BMC Moerdijk thermochemical process is a mono incineration process with poultry manure/poultry litter, witch aims to recover nutrients and to convert poultry manure into a more concentrate inorganic fertilizer. The PK fertilizer is derived from hydrated ash of incinerated poultry manure. After the process, powder (ash) could be milled and pelletized/granulated in further preparation steps if desired. The fertiliser has a neutralizing value due to the presence of hydrated burnt lime.The product has a low content of contaminants, e.g. heavy metals (Cd, As, Pb), no organic compounds and is free of pathogens. | no data | Ash from poultry manure | Electricity (292 MWh gross) | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | 4.37 | 10 | 14.29 | 3.01 | 2.8 | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_399 | 57.000 t/year | Static | 9 | Yes | No | High | Low | EU Southwest | The Netherlands, EU 27 | 1) The construction of the power plant is subjected to regional regulations for construction law and the immission protection law. | BMC Moerdijk BV https://www.bmcmoerdijk.nl/nl/ | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_399 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_401 | NUTRIMAN / project completed | IUNG | |||||||||||||||
T12 | Technology for P recovery as PK fertilizer from the ash from olive stones and the pomace pulp with B-Ferst project technology | Technology for P recovery as PK fertilizer from the ash from olive stones and the pomace pulp | Agricultural Biomasses | agricultural processing residues | ash from biomass combustion | CMC 2: Plants, plant parts or plant extracts | Thermal decomposition, granulation | M-BBx-0 | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | 6 | Yes | Not known | High | EU Southwest | Spain | https://bferst.eu/project/ | B-Ferst | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
T13 | Technology for P recovery as organo mineral fertilizer with microbiological coating by B-Ferst project technology | Agricultural Biomasses | agricultural processing residues | composted crop residues | CMC 2: Plants, plant parts or plant extracts | composting plant residues, granulation, coating with biodegradable coating agent | OM-0-MPBx | PFC 1(B) Organo-mineral fertilizer | 8.1 - 9.6 | 6 | Yes | Not known | High | EU Southeast | Spain | FERTIBERIA CORPORATE SL (Madrid, Spain) | https://bferst.eu/project/ | B-Ferst | IUNG | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
T14 | Anaerobic digestion | Municipal Biowaste | Agricultural Biomasses | Municipal Biowaste | Municipal Biowste | Municipal Biowaste | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | 5,000 tonne dry matter/year | Anaerobic digestion to convert spent mushroom substrate and other agri-food wastes into biogas. Besides electricity, they also obtain solid and liquid fertilizers. | After harvesting the oyster mushroom fruiting bodies, spent mushroom substrate (SMS) is transported into the biogas plant and mixed with other residues (poultry manure, marc, expired food, oil based mud, etc.). 110 m3 biogas can be produced per tonne of input material (dry matter content: 50-60%). The plant can process maximum 10 thousand tonnes of biomass per year, 1-1,2 million m3 biogas is produced per year from this amount of biomass. Biogas is converted into electrical energy (2,000-2,400 MWh/year) by burning it in a gas engine CHP (combined heat and power). Biogas digestate, the by-product of the anaerobic digestion process is separated: the solid phase (containing 3 w % nitrogen) is used as biofertilizer by local farmers and the liquid phase is stored in an open digestate storage pond A part of this liquid material is used for wetting the input material of the biogas plant and the rest is placed on agricultural fields as a liquid biofertilizer. | Pilze Nagy solid and liquid fertiliser | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 3 | 50-60 | 10000t/year | Static | 9 | Yes | No | High | Medium | EU Central | Hungary | http://pleurotus.hu/biogas Power4Bio Catalogue – Pilze-Nagy factsheet | Business Model - MainstreamBIO Digital Toolkit | MAINSTREAMBIO / project completed | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||||||
T15 | Aerobic conversion | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: broiler farm manure | Industrial side-streams: The ashes of incinerated dead poultry | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | CMC 2: Plants, plant parts or plant extracts | Feedstock streams (dead poultry and broiler farm manure) are collected from the farms by dedicated personnel and transported by special vehicles to the company’s treatment plants. The ashes of incinerated dead poultry are combined with broiler farm manure and other organic wastes. The mix undergoes aerobic digestion, becoming stable, high-quality, and safe to use as recyclable organic and biological solid fertilizer. An aerobic conversion process relies on microorganisms that thrive under aerobic conditions i.e. where plenty of oxygen is available and a sufficient amount of feedstock is present. An example is composting which is a microbiological process in which heterogeneous organic material is oxidised and broken down into compost, CO2, H2O and heat in a set-up where air passes through a heap (pile, mound) of porous, solid material. Although composting can occur spontaneously in the field (for example in mown verge grass), the process referred to here is controlled composting. It is often carried out with forced ventilation (through a ventilator) in a container, hall or in the open air. The aim of composting is to produce a final product that is stable, free of pathogens and germinable weed seeds. The composting process proceeds through three phases: i) mesophilic 10-45°C, ii) thermophilic 45-70°C and iii) maturation (curing). As composting is a kind of biological combustion process, heat is emitted which can also be used. The heat also causes water to evaporate and the material becomes drier, and many pathogens and seeds of weeds are exterminated due to the high temperature (70°C). The process takes a few weeks. | AGROSYN | water vapor | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 70-80 | 4.6 | 1.31-2.18 | 3.33-5 | 2.14-2.86 | 0.9 | https://www.agromarket-hellas.gr/en/c/Granular_Fertilizers-897/Agromarket-Hellas-Kolovos-1/AGROSYN_MANURE_25kg-1312 | 9 | Yes | No | Low | Low | EU Southeast | Greece | https://www.pindos-apsi.gr/ https://www.facebook.com/agrosynmegara/?locale=nb_NO | https://www.pindos-apsi.gr/ https://www.facebook.com/agrosynmegara/?locale=nb_NO | MAINSTREAM BIO/ project completed | IUNG | |||||||||||||||||||
T16 | Aerobic conversion | Manure from goat and sheep. | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses | Manure from goat and sheep husbandry is fed into an aerobic digestor. The organic matter is subjected to high temperatures (> 70ºC). The obtained liquid fertilizer undergoes several quality controls to confirm it complies with the quality standards before being commercialized. An example is composting which is a microbiological process in which heterogeneous organic material is oxidised and broken down into compost, CO2, H2O and heat in a set-up where air passes through a heap (pile, mound) of porous, solid material. Although composting can occur spontaneously in the field (for example in mown verge grass), the process referred to here is controlled composting. It is often carried out with forced ventilation (through a ventilator) in a container, hall, or open air. Composting aims to produce a stable final product, free of pathogens and germinable weed seeds. The composting process proceeds through three phases: i) mesophilic 10-45°C, ii) thermophilic 45-70°C and iii) maturation (curing). As composting is a kind of biological combustion process, heat is emitted, which can also be used. The heat also causes water to evaporate and the material becomes drier, and many pathogens and seeds of weeds are exterminated due to the high temperature (70°C). The process takes a few weeks. | PEDRIN (Producto Líquido Natural Pedrín) | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 70 | 4.1 | 2.5 | 2.92 | 1000 | https://organicospedrin.com/producto-liquido-natural-pedrin/ | 9 | Yes | No | High | Low | EU Southeast | Spain | https://organicospedrin.com/producto-liquido-natural-pedrin/ https://www.facebook.com/OrganicosPedrinSL/?locale=es_LA | https://mainstreambio-digital-toolkit.eu/catalogue_business_model/1689318638565x381442550259800600?lang=en_us&intro=yes&solution=business_models&business=tech&repository=audio_visual&tech=biochemical&technology=feedstock | MAINSTREAM BIO/ project completed | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||||||||
T17 | Insect-based bioconversation | Insect-based bioconversion also known as insect farming is based on the selection of insect species e.g. Black Soldier Fly (BSF) larvae, house fly maggots, mealworms, and grasshoppers-crickets and different rearing substrates. The main benefits of this conversion process are reduction of waste by producing high quality protein (mainly for animal feed) and the extraction of products such as oil, natural fertilizer and chitin. Black soldier fly larvae are grown in crates on rack cupboards and fed with agricultural and food residue streams. Technology is simply scalable to the amounts of vegetable residue streams available, whether smaller or larger quantities. Larvae are harvested, dried & used as feed (when grown on GMP+ food safety assured side streams) or further refined to a protein rich fraction and lipids. Larvae and protein fraction contain essential amino acids which are low in feeds produced from plants. During harvesting the insects are sieved out of their remaining feed medium, the fine fraction (left-overs, debris, etc.) is sold as fertilizer (compost). Also the substrate residue (skins of worms) remaining after pressing of the worms can be used as fertilizer. | Agricultural Biomasses | Industrial side-streams | Agricultural Biomasses: agricultural processing residues | Industrial side-streams: food industry by-products | CMC 2: Plants, plant parts or plant extracts | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | Black soldier fly is grown and produced in crates on rack cupboards and fed with agricultural and food residue streams. Technology is simply scalable to the amounts of vegetable residue streams available, whether smaller or larger quantities. Larvae are harvested, dried & used as feed (when grown on GMP + side streams) or further refined to a protein-rich fraction and lipids. Larvae and protein fraction contain essential amino acids that are low in plant feeds. During harvesting the insects are sieved out of their remaining feed medium, and the fine fraction (left-overs, debris, etc.) is sold as fertilizer (compost). Also, the substrate residue (skins of worms) remaining after pressing the worms can be used as fertilizer. | Agri-food residues are revalorised into feed and fertilizers by insect bioconversion. | Bestico Insect Frass - organic fertilizer | Fuel (bioethanol, biogas), Heat, Electrical power | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 45 | 4 | 3 | 2.1 | 0.3 | 0.7 | https://shop.mobiusfarms.com/products/insect-frass | 400-600t/year | Static/Mobile | 8 | Yes | Yes | Medium | Low | EU Southwest | Netherlands | https://biocycleindo.com/products/fertilizer/ https://www.bestico.eu/products https://www.tokopedia.com/palestari/pupuk-kandang-bestico-insect-frass-40kg-murah | https://mainstreambio-digital-toolkit.eu/catalogue_business_model/1689323287114x994799025823664500?lang=en_us&intro=yes&solution=business_models&business=tech&repository=audio_visual&tech=biochemical&technology=feedstock&resources=audio_visual | MAINSTREAMBIO / project completed | Bestico Insect Frass is a premium organic fertilizer produced through the cultivation of Black Soldier Flies. This product harnesses the by-products of fly cultivation to create high-quality organic fertilizer that benefits your plants. | IUNG | ||||||||||||||
T18 | Anaerobic digestion - Biogas plant manufacturer - falily company | HoSt - solutions for biogas technology | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses : Fresh cattle manure | Agricultural Biomasses : Sewage sludges, poultry manure, grass, cereal straw, agricultural residues | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | CMC 2: Plants, plant parts or plant extracts | The manure is anaerobically digested in the digester and converted into biogas (57 % v/ v CH4). In the biogas upgrading system, it is upgraded to biomethane (green gas or renewable gas, 89 % v/v CH4). Subsequently, the product gas with natural gas quality is fed directly into the natural gas network. In order to reduce the production costs, the company generates its own electrical energy and sells the surplus energy. One of the by-products of the process is biogas digestate. This material, being rich in nitrogen, is used as fertilizer by local farmers. Other Input Materials are heat and power. | Anaerobic digestion is a series of biological process in which micro-organisms break down organic material under oxygen-free conditions. This usually refers to methane fermentation in which the final product is biogas, a mixture of methane and carbon dioxide. Anaerobic digestion therefore is a form of fermentation. The recalcitrant part remains and is called digestate. The process takes place in stirred and heated reactors, often with a volume of more than 1,000 m3, and the conversion of solid organic substances into biogas usually takes one month. There are basically two subtypes of digestion (next to the already mentioned main types, co- and mono-digestion): namely wet and dry digestion. Wet digestion means that a big basin with a stirring mechanism (mixing the slurry) is filled with a liquid mixture. Dry digestion is suitable for fibrous/stalky materials, that are difficult to digest in a slurry. An example of a feedstock suitable for dry digestion is grass or straw. | digestate fertilizer | biomethane | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 9 | Yes | No | Medium | Low | EU Southwest | The Netherlands | https://www.host-bioenergy.com/solutions/biogas-plants/organic-waste-manure-biogas-plants/ | https://mainstreambio-digital-toolkit.eu/catalogue_business_model/1689319184228x587201994388951000?lang=en_us&intro=yes&solution=business_models&business=tech&repository=audio_visual&tech=biochemical&technology=feedstock | MAINSTREAM BIO / project completed | IUNG | |||||||||||||||||||||||
T19 | Biobased fertilizers (BBF) obtained by thermomechanical-chemical (TMC) fractionation | Thermomechanochemical fractionation of fish by products by twin-screw extrusion for the production of biobased fertilizers (BBF) | Blue Biomasses | Blue Biomasses: fish by-products (viscera, bones, flesh, heads) | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | The process scheme includes the following technological units: (i) grinding, (ii) continuous TMC fractionation by twin-screw extrusion / enzymatic hydrolysis, (iii) downstream processing (separation , concentration). | Thermomechanochemical (TMC) fractionation by twin-screw extrusion is a versatile and compact process, working at low liquid/solid ratios and able to provide simultaneously solid and liquid fractions. The use of TMC process for fertilizers production from fish by-products is an innovative approach which makes it possible to recover not only fertilizers (proteic fractions) but also highly valuable lipids to reach a Zero-waste process. The process scheme includes the following technological units: (i) grinding technologies, (ii) continuous TMC fractionation by twin-screw extrusion / enzymatic hydrolysis, (iii) downstream processing (separation technologies, concentration). Trials were achieved using an Evolum HT53 (Clextral) at a feeding rate of 150-200 kg/hr in by-product i.e. heads and fishbones from Steelhead truit. Working at 200 kg/h (65 kg/hr DM), the complete process provides 89 kg/hr solid BBF (25 kg/h DM ; 57% Proteins/DM), 129 kg/hr aqueous proteic hydrolysate (16 kg/h DM ; 61% Proteins/DM) and 24 kg/hr lipids. | Solid biobased fertilizers (BBF), aqueous proteic hydrolysate, lipids | Working at 200 kg/h (65 kg/hr DM), the complete process provides 89 kg/hr solid BBF (25 kg/h DM ; 57% Proteins/DM), 129 kg/hr aqueous proteic hydrolysate (16 kg/h DM ; 61% Proteins/DM) and 24 kg/hr lipids. | Static | 5 | No | Not known | High | Medium | EU Southwest | France | 1) SWOT analysis– Atlantic sea https://sea2landproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/SEA2LAND_9.4-Practice-Abstracts-M18.pdf (p. 29) | CATAR, Centre Régional d’Innovation et de Transfert de Technologies Agroressources https://catar.critt.net/le-catar/ | https://sea2landproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/SEA2LAND_9.4-Practice-Abstracts-M18.pdf (p. 63-65) https://sea2landproject.eu/the-atlantic-area/ | SEA2LAND / project completed | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||
T20 | Anaerobic digestion | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses : livestock manure, agricultural residues and slaughterhouse waste | Agricultural Biomasses | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | Anaerobic digestion to convert livestock manure, agricultural residues and slaughterhouse waste into biogas for electricity and heat production. A portion is converted into biofuel for transport. Coupled to waste reduction, there is environmentally friendly produced biogas, electricity and heat that replace commercial fuels. Moreover, use of commercial fossil-dependent fertilizers is reduced by applying the produced biofertilizer. | Manure, agricultural and slaughter waste are collected from surrounding producers. All feedstock is derived to an anaerobic digester to produce biogas at BBAB (Biogas Brålanda AB). Part of said biogas is converted into biofuel (biomethane). GBAB (Grönt Brånsle i Sverige AB) distributes and sells a portion of biogas for private and public traffic in Trollhättan. The remaining biogas is converted into electricity and heat. | Bio fertylizer | Energy, Heat, Biofuel | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | Static | 9 | Yes | Not known | High | EU North | Sweden | https://biogasbralanda.se/ | mainstreambio-digital-toolkit.eu/catalogue_business_model/1689321099241x772615588752109300?lang=en_us&intro=yes&solution=business_models&business=tech&repository=audio_visual&tech=biochemical&technology=feedstock | MAINSTREAMBIO / project completed | IUNG | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||
T21 | Biorefinery using the leftovers from seafood (mollusc and fish) | Producing advanced bio-based fertilisers (BBF) from fisheries wastes by enzymatic hydrolysis, chemical extraction, composting and pyrolysis | Blue Biomasses | Blue Biomasses: fish and shellfish by-products wastes from the processing of mollusc/mussels ( hard fraction - shells) and fish wastes (soft fraction - viscera, bones, heads, etc.) | Blue Biomasses: compost, hydrolyzed waste, biochar | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | Valorise the different fractions from seafood processing industries by wet separation, enzymatic hydrolysis, chemical extraction, composting and pyrolysis . | Mollusc waste management requires a first of all separation step to split hard (shells) and soft/organic fraction (e.g. adding water and then using a shredding pump before separating them by gravity). Once dried and milled, shells could be used as a soil liming agent. Due to high protein content in the organic fraction of mollusc and fish waste, protein hydrolysates (FPH) are obtained through enzymatic hydrolysis carried out in a 100-L pilot reactor, followed by centrifugation to separate the raw FPH from the solid residue (bones, not hydrolysed substrate, etc) and by evaporation to concentrate the liquid stream. FPH could be used as a biostimulant for the agriculture sector or as high-quality N-fertiliser in combination with chitin that is previously extracted from crustacean shell. The solid organic residue could be further valorised by composting and/or pyrolysis. The addition of biochar to the compost substrate increases the composting efficiency by accelerating organic waste decomposition, reducing air pollution and GHG emission, and allows to obtain a value-added product (biochar-compost blend). Active composting is performed in an adiabatic cylindrical reactor (operating volume of 100 L) with forced aeration. Maturation phase follows in a static reactor with manual turning and final sieving is performed to obtain a mature biochar-compost composite. | https://sea2landproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/SEA2LAND_9.4-Practice-Abstracts-M18.pdf (p.47) | Organic N-fertiliser (protein hydrolysates with chitin) (PFC 1(A)), biochar-compost composite (PFC 3(A), soil liming agent for acidic soil (PFC 2) | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | PFC 2 Liming material | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | Static | 5 | No | Not known | High | Medium | EU Southwest | Italy | 1) SWOT analysis - Adriatic sea https://sea2landproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/SEA2LAND_9.4-Practice-Abstracts-M18.pdf (p. 27, 39) 2) all side streams must meet the condition of being waste (Regulation 2008/98/CE) and shall constitute part of a fertiliser productcompliant Regulation 2019/1009 | UNIVPM - UNIVERSITÀ POLITECNICA DELLE MARCHE https://www.univpm.it/Entra/ | https://sea2landproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/SEA2LAND_9.4-Practice-Abstracts-M18.pdf (p. 45-51) https://wweelab.simau.univpm.it/sea2land https://sea2landproject.eu/the-adriatic-sea-case/ | SEA2LAND / project completed | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||||||||
T22 | Compost from green waste and digested mixed-waste by "ACEA Pinerolese" process | Technology for N&P recovery as compost starting from green waste and pre-digested mixed waste with "ACEA Pinerolese" anaerobic digestion and composting process | Municipal Biowaste | Municipal Biowaste (municipal organic wastes) | Municipal Biowaste: digestate (de-hydrated effluent from the anaerobic digestion of organic fraction of municipal solid waste, green residue from separate urban collection and dehydrated effluent from the wastewater treatment plant) | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | 60 000 t/year of organic waste 20 000 t/year of green waste (the composting plant) | volumetric reductions and mechanical selections, diluting in water and preheating, the biological anaerobic digestion, handling of biomass, the extraction of the digestat bottom of the digester by gravity mixing, dehydrateing digestat, aerobic composting | Basis of the the process is an anaerobic biodigestion, which allows for obtaining two important resources: digestate for the production of quality compost and biogas, from which thermal and electric energy derives. The organic waste undergoes, in the first of all, a series of volumetric reductions and mechanical selections. The purified stream (without undesirable fractions - plastic and metals) is trasnferred to intermediate tanks, where the material is diluted in water and the material is preheated. After the preparation phase, the stream is pumped into the digesters, where the main phase of the process takes place: the biological anaerobic digestion. The process involves constant handling of biomass. The extraction of the sludge takes place from the conical bottom of the digester, by gravity mixing. Digested organic waste (digestate) it is dehydrated and then sent to the neighboring composting system. The biogas obtained from fermentation it is conveyed to a gasometer and temporarily stored. The water used in the process is partly recirculated, while the remaining portion is sent to the wastewater treatment plant. In the aerobic composting process, quality Floraviva compos is produced, the production of which uses de-hydrated digestate from the anaerobic digestion, of green residues from separate urban collection and dehydrated effluents from the wastewater treatment plant. | https://nutriman.net/sites/default/files/2019-10/Acea_florawiva_technology_1.PNG | Florawiva (compost) | biogas - thermal and electrical energy (3 engines Otto cycle - the total nominal power is 3 MW) waste water | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 31.1 | 2.4 | 1 | 1.08 | 24 | Static | 9 | Yes | No | High | Low | EU Southwest | Italy / province of Turin; UE 27 | 1) organic waste disposal, serving approximately 1 million inhabitants 2) the ACEA system consists of physical and logistical integration of several plants where each phase of purification is closely related to the next one (waste treatment, composting plant, landfill, sewage treatment plant) 3) ACEA process patented in 2002 | ACEA Pinerolese Industriale S.p.A. https://ambiente.aceapinerolese.it/ | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_209 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_210 | NUTRIMAN / project completed | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||
T23 | Compost from green waste and food wastes by "Biociclo" process | Technology for N&P recovery as compost starting from sludge, green waste and food residues with "BIOCICLO" aerobic digestion process | Municipal Biowaste | Municipal Biowaste: household food waste, restaurant food waste, green landscape waste (biowaste, food waste, green waste) (agro-industrial sludge, concentrated sewage, sewage sludge, wood waste) | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | 46.000 - 69.000 t/year | (1) Pre-treatment of the different waste fraction and mixing together in appropriate proportions. (2) Aerobic treatment / decomposition of waste (heaps) with a forced ventilation system. (3) Maturation in aerated boxes with a forced ventilation system. (4) Stabilization (curing ) phase - compost maturation in heaps. | The process of production is characterized by following stages: (1) Pre-treatment of the organic fraction with the separation of unwanted fractions (plastic, metals, etc.) using a "squeezer", shredding of cellulose wood waste, different waste materials (organic and plant) are mixed together in appropriate proportions. (2) Static heaps of mixed waste are ndergoes to aerobic treatment (accelerated bio-oxidation), inside aerated biocells through a forced ventilation system designed for both blowing and sucking air from the heaps; the duration of this stage is 14 days. (3) Maturation in aerated boxes in static heaps by means of a forced ventilation system designed for the sole insufflation of air into the heaps; the duration of this stage is about 33 days. (4) This is the stabilizes phase (known as a curing phase), which is characterized by the process of transforming organic matter into humic substances (humus).The final phase takes place in external covered stalls, where the material matures in heaps on for about 50 days. The duration of the biological transformation process to obtain the compost is 90 days and the accelerated phase of the process takes place in 7 biocells and subsequently in a controlled maturation phase in 28 ventilated boxes. The whole transformation process is managed by a remote control system. The air sucked in by the aerobic treatment department is purified, before being released into the atmosphere by a double abatement stage: scrubber (washing the air with water jets) and natural biofilter. The leachate deriving from the process and the run-off waters of the aprons are reused within the composting process and for the pretreatment of the organic fraction; the excess of the rain water is sent to the adjacent AQA biological purification plant. | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_261 https://www.biociclo.it/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/Rapporto-Ambientale-2019.pdf | BioComp/ BioVitae/ BioComPlus (compost) (various contents of heavy metals and Zn, Cu) | Energy (180.000-300.000 kWh/year) | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 28 | 2.5 | 0.87 | 1.67 | 70 | 15.000 - 22.000 t/year | Static | 9 | Yes | No | High | Low | EU Southwest | Italy | 1) The company has a production permit (waste processing permit) and an Integrated Environmental Permit. 2) Compost, like other organic soil improvers and organic fertilizers, is subject to compliance with the "nitrates directive" law (Legislative Decree No. 152/99 and Legislative Decree 152/06) which provides for its use with certain spatial, temporal and quantitative limitations. | Biociclo S.r.l. https://biociclo.it/ | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_261 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_260 https://biociclo.it/ | NUTRIMAN / project completed | The company’s website has environmental reports, but only until 2019. https://www.biociclo.it/il-nostro-bilancio-ambientale/ | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||
T24 | Compost from green waste by "IMOG" process | Technology for N&P recovery as green compost starting from green waste with "IMOG" composting windrow process including membrane and forced aeration | Municipal Biowaste | Municipal Biowaste: green landscape waste (from parks, gardens, lawns and road sides) | none | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | (1) shredding and mixing green waste, (2) arranging the pile with a membrane and forced aeration, (3) increasing the height of the pile, (4) rotating the pile, (5) sifting compost | Green composting refers to the controlled, biological aerobic breakdown and stabilisation of organic matter, (green waste) using a variety of microorganisms. Allowed input is selectively retrieved green waste (compostable, organic waste from gardens, parks and lawns). At IMOG green waste follows undergoes a 4-phase composting: (a) reduce (chip) and mix the green waste, (b) 5 weeks: set up compost heap on windrow with membrane and forced aeration, (c) 3 weeks: converting windrow to a higher pile (‘table’), (d) 3 weeks: conversion from table to table (rotation of the pile). Last stage is the sifting of the compost (0-15mm) with additional short storage (ad hoc maturation). Minimum requirements are at least 10 consecutive weeks at 45°C including at least 4 days at at least 60°C or at least 12 days at at least 55°C. In addition, minimum requirements must be met regarding the intensity of pile rotation and moisture monitoring. The temperatures achieved by microbiological activity allow for the purification of the final product. At the end of the maturation phase, the compost represents about ½ of the weight of the treated inputs.Percolate water is collected and purified and afterwards partly reused. The IMOG process recuperation technology uses a chipper, a crane, a wheel loader, a turner, membranes and a screen. Through a regular set-up of open air piles several (tens of) thousands of tons can be turned within 12 to 15 weeks into a quality compost usable in gardening and agriculture. | Compost | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 17-22 | 1.22-1.62 | 0.20-0.27 | 0.72-1.05 | 1.43-1.98 | 0.24-0.36 | 0.14-0.18 | 56-66 | 10.000 t/year (12.000 t/year - available capacity) | Static | 9 | Yes | No | Low | High | EU Southwest | Belgium / Flemish Region | 1) Required: appropriate amount of input material ("brown" and "green" organic waste), space for storing piles and appropriate machinery. 2) Capital Expenditure for economical industrial scale: 12€/ton. Operational Expenditure for economical industrial scale: 28€ /ton (data from 2021). 3) Typically an environmental license/permit for installing this technology will have to be asked & obtained from the local authorities. Environmental license categories classify green composting sites in class 3 (max 25m³ composting capacity), class 2 (between 25m³ and 2000 m³ capacacity) and class 1 (> 2000 m³ capacity). In Flanders an ‘omgevingsvergunning’ will be required from the Department of Environment, taking into account BAT (best available technologies) guidelines and recommendations of other advisory bodies. On the other hand, in Flanders farm composting is not considered as waste transformation nor submitted to legal compliancies (licensing, emissions, certification..….) if only own company-generated organic streams are used and the compost is solely used on own plots. If on the contrary ‘farm compost’ is also used outside of company plots then not only will its composition need to be conform with maximum levels of certain contaminants (heavy metals, organic contaminants) but also will it need to undergo a quality certification process by an appointed quality organisation. | IMGO https://www.imog.be/ | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_279 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_280 | NUTRIMAN / project completed | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||
T25 | Compost from green waste and pre-digested vegetable, fruit and garden wastes by "IOK Afvalbeheer" process | Technology for N&P recovery as compost starting from vegetable, fruit and garden wastes with "IOK Afvalbeheer" anaerobic digestion and composting process | Municipal Biowaste | Municipal Biowaste vegetable, fruit and garden wastes, kitchen waste, green landscape waste | Municipal Biowaste: digestate | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | (1) Waste is shredded, stripped of impurities (iron, glass, plastics), heated with steam and subjected to a dry thermophilic anaerobic digestation. (2) The minerale-rich digestate is mixed with green waste - intensive composting process. (3) The aerobic digestion takes place under controlled conditions (time, temperature and moisture, turning, forced aeration and/or increasing water content) - hygienisation of compost (4) The sieved matter further post-composts and matures, including further turning of the pilies. | Technological elements used by IOK Afvalbeheer process for the different anaerobic and aerobic digestio: Dranco dry thermophilic anaerobic digester, shredder and crane, paddle wheel, conveyor belts, drum sieves, CHP engines and membrane technology. Selectively retrieved waste is shredded, stripped of impurities (iron, glass, plastics), heated with steam and fed into a dry thermophilic anaerobic digester (OWS) that yields digestate and biogas which is partly used as a fuel for 2 CHP’s (combined heat and powermotors Jenbacher and MAN) in situ. The biogas is upgraded via membrane technology for gas grid injection. The minerale-rich digestate is mixed with (sieved, de-ironed and shredded) green waste in an intensive composting process. This aerobic digestion phase is a controlled (= measuring temperature and moist, turning, forced aeration, and/or increasing water content) transformation proces in, an open or closed environment, that mimics the natural conversion process from organic matter to humus in the soil (humification). This composting is a controlled proces lasting a minimum of 4 weeks with minimum 3 turns, after which sieves (16mm) are used to separate the compost from the overflow fraction (recirculating to shredder/start of composting process). To ensure hygienisation of the end product (compost) the following minimum temp/time-ratio’s are upheld and controlled: thermophile digestion of min 2 consecutive weeks >50°C, followed by min. 2 weeks composting at min. 45°C of which min. 4 days at min. 60°C or min. 12 days at min. 55°C. The sieved matter (<16mm) further post-composts and matures, including further turning of the pilies, outside for about 8 -10 weeks. The high temperature during the process means that compost is free of pathogens, insect larvae and weed seeds. | Compost | energy in the form of biogas | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | > 20 | 1.79-2.10 | 0.35-0.52 | 0.92-1.50 | 1.79-2.86 | 0.30-0.48 | 0,2-0,32 | 57-74 | https://nutriman.net/sites/default/files/2020-10/ID-271_Training_material_PL.pdf | 25.000 t/year | Static | 9 | Yes | No | High | Low | EU Southwest | Belgium / Flemish Region; EU 27 | 1) Typically an environmental license/permit for installing this technology will have to be asked & obtained from the local authorities. Environmental license categories classify composting sites in class 3 (max 25m³ composting capacity), class 2 (between 25m³ and 2000 m³ capacacity) and class 1 (> 2000 m³ capacity). In Flanders an ‘omgevingsvergunning’ will be required from the Department of Environment, taking into account BAT (best available technologies) guidelines and recommendations of other advisory bodies. 2) Total CAPEX of abovementioned machinery: 13.000.000 euro (incl. VAT and funding). | IOK Afvalbeheer https://www.iok.be/ | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_271 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_272 | NUTRIMAN / project completed | IUNG | |||||||||||||
T26 | Liquid and solid fraction digestate from manure and maize by "Agrogas" process | Technology for N&P recovery as liquid or dried digestates with "Agrogas" separation, drying, membrane filtration and/or reverse osmosis combined with post-treatment system | Agricultural Biomasses | Municipal Biowaste | Agricultural Biomasses: manure, organic wastes, energy maize Municipal Biowaste: household organic waste | Agricultural Biomasses: digestate | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | CMC 2: Plants, plant parts or plant extracts | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | Co-digestion + digestate posttreatments separation (of solid from liquid fraction), drying, membrane filtration (MBR) and reverse osmosis (RO) | The anaerobic digestion process is a natural process in which various microorganisms break down biodegradable organic material under anaerobic conditions and convert it (10-15%) into biogas and digestate (85-90%). Agrogas has two separate digestion and post-treatment lines: one purely vegetal proces line and one animal by products/manure proces line. Agrogas’ digestate fractions come through several mesophilic and thermophilic digesters. In the vegetal line: the (two times fermented) digestate is separated via a screw press into a liquid fraction and solid fraction. The liquid fraction of the vegetal line can be disposed on agricultural soils or is sometimes mixed with the hygienised liquid fraction of the animal process line. (Both types) liquid fractions can be further processed, namely a biological water treatment with membrane filtration (membrane bioreactor (MBR)) or reverse osmosis (RO). This MBR permeate or RO concentrate can undergo further evaporation in the thickener. In the animal line: the digestate is always secondary post-fermented themophilic (> 55°C) in a thermophilic post-digester. In the next step, the digestate is separated into a liquid and solid fraction via a sieve belt press.The solid fraction of the animal fermentation line is stored in a separate loading area for drying or further external processing. The liquid fraction of the hygienized digestate with manure is mostly further treated at the biological water treatment plant with membrane filtration (MBR). The permeate that is released during this process can either be removed or further evaporated to thickened permeat with manure. The obtained products conform strict quality requirements, are in homogenized and purified form - they are free from pathogens, insect larvae and weed seeds. | Liquid and solid digestate | biogas | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | Liquid fraction | 29.5-35.6 | 5.7-9.9 | 0.92-2.79 | 4.50-7.42 | 1.29-4.00 | 0.84-1.60 | 3.5-8.5 | 60.000 t/y liquid fraction digestate (including concentrated and/or, thickened effluent), 3.000 t/y dried digestate, and 1.000 à 2.000 t/y raw digestate and/or solid fraction digestate | Static | 9 | Yes | No | High | Low | EU Southwest | Belgium / Province of Antwerp | 1) Must own at least an environmental license/permit for installing this technology will have to be asked & obtained from the local authorities. This legislation and authority depends on the specific EU region. For example in Flanders an ‘omgevingsvergunning’ will be required from the Department of Environment, taking into account BAT (best available technologies) guidelines and recommendations of other advisory bodies. 2) CAPEX for economical industrial scaleis significant (in mio €). 3) Agrogas technology is interesting in regions with high production of natural fertilizer (intensive breeding). 4) Digestate from the vegetal line is useful in organic farming. | AGROGAS bvba https://www.facebook.com/Agrogas/ https://vlaco.be/vlaco-vzw/producten/agrogas-bv | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_263 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_264 | NUTRIMAN / project completed | IUNG | |||||||||||
T27 | Liquid and solid fraction digestate from manure and maize by "Agrogas" process | Technology for N&P recovery as liquid or dried digestates with "Agrogas" separation, drying, membrane filtration and/or reverse osmosis combined with post-treatment system | Agricultural Biomasses | Municipal Biowaste | Agricultural Biomasses: manure, organic wastes, energy maize Municipal Biowaste: household organic waste | Agricultural Biomasses: digestate | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | CMC 2: Plants, plant parts or plant extracts | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | Co-digestion + digestate posttreatments separation (of solid from liquid fraction), drying, membrane filtration (MBR) and reverse osmosis (RO) | The anaerobic digestion process is a natural process in which various microorganisms break down biodegradable organic material under anaerobic conditions and convert it (10-15%) into biogas and digestate (85-90%). Agrogas has two separate digestion and post-treatment lines: one purely vegetal proces line and one animal by products/manure proces line. Agrogas’ digestate fractions come through several mesophilic and thermophilic digesters. In the vegetal line: the (two times fermented) digestate is separated via a screw press into a liquid fraction and solid fraction. The liquid fraction of the vegetal line can be disposed on agricultural soils or is sometimes mixed with the hygienised liquid fraction of the animal process line. (Both types) liquid fractions can be further processed, namely a biological water treatment with membrane filtration (membrane bioreactor (MBR)) or reverse osmosis (RO). This MBR permeate or RO concentrate can undergo further evaporation in the thickener. In the animal line: the digestate is always secondary post-fermented themophilic (> 55°C) in a thermophilic post-digester. In the next step, the digestate is separated into a liquid and solid fraction via a sieve belt press.The solid fraction of the animal fermentation line is stored in a separate loading area for drying or further external processing. The liquid fraction of the hygienized digestate with manure is mostly further treated at the biological water treatment plant with membrane filtration (MBR). The permeate that is released during this process can either be removed or further evaporated to thickened permeat with manure. The obtained products conform strict quality requirements, are in homogenized and purified form - they are free from pathogens, insect larvae and weed seeds. | Liquid and solid digestate | biogas | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | Solid fraction | 34.5-40.5 | 2.4-3.1 | 1.62-2.40 | 1.25-3.50 | 2.07-3.14 | 0.60-0.96 | 0.76-1.12 | 80-90 | 60.000 t/y liquid fraction digestate (including concentrated and/or, thickened effluent), 3.000 t/y dried digestate, and 1.000 à 2.000 t/y raw digestate and/or solid fraction digestate | Static | 9 | Yes | No | High | Low | EU Southwest | Belgium / Province of Antwerp; UE 27 | 1) Must own at least an environmental license/permit for installing this technology will have to be asked & obtained from the local authorities. This legislation and authority depends on the specific EU region. For example in Flanders an ‘omgevingsvergunning’ will be required from the Department of Environment, taking into account BAT (best available technologies) guidelines and recommendations of other advisory bodies. 2) CAPEX for economical industrial scaleis significant (in mio €). 3) Agrogas technology is interesting in regions with high production of natural fertilizer (intensive breeding). 4) Digestate from the vegetal line is useful in organic farming. | AGROGAS bvba https://www.facebook.com/Agrogas/ https://vlaco.be/vlaco-vzw/producten/agrogas-bv | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_263 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_264 | NUTRIMAN / project completed | IUNG | ||||||||||
T28 | Digestate form plant-based biogasplant - dry fraction | The dry fraction of raw (plant based) digestate from an agricultural biogas plant is produced by separating the liquid phase from the solid phase. | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: agricultural processing residues, crop residues | Agricultural Biomasses: crop residues | CMC 4: Fresh crop digestate | Co-digestion + digestate posttreatments separation (on solid and liquid fraction). | The plant biomass placed in the digester undergoes a methane fermentation process. This process occurs due to the vital activities of micro-organisms - methane bacteria. Under anaerobic conditions, these bacteria break down fatty acids, alcohols and other simple and macromolecular organic compounds into methane and carbon dioxide. Anaerobic methane digestion occurs within the digesters of a biogas plant, where organic materials are broken down in the absence of oxygen. This process results in digestate, a by-product with the status of organic fertilizer. The digestate is then subjected to a separation process, where solids are extracted from the liquid. | planteo dry, planteo liquid, planteo pelet | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | planteo dry | 90 | 1.45 | 0.56 | 1.05 | 0.7 | Static | 9 | Yes | Not known | Medium | Medium | EU Central | Poland | https://planteo.eu/ | https://interreg-baltic.eu/project/cinurgi/ | CiNURGi / ongoing project | IUNG | |||||||||||||||||||
T29 | Extraction and desalination | Blue Biomasses | Blue Biomasses: Seawater desalination brine | Blue Biomasses: Seawater desalination brine | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | 500l/day | Chemical Precipitation; Nanofiltration (NF); Multiple Effect Distillation (MED); Selective crystallisation or Flotation | The effluent from the desalination plant (on average 500 L/d brine) will be directed to the first precipitation tank for Mg(OH)2 recovery after NaOH addition. The resulting liquid stream will be fed to the second precipitation tank for CaCO3 removal after Na2CO3 addition. These chemical precipitations, except for Mg recovery for BBFs, will also eliminate scaling problems during Nanofiltration (NF) and Multiple Effect Distillation. NF unit will be used to achieve separation of monovalent from multivalent ions and MED to concentrate the NF permeate. From these process units, high-quality distillate water will also be recovered. The MED concentrate stream containing Na+, K+ and Cl– will be directed to a crystallizer for salts crystallization, i.e. NaCl and KCl and will promote the production of high-quality products. Selective crystallization or flotation will be used for NaCl and KCl separation. | Inorganic fertilizer Potassium (K) – KCl; Magnesium (Mg) – Mg(OH)2 | water | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | Static | 9 | Yes | High | Low | EU Southeast | Greece | https://walnutproject.eu/news/walnut-at-the-verdetec-exhibition-in-athens/ | https://walnutproject.eu/pilot/brine/ | WALNUT project completed | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||
T30 | Digestate form separately collected biowase, organic waste, manure and slaughterhouse waste and garbage fish - liquid fertiliser suitable for organic farming | The liquid fraction of raw (plant based) digestate from an agricultural biogas plant is produced by separating the liquid phase from the solid phase. | Agricultural Biomasses | Industrial side-streams | Agricultural Biomasses: separately collected biowaste, organic waste Industrial side-streams: food industry, mature and sloughterhouse waste and garbage fish | Agricultural Biomasses: plant-based waste and residues, manure | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | Pretreatment (incl. crushing, packaging separation, chopping) of substrates to anaerobic digestion, sanitization, separation into different fractions: solid and liquid. The liquid fraction is suitable for distribution to fields by slurry tankers. | The raw materials of LuomuKymppi are plant-based waste and residues, manure and biowaste collected separately from households. In addition, grease and sewage sludge have been used in the manufacture of PeltoKymppi. The energy contained in the raw materials is utilised as biogas in the production of electricity and heat, and the nutrients are recycled into fertilisers. The safety of fertiliser products is ensured in hygiene by heating them to over 70 degrees for at least 1 hour. The treatment destroys e.g. salmonella, e-coli and weed seeds, as well as waste oats. | https://bio10.fi/?page_id=37 | LuomuKymppi A, LuomuKymppi B, PeltoKymppi A | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | LuomuKymppi A | 72 | 1.94 | 0.53 | 0.06 | 0.21 | 0.01 | 0.034 | 4.8 | https://bio10.fi/?page_id=137 | 1100 t/a | Static | 9 | Yes | Not known | Medium | Medium | EU Central | Finland | https://bio10.fi/?page_id=26 | CiNURGi project (https://interreg-baltic.eu/project/cinurgi/) and Bio10 website (https://bio10.fi/?page_id=137) | CiNURGi / ongoing project | IUNG | |||||||||||||
T31 | Treated sewage sludge - liquid fertilizer form digestatate sewage sludge | Treated sewage sludge - liquid fertilizer form digestatate sewage sludge (from separately collected biowase, organic waste, manure, grease sludge, sewage sludge 10 (12,1%) and slaughterhouse waste and garbage fish) - liquid fertiliser suitable for organic farming | Urban Wastewater | Agricultural Biomasses | Industrial side-streams | Urban wastewater: sewage sludge, Agricultural Biomasses: separately collected biowaste, organic waste Industrial side-streams: food industry, mature and sloughterhouse waste and garbage fish | Agricultural Biomasses: plant-based waste and residues, manure | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | Pretreatment (incl. crushing, packaging separation, chopping) of substrates to anaerobic digestion, sanitization, separation into different fractions: solid and liquid. It is treated sewage sludge - liquid fertilizer form digestatate sewage sludge | The raw materials of LuomuKymppi are plant-based waste and residues, manure and biowaste collected separately from households. In addition, grease and sewage sludge have been used in the manufacture of PeltoKymppi. The energy contained in the raw materials is utilised as biogas in the production of electricity and heat, and the nutrients are recycled into fertilisers. The safety of fertiliser products is ensured in hygiene by heating them to over 70 degrees for at least 1 hour. The treatment destroys e.g. salmonella, e-coli and weed seeds, as well as waste oats. | https://bio10.fi/?page_id=37 | PeltoKymppi A, LuomuKymppi A, LuomuKymppi B, | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | PeltoKymppi A | 66,1 | 1.5 | 0.41 | 0.09 | 0.13 | 0.01 | 0.04 | 4.1 | https://bio10.fi/?page_id=137 | Static | 9 | Yes | Not known | Medium | Medium | EU Central | Finland | https://bio10.fi/?page_id=26 | CiNURGi project (https://interreg-baltic.eu/project/cinurgi/) and Bio10 website (https://bio10.fi/?page_id=137) | CiNURGi / ongoing project | IUNG | |||||||||||||
T32 | Digestate form plant-based biogasplant - liquid fraction | The liquid fraction of raw (plant based) digestate from an agricultural biogas plant is produced by separating the liquid phase from the solid phase. | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: agricultural processing residues, crop residues | Agricultural Biomasses: crop residues | CMC 4: Fresh crop digestate | Co-digestion + digestate posttreatments separation (on solid and liquid fraction). | The plant biomass placed in the digester undergoes a methane fermentation process. This process occurs due to the vital activities of micro-organisms - methane bacteria. Under anaerobic conditions, these bacteria break down fatty acids, alcohols and other simple and macromolecular organic compounds into methane and carbon dioxide. Filtration of the digestate results in a liquid organic fertiliser. | https://planteo.eu/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/PLANTEO_BROSZURA_12str_210mm_x_210mm_4.01.2021_Q_WWW-1.pdf | planteo liquid, planteo draw, plateo pelet | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | planteo liquid | 74 | 1.2 | 0.45 | 0.05 | 0.34 | 0.28 | 0.05 | Static | 9 | Yes | Not known | Medium | Medium | EU Central | Poland | https://planteo.eu/ | https://interreg-baltic.eu/project/cinurgi/ | CiNURGi / ongoing project | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||
T33 | Solid manure and mineral concentrate from pig and cattle slurry by Vlako process | Technology for N&P recovery as solid manure and mineral concentrate from pig and cattle slurry by belt press sieve and pasteurization or reverse osmosis | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: livestock manure and slurry from pigs and cattle or mink | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | 135.000 m3/year | Adding sulfuric acid and iron sulfate to the slurry/manure tank; solid-liquid fraction mechanical separation with belt press sieve; pasteurization solid fractionusing infrared and processing of the liquid fraction by membrane filtration / reverse osmosis. | Local transporters collect the slurry from local pig, cattle or mink farmers and transport this manure to the manure storage at Vlako’s. The process starts in a reactor tank where sulphuric acid and iron sulphate are added to the slurry. From the reactor tank the manure goes to the sieve belt press. The slurry is separated in a solid and liquid fraction using a belt press sieve. After separation, the solid fraction is pasteurized using infrared and then export and sales as organic fertilizer. By pasteurizing the solid fraction, it is free of pathogens like salmonella and e-coli. The liquid fraction is collected and send to the flotation unit. After the flotation unit the liquid fraction goes through a paper filter where left over organic materials are filtered out. From the paper filter the liquid fraction goes through the reverse osmosis where membrane filtration separates clean water from the mineral concentrate. Only after the last step of the process, the reverse osmosis, the product can be called mineral concentrate. The product is characterized by low phosphate and heavy metal contents (Cu: <0,1 ppm; Zn: 0,14 ppm). Reverse osmosis is considered a best available technique to separate clean water for surface water discharge, from liquid manure fractions. | Mineral concentrate (PFC 3(B)), Pasteurized solid fraction (PFC 3(A)) | clean water | PFC 3(B): Inorganic soil improver | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | Mineral concentrate | 0.65 | 0.004 | 0.63 | 0.03 | 0.13 | Static | 9 | Yes | No | High | Low | EU Southwest | The Netherlands (North-Brabant, Northern Limburg) | 1) The mineral concentrate is allowed as pilot RENURE fertilizer which means that application is no longer defined as livestock manure in the Nitrates Directive. 2) Solid fraction there are less tons needed to bring the same kinds of nutrients as when slurry is being brought to the fields. Where normally 6 to 10 tons of slurry is being spread, this can be replaced by using only 2 to 2,5 tons of solid fraction. This means that solid fraction is cheaper to transport and it can be spread with lighter spreaders which leads to less soil compaction. 3) In order to bring considerable quantities of nutritional elements, it is necessary to transport high volumes of the product, taking note of the fact that it is characterized by a low concentration of N, P, K in comparison with mineral fertilizer. 4) Due to the organic origin of the fertilizer, nutrient content may vary. 5) The product is locally produced for local farmers. | Vlako B.V. https://www.vlako.nl/ | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_519 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_594 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_520 | NUTRIMAN / project completed | IUNG | |||||||||||||||||
T34 | Solid manure and mineral concentrate from pig and cattle slurry by Vlako process | Technology for N&P recovery as solid manure and mineral concentrate from pig and cattle slurry by belt press sieve and pasteurization or reverse osmosis | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: livestock manure and slurry from pigs and cattle or mink | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | 135.000 m3/year | Adding sulfuric acid and iron sulfate to the slurry/manure tank; solid-liquid fraction mechanical separation with belt press sieve; pasteurization solid fractionusing infrared and processing of the liquid fraction by membrane filtration / reverse osmosis. | Local transporters collect the slurry from local pig, cattle or mink farmers and transport this manure to the manure storage at Vlako’s. The process starts in a reactor tank where sulphuric acid and iron sulphate are added to the slurry. From the reactor tank the manure goes to the sieve belt press. The slurry is separated in a solid and liquid fraction using a belt press sieve. After separation, the solid fraction is pasteurized using infrared and then export and sales as organic fertilizer. By pasteurizing the solid fraction, it is free of pathogens like salmonella and e-coli. The liquid fraction is collected and send to the flotation unit. After the flotation unit the liquid fraction goes through a paper filter where left over organic materials are filtered out. From the paper filter the liquid fraction goes through the reverse osmosis where membrane filtration separates clean water from the mineral concentrate. Only after the last step of the process, the reverse osmosis, the product can be called mineral concentrate. The product is characterized by low phosphate and heavy metal contents (Cu: <0,1 ppm; Zn: 0,14 ppm). Reverse osmosis is considered a best available technique to separate clean water for surface water discharge, from liquid manure fractions. | Pasteurized solid fraction (PFC 3(A)), Mineral concentrate (PFC 3(B)) | clean water | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | PFC 3(B): Inorganic soil improver | 23 | 1.33 | 0.79 | 0.43 | 30-35 | Static | 9 | Yes | No | High | Low | EU Southwest | The Netherlands (North-Brabant, Northern Limburg) | 1) The mineral concentrate is allowed as pilot RENURE fertilizer which means that application is no longer defined as livestock manure in the Nitrates Directive. 2) Solid fraction there are less tons needed to bring the same kinds of nutrients as when slurry is being brought to the fields. Where normally 6 to 10 tons of slurry is being spread, this can be replaced by using only 2 to 2,5 tons of solid fraction. This means that solid fraction is cheaper to transport and it can be spread with lighter spreaders which leads to less soil compaction. 3) In order to bring considerable quantities of nutritional elements, it is necessary to transport high volumes of the product, taking note of the fact that it is characterized by a low concentration of N, P, K in comparison with mineral fertilizer. 4) Due to the organic origin of the fertilizer, nutrient content may vary. 5) The product is locally produced for local farmers. | Vlako B.V. https://www.vlako.nl/ | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_519 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_594 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_520 | NUTRIMAN / project completed | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||||
T35 | Liquid mineral concentrate by VP-Hobe process | Technology for N recovery as mineral concentrate, ammonia water and ammonium sulphate from manure/digestate by VP-Hobe manure and digestate valorisation system | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: livestock manure and slurry | Agricultural Biomasses: digestate of cattle manure, pig manure or co-fermentation | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | The capacity of the technology is scalable: 50.000, 125.000, 250.000 ton input/year | (1) Separation manure in a flotation unit and in a belt filter press to the liquid and solid fraction. (The solid fraction is dried on a belt dryer.) (2) Concentration of the liquid fraction reverse osmosis (RO) process (3) De-watering the RO-concentrate in an evaporator. (4) Removal of ammonia from flowing liquid stream by stripping and concentrated into NH3-water. (5) Futher production of potassium concentrate and ammonium sulphate solution by scrubbing the vapour coming out of the evaporator with sulphuric acid. (6) Cleaning of condensate from the Evaporator/ Stripper/ Scrubber (ESS) unit and RO permeate in the RO water polisher and the ion exchanger (RO-IE) for discharge into surface waters. | The VP-Hobe manure and digestate valorisation system is a robust proven technology operated at own processing plants. Contains the following modules : (1) Solid-Liquid-separation: Separation takes place in a flotation unit and in a belt filter press. The input manure is separated into a solid and a liquid fraction. A flocculant is added. In the flotation system, small air bubbles bring particles to the surface of the tank where it forms a layer of sludge. This layer is scraped off and de-watered in the belt filter press into a solid fraction of 30% dry matter (DM). The solid fraction is dried on a belt dryer to 90% DM. (2) Reverse Osmosis (RO): A RO processes the liquid fraction (1,7% DM) into a retentate concentrated-N/K2O product (3,4% DM) and a permeate product to be processed in the clean water production. (3) Evaporator/ Stripper/ Scrubber (ESS): The RO-concentrate or thin fraction will be further de-watered in an evaporator. The liquid passes through a falling film evaporator with mechanical vapour recompression. Heating the liquid in the evaporator causes water to evaporate. A vacuum lowers the boiling point, less energy is needed than when evaporating at normal atmospheric pressure. The ammonia in the incoming liquid is removed from the product flow by stripping and concentration into NH3-water (14% N). The evaporator further produces a potassium concentrate (25% DM and 6,5% K2O) and ammonium sulphate solution by scrubbing the vapour coming out of the evaporator with sulphuric acid. (4) Clean water production (RO-IE): The condensate from ESS unit and the permeate from the RO is cleaned in the RO water polisher and the ion exchanger (RO-IE) to achieve the right quality for discharge into surface waters. The VP-Hobe process achieves lowest possible operational costs (energy, additives) while produces several fertilizers, e.g. mineral- and potassium-concentrate, NH3-water, Ammonium sulphate, as well as clean dischargeable water. The products are hygienic and free from salmonella and E-coli. | Liquid mineral concentrate (PFC 3(B)), Liquid ammonium sulphate (PFC 1(C)), NH3-water (PFC 1(C)), Liquid K concentrate (PFC 3(A)) | PFC 3(B): Inorganic soil improver | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | Liquid mineral concentrate | 0.8 | 0.02 | 0.75 | 3.4 | Static | 9 | Yes | No | High | Low | EU Southwest | The Netherlands also Belgium, Germany and other | 1) Authority permit not necessary for local distribution. This product is a potential RENURE fertilizer which means that application will no longer be defined as livestock manure in the Nitrates Directive. This means application will no longer be limited to 170 kg N/ha. /The nitrogen in liquid K concentrate product is still considered livestock manure as defined in the Nitrates Directive. 2) The presence of sulfur in the product can be limiting aplication on grass. 3) Geographical area: max 30 kms from processing plant (for liquid ammonium sulfate) or 200 kms area around processing plant (for liquid NK concentrate). 4) Due to the organic origin of the fertilizer, nutrient content may vary change if changes the quality of the inputs (for liquid mineral concentrate). | VP-HoBe http://www.vp-hobe.nl/ | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_669 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_1529 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_1527 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_1504 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_1528 | NUTRIMAN / project completed | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||
T36 | Filtration unit; Ion exchange; Hollow Fibre Membrane Contactors | Urban Wastewater | Urban Wastewater: wastewater (reject water) | Urban Wastewater: wastewater | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | The aim of this pilot plant is to recover nitrogen from reject water. It consists in three main units: a filtration pre-treatment process to remove the suspended solids presented in reject water; an ion exchange column loaded with 0.5-1 mm zeolites for nitrogen concentration; and two membrane contactors with an unitary surface of 1.4 m2 (3M™ Liqui-Cel™ EXF-2.5×8). These membranes allow the ammonia transport from the feed solution and to the acid one, in this case, nitric acid, producing ammonium nitrate which is free of PTEs and organic micropollutants (OMPs) because the selected membrane is gas permeable and none of these compounds should pass through. | Fertilizer -Nitrogen as ammonium nitrate | water | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 9 | Yes | Not known | High | EU Southwest | Spain | https://www.viaqua.gal/en/digitalizacion-e-innovacion https://walnutproject.eu/news/walnut-partners-pay-a-visit-to-ourense-and-zamora-pilot-plants/ https://www.cetaqua.com/en/laboratorios/cetec-lab/ | https://walnutproject.eu/pilot/sewage-sludge/ | WALNUT project completed | IUNG | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
T37 | Heterotrophic biorreactor- cultivation alge | Hybrid system of Photoautotrophic and heterotrophic microalgal cultivation or Microbial Fuel Cell | Urban Wastewater | Industrial side stream : Industrial waste water ( dairy industry) | Industrial side stream: Industrial waste water | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | The technology consists of three main stages, (i) microalgae cultivation in two stages, which consume the organic matter and nutrients contained in the waste water; (ii) harvesting or separation phase to recover the solid fraction of microalgae as high-value by product and the liquid fraction as reusable water in the process; (iii) a drying stage by spray dryer to recover the dry microalgae. | Nitrogen and Phosphorus | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | PFC 1(B) Organo-mineral fertilizer | 9 | Yes | Yes | High | EU Southwest | Belgium | https://www.aquafin.be/en | https://walnutproject.eu/pilot/industrial/ | WALNUT/ Project completed | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
T38 | HRAS (high-rate activated sludge) Adsorption/ion-exchange | Wastewater treatment process that aims to remove organic matter efficiently, while minimizing energy consumption. It achieves this by employing short sludge and hydraulic retention times, and often prioritizes capturing organic matter for later anaerobic digestion. | Urban Wastewater | Urban wastewater: sludge, wastewater | Urban wastewater: sewage sludge, wastewater | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | A novel 2-stage process that combines (1) high-rate activated sludge (HRAS) and (2) adsorption/ion-exchange will be set up. The first stage (HRAS) will mainly focus on removing organic matter. Aquafin foresees a sequencing batch reactor (SBR) to explore the potential of HRAS treating urban wastewater. The pilot will be able to deal with a discontinuous influent flow of 1300 L/day. During the second stage (adsorption/ion-exchange) we aim to recover at least 50% of the total nitrogen content from the influent wastewater, in the form of ammonium sulphate (from regeneration of the adsorbent) or as saturated adsorbent. On lab-scale, the type of adsorbent and dimensioning of the pilot are still under investigation. Bed volumes per hour (BV/h) are estimated between 8 and 40. | Ammonium sulphate ((NH4)2SO4); Ammonium nitrate (NH4NO3), phosphorus and potassium | PFC 1(B) Organo-mineral fertilizer | 9 | Yes | Not known | High | EU Southwest | Belgium | https://www.aquafin.be/en | https://walnutproject.eu/pilot/urban/ | WALNUT- project completed | IUNG | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
T39 | Anaerobic digestion | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses : pig manure and agricultural waste | Municipal Biowaste: expired food | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | Pig manure, agricultural waste and expired food are provided by nearby producers. All feedstock is processed in an anaerobic digestor where bacteria convert the organic material to biogas (methane and CO2). Said biogas powers motors, transforming into electrical power and heat. Biological residues from the digestor are commercialized as a natural fertilizer. | Pig manure is rich in organic matter is converted into biogas through anaerobic digestion. This process typically yields a high methane content, making it a valuable energy source. Applying thermal pretreatment to pig manure before anaerobic digestion enhancing the stability and efficiency of the process. Thermal pretreatment at 80°C followed by digestion at thermophilic temperatures (45°C) resulted in stable biogas production with methane content around 69%. Integrating hydrothermal pretreatment with anaerobic digestion also improving the removal of antibiotics and increase methane productivity. Regularly monitoring parameters such as pH, temperature, and volatile fatty acids is crucial for maintaining optimal conditions and preventing process imbalances. Mixing pig manure with other organic materials, such as food waste or agricultural residues, can improve the nutrient balance and increase biogas production. The biogas produced can be used to generate electricity, heat, or be upgraded to renewable natural gas for injection into the gas grid. | Naturgal - natural organic fertilizer | Fuels, Heat, Electrical power | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | Static | 9 | Yes | No | High | Medium | EU Central | Poland | https://biogal.pl/zo-0118poiis.html | https://mainstreambio-digital-toolkit.eu/catalogue_business_model/1689321597866x619445133209304400?lang=en_us&intro=yes&solution=business_models&business=references&repository=audio_visual&tech=biochemical&technology=feedstock | MAINSTREAMBIO / project completed | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||
T40 | Anaerobic digestion | The biogas plant is mainly fed by food leftovers and fat, that are both partly hygienised or non-hygienised. The biogas plant is furthermore fed by grass juices as by-products from the biorefinery. | Municipal Biowaste | Municipal Biowaste | Municipal Biowaste | Agricultural Biomasses | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | The biogas plant is mainly fed by food leftovers and fat, that are both partly hygienised or non-hygienised. The biogas plant is furthermore fed by grass juices as by-products from the biorefinery. Biogas is produced by anaerobic digestion and then converted into electrical energy and heat. Around 500 kg of nutrients can be supplied to the biogas process from one tonne of dry matter of grass processed in the biorefinery. At the end of the cycle, the process water is recovered from the substrate and a material with high nitrogen content is separated and used as an organic fertiliser (AgriFer). | Anaerobic digestion is a series of biological process in which micro-organisms break down organic material under oxygen-free conditions. This usually refers to methane fermentation in which the final product is biogas, a mixture of methane and carbon dioxide. Anaerobic digestion therefore is a form of fermentation. The recalcitrant part remains and is called digestate. The process takes place in stirred and heated reactors, often with a volume of more than 1,000 m3, and the conversion of solid organic substances into biogas usually takes one month. There are basically two subtypes of digestion (next to the already mentioned main types, co- and mono-digestion): namely wet and dry digestion. Wet digestion means that a big basin with a stirring mechanism (mixing the slurry) is filled with a liquid mixture. Dry digestion is suitable for fibrous/stalky materials, that are difficult to digest in a slurry. An example of a feedstock suitable for dry digestion is grass or straw. | AgriFer - Organic fertilizer with high nitrogen content. | biogas - thermal and electrical energy | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 18.2 | 18.2 | 2.79 | 4.78 | 8.14 | 0.21 | 0.05 | 3.6 | 1.030 | Static | 9 | Yes | No | High | Low | EU Central | Germany | https://biowert.com/en/agrifer/ https://de.linkedin.com/company/biowert-industrie-gmbh https://www.facebook.com/Biowert/ | https://mainstreambio-digital-toolkit.eu/catalogue_business_model/1689318968177x304884978554370800?lang=en_us&intro=yes&solution=business_models&business=references&repository=audio_visual&tech=biochemical&technology=feedstock | MAINSTREAMBIO / project completed | IUNG | |||||||||||||||
T41 | Insect-based bioconversion | Insect-based bioconversion also known as insect farming is based on the selection of insect species e.g. Black Soldier Fly (BSF) larvae, house fly maggots, mealworms, and grasshoppers-crickets and different rearing substrates. | Municipal Biowaste | Municipal Biowaste: organic residues (e.g. food waste) | Municipal Biowaste: organic residues (e.g. food waste) | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | Pressing, rafination and bioconversion by insects | The production process consists of the following phases/modules: • Preparing the input. The larvae of the Black Soldier Fly (BSF) are generally able to convert any kind of organic residue. • Rearing the larvae • Separating the larvae from the organic fertilizer by sieving. • Drying the larvae in an oven. • Pressing the larvae separate fat from protein meal. The technology madebymade uses originates from a variety of technology providers. Segments of the production process are outsourced to other companies. As much as possible, machinery and equipment already existing is being used, and where needed new technology is developed. No single company is individually able to meet the complete technological needs. The provider of technology is madebymade. The technology is easily scalable. | Mdebymade- Made Green- organic fertilizer | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 80 | 3 | 0.96 | 3.67 | 0.36 | 0.4 | https://madebymade.eu/warum-natuerlicherduenger/ | 20t/day | Static/Mobile | 7 | Yes | Yes | Low | High | EU Central | Germany | https://mainstreambio-digital-toolkit.eu/catalogue_business_model/1689323423748x896236002888529300?lang=en_us&intro=yes&solution=business_models&business=feedstock&repository=audio_visual&tech=biochemical&technology=feedstock&resources=audio_visual | https://madebymade.eu/warum-natuerlicherduenger/ | MAINSTREAMBIO / project completed | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||||
T42 | Bioconversion/ Insect breeding + biorefinery’ | Insect-based bioconversion also known as insect farming is based on the selection of insect species e.g. Black Soldier Fly (BSF) larvae, house fly maggots, mealworms, and grasshoppers-crickets and different rearing substrates. The main benefits of this conversion process are reduction of waste by producing high quality protein (mainly for animal feed) and the extraction of products such as oil, natural fertilizer and chitin. Black soldier fly larvae are grown in crates on rack cupboards and fed with agricultural and food residue streams. Technology is simply scalable to the amounts of vegetable residue streams available, whether smaller or larger quantities. Larvae are harvested, dried & used as feed (when grown on GMP+ food safety assured side streams) or further refined to a protein rich fraction and lipids. Larvae and protein fraction contain essential amino acids which are low in feeds produced from plants. During harvesting the insects are sieved out of their remaining feed medium, the fine fraction (left-overs, debris, etc.) is sold as fertilizer (compost). Also the substrate residue (skins of worms) remaining after pressing of the worms can be used as fertilizer. | Industrial side-streams | Municipal Biowaste: organic food waste | Municipal Biowaste: organic food waste | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | Pressing, rafination and bioconversion by insects | Organic food waste from several origins is fed to mealworm (molitor) larvae. • Worms are grown in patented vertical farms that optimize their growth and molecular components. • These insects contain high quality proteins and other valuable compounds, such as fatty acids and chitosan (scarce compounds). • Mealworms’ dejections are processed into high-quality fertilizers. | Ynfrass- organic fertilizer | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | https://www.ynsect.com/why-ynfrass/ | Static/Mobile | 9 | Yes | Yes | Low | High | EU Central | France | https://www.ynsect.com/ https://www.ynsect.com/plants/ | https://mainstreambio-digital-toolkit.eu/catalogue_business_model/1689323560067x440714238769957440?lang=en_us&intro=yes&solution=business_models&business=feedstock&repository=audio_visual&tech=biochemical&technology=feedstock&resources=audio_visual | MAINSTREAMBIO / project completed | https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-61765-x | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
T43 | Anaerobic digestion | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: livestock manure and slurry | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | The biogas plant is fed by chemically and enzymatically pretreated manure and slurry from pig and poultry farms. Biogas is produced by anaerobic digestion and then converted into electrical energy and heat. At the end of the cycle, a material with high nitrogen content is separated and used as an organic fertilizer. Other Input Materials: water | During the process of anaerobic digestion cattle manure is mixed with biomass. Bacteria in the manure convert organic material (such as sugars, fats and cellulose) into biogas (methane and CO2). The biogas consists of about 60% methane, 35% CO2 and 5% of other gasses, such as H2S, NH3 and others. There are basically two subtypes of digestion (next to the already mentioned main types, co and mono digestion): namely wet and dry. Wet digestion means that a big bassin with a stirring mechanism (mixing the slurry) is filled with a liquid mixture of manure and possibly biomass. Dry digestion is suitable for fibrous/stalky materials, that are difficult to digest in a slurry. An example of a feedstock suitable for dry digestion is grass or straw. Dry digestion is done by a air tight device/container with a sprinkler in the roof. Biomass is placed on the floor and liquid manure is sprayed over the biomass. The liquid manure seeps through the biomass to the floor, which is permeabel for the liquid manure. In the floor, the liquid manure is collected and pumped to the sprinklers again. Most common in the market are wet digestors and these widely commercially available. Dry digestors are still more in development but there are some available on the market. Most digestors are mesofile digestors, that run on temperatures between 37°C and 40°C. In these digestors the manure is kept for about 15 to 40 days.There are also thermofile digestors, that are kept at a temperature of around 55°C. In these digestors the manure is kept for about 10 to 20 days. The time that manure is kept in a digestor is depending on the speed of the digestion process and on the ingredients of the product that is digested. | Catalysts (chemical and enzymatical pretreatment, yeast) | Organic fertilizer (with high nitrogen content) | Biogas, Electrical energy, Heat | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | Static | 9 | Yes | No | High | Medium | EU North | Sweden | https://www.lantmannen.com/ http://agroinlog-h2020.eu/en/home/ https://www.facebook.com/p/Agroinlog-100075643074911/ | https://mainstreambio-digital-toolkit.eu/catalogue_business_model/1689319710089x564223039173296960?lang=en_us&intro=yes&solution=business_models&business=feedstock | MAINSTREAMBIO / project completed | Lantmännen Agriculture is certified : ISO9001, ISO14001+STEMS (energy management), EFISC-GTP, KRAV certificate EU-organic certificate, Sustainable production of biomass (RED)2BSvs https://www.lantmannenlantbrukmaskin.com/about-us/certificates/ | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
T44 | Organic fertilizers from fish and food waste by fermentation proces | Technology for developing organic fertilizers from fish processing and other organic side-streams by fermentation process | Blue Biomasses | Municipal Biowaste | Industrial side-streams | Blue Biomasses: fish by-products - fish waste (i.e. salmon heads, bones, collars, cheeks, spines and bellies) Municipal Biowaste: restaurant food waste, green landscape waste (tree leaves) | Industrial side-streams: ash from wood | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | Impurities removal, fermentation, liquid separation, mixing of the organic mass with ash, granulation and drying or vermicomposting and sieving | Developed of a prototype technological solution for obtaining organic fertilizers, such as foliar spray, granulated ferment and vermicompost, from fish processing and other side- streams. The main treatment is bokashi fermentation and further developments include pelletizing, producing vermicompost and separation of liquid. Extrusion together with hammer mill is the most suitable pelletization method, because it allows the input material to consist of up to 50 % of moisture (compared to the 5 % applicable to the matrix method). For drying the pellets, a solar-powered tumbler dryer was developed. It is an off grid system on a trailer that uses sun power (12 (DC) volts), which capacity ranges up to 2000L per month. It was established that fish waste can be bokashi fermented alone as effectively as together with other types of food waste. That allows fish waste producers to start fermenting on spot, saving them from the cost of freezing or the problem with rotting. | granulated ferment (PFC 1(A)), vermicompost (PFC 3(A)), organic foliar spray (biostimulant) | solar-powered tumbler dryer | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | https://sea2landproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/SEA2LAND_9.4-Practice-Abstracts-M18.pdf (p. 43) | Static/Mobile | 5 | No | Not known | Low | Medium | EU North | Estonia | 1) SWOT analysis - Baltic sea https://sea2landproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/SEA2LAND_9.4-Practice-Abstracts-M18.pdf (p. 31, 39) 2) all side streams must meet the condition of being waste (Regulation 2008/98/CE) and shall constitute part of a fertiliser productcompliant Regulation 2019/1009 | NutriLoop OÜ https://nutriloop.org/ https://www.facebook.com/NutriLoop/videos/4651964931570564/ | https://sea2landproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/SEA2LAND_9.4-Practice-Abstracts-M18.pdf (p.41-43) https://sea2landproject.eu/baltic-sea-case/ | SEA2LAND / project completed | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||||||
T45 | Digestate form plant-based biogasplant - pelet | Pelet from the dry fraction of raw (plant based) digestate from an agricultural biogas plant is produced by separating the liquid phase from the solid phase. | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: agricultural processing residues, crop residues | Agricultural Biomasses: crop residues | CMC 4: Fresh crop digestate | Co-digestion + digestate posttreatments separation (on solid and liquid fraction). | The plant biomass placed in the digester undergoes a methane fermentation process. This process occurs due to the vital activities of micro-organisms - methane bacteria. Under anaerobic conditions, these bacteria break down fatty acids, alcohols and other simple and macromolecular organic compounds into methane and carbon dioxide. Filtration of the digestate results in a solid organic fertiliser, later on dryied and pelletizied. | https://planteo.eu/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/PLANTEO_BROSZURA_12str_210mm_x_210mm_4.01.2021_Q_WWW-1.pdf | planteo pellet, planteo dry, plateo liquid | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | planteo pellet | 90 | 1.85 | 0.57 | 1.04 | https://planteo.eu/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/PLANTEO_BROSZURA_12str_210mm_x_210mm_4.01.2021_Q_WWW-1.pdf | 110 000 m3 of digestate transormed in 2024 year = 400 t of pellet | Static | 9 | Yes | Not known | Medium | Medium | EU Central | Poland | https://planteo.eu/ | https://interreg-baltic.eu/project/cinurgi/ | CiNURGi / ongoing project | IUNG | |||||||||||||||||
T46 | Potassium concentrate by VP-Hobe process | Technology for N recovery as mineral concentrate, ammonia water and ammonium sulphate from manure/digestate by VP-Hobe manure and digestate valorisation system | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: livestock manure and slurry | Agricultural Biomasses: digestate of cattle manure, pig manure or co-fermentation | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | The capacity of the technology is scalable: 50.000, 125.000, 250.000 ton input/year | (1) Separation manure in a flotation unit and in a belt filter press to the liquid and solid fraction. (The solid fraction is dried on a belt dryer.) (2) Concentration of the liquid fraction reverse osmosis (RO) process (3) De-watering the RO-concentrate in an evaporator. (4) Removal of ammonia from flowing liquid stream by stripping and concentrated into NH3-water. (5) Futher production of potassium concentrate and ammonium sulphate solution by scrubbing the vapour coming out of the evaporator with sulphuric acid. (6) Cleaning of condensate from the Evaporator/ Stripper/ Scrubber (ESS) unit and RO permeate in the RO water polisher and the ion exchanger (RO-IE) for discharge into surface waters. | The VP-Hobe manure and digestate valorisation system is a robust proven technology operated at own processing plants. Contains the following modules : (1) Solid-Liquid-separation: Separation takes place in a flotation unit and in a belt filter press. The input manure is separated into a solid and a liquid fraction. A flocculant is added. In the flotation system, small air bubbles bring particles to the surface of the tank where it forms a layer of sludge. This layer is scraped off and de-watered in the belt filter press into a solid fraction of 30% dry matter (DM). The solid fraction is dried on a belt dryer to 90% DM. (2) Reverse Osmosis (RO): A RO processes the liquid fraction (1,7% DM) into a retentate concentrated-N/K2O product (3,4% DM) and a permeate product to be processed in the clean water production. (3) Evaporator/ Stripper/ Scrubber (ESS): The RO-concentrate or thin fraction will be further de-watered in an evaporator. The liquid passes through a falling film evaporator with mechanical vapour recompression. Heating the liquid in the evaporator causes water to evaporate. A vacuum lowers the boiling point, less energy is needed than when evaporating at normal atmospheric pressure. The ammonia in the incoming liquid is removed from the product flow by stripping and concentration into NH3-water (14% N). The evaporator further produces a potassium concentrate (25% DM and 6,5% K2O) and ammonium sulphate solution by scrubbing the vapour coming out of the evaporator with sulphuric acid. (4) Clean water production (RO-IE): The condensate from ESS unit and the permeate from the RO is cleaned in the RO water polisher and the ion exchanger (RO-IE) to achieve the right quality for discharge into surface waters. The VP-Hobe process achieves lowest possible operational costs (energy, additives) while produces several fertilizers, e.g. mineral- and potassium-concentrate, NH3-water, Ammonium sulphate, as well as clean dischargeable water. The products are hygienic and free from salmonella and E-coli. | no data | Liquid K concentrate (PFC 3(A)), Liquid ammonium sulphate (PFC 1(C)), NH3-water (PFC 1(C)), Liquid mineral concentrate (PFC 3(B)) | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | PFC 3(B): Inorganic soil improver | Liquid K concentrate | 7.5 | 4.0 | 1.75 | 5.42 | 25 | Static | 9 | Yes | No | High | Low | EU Southwest | The Netherlands also Belgium, Germany and other | 1) Authority permit not necessary for local distribution. This product is a potential RENURE fertilizer which means that application will no longer be defined as livestock manure in the Nitrates Directive. This means application will no longer be limited to 170 kg N/ha. /The nitrogen in liquid K concentrate product is still considered livestock manure as defined in the Nitrates Directive. 2) The presence of sulfur in the product can be limiting aplication on grass. 3) Geographical area: max 30 kms from processing plant (for liquid ammonium sulfate) or 200 kms area around processing plant (for liquid NK concentrate). 4) Due to the organic origin of the fertilizer, nutrient content may vary change if changes the quality of the inputs (for liquid mineral concentrate). | VP-HoBe http://www.vp-hobe.nl/ | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_669 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_1529 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_1527 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_1504 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_1528 | NUTRIMAN / project completed | IUNG | ||||||||||||||
T47 | Slurry acidification | The addition of acids aids the protonation of ammonia, shifting the equilibrium towards ammonium thus reducing the possibility of nitrogen loss through ammonia evaporation and increasing the nitrogen content of the slurry in effect. | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: slurry | Agricultural Biomasses: slurry | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | Addition of acids aids the protonation of ammonia, shifting the equilibrium towards ammonium thus reducing the possibility of nitrogen loss through ammonia evaporation and increases the nitrogen content of slurry in effect. When sulfuric acid is used for acidification, then the sulfur content of the slurry is also increased. There are commercially available technologies to acidify slurry in the animal house, before slurry is pumped to storage, or just before or during spreading. All systems use sulfuric acid for the acidification. Acidified slurry is stored or spread with regularl equipment | The addition of acids aids the protonation of ammonia, shifting the equilibrium towards ammonium thus reducing the possibility of nitrogen loss through ammonia evaporation and increasing the nitrogen content of the slurry in effect. When sulfuric acid is used for acidification, then the sulfur content of the slurry is also increased. There are commercially available technologies to acidify slurry in the animal house, before the slurry is pumped to storage, or just before or during spreading. All systems use sulfuric acid for acidification. The acidified slurry is stored or spread with regular equipment. The acidified slurry has characteristics with significantly different buffering capacities, N and P speciation, and electrical conductivity. Slurry acidification can lead to significant CO2 emissions during the process as well as H2S emissions during storage. Acidification in the animal house involves pumping acidified slurry into the storage area beneath the slatted floors. Another approach is to add the acid in the slurry storage tank just before the slurry is applied to fields or the acid can be applied in-line on the slurry tanker during field application. This approach is cheaper than in-house acidification as less equipment and sulphuric acid are needed for decreasing the pH of the slurry. However, field acidification only reduces NH3 emissions in the field and does not reduce emissions from animal housing or manure storage. The improved fertilizer value of nitrogen (N) is another advantage of slurry acidification. Lower NH3 losses following acidification mean more slurry total-N and plant-available N remains in the slurry applied to fields, resulting in an increased mineral N fertilizer equivalent (MFE) value compared to the untreated slurry. | Acidification decreases ammonia emissions from manure and digestate by 50–70%. When the pH is decreased from typically around 7.5 to 5.5, the gaseous acid-base compound concentration of NH3 decreases from 1.8% to 0.02%. Ammonia emissions from pig housing were reduced by up to 70% when slurry was acidified from pH 7.5 to pH 6 and by 67% following subsequent field application by band-spreading. If slurry is acidified during the storage period, it will also reduce methane emissions by +90% during storage. Some studies suggest that acidification can reduce nitrous oxide emissions but there is not consensus on this in scientific literature | Fertilizer / Acidified slurry or digestate used to crop fertilization | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | Static/Mobile | 9 | Yes | No | Low | High | EU Central | Baltic Sea regions countries ( Denmark, Estonia, Finland,Latvia, Lithuania, Germany, Netherlands, Poland, Spain, Sweden) | Baltic slurry acidification project YouTube channel https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC1W0TdVuzREXROIsYC6uKaQ | http://balticslurry.eu/goals-and-achievements/ | MAINSTREAMBIO / project completed | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
T48 | Digestate form separately collected biowase, organic waste, manure and slaughterhouse waste and garbage fish - solid soil conditioner suitable for organic farming. | The solid fraction of raw (plant based) digestate from an agricultural biogas plant is produced by separating the solid phase from the liquid phase. | Agricultural Biomasses | Industrial side-streams | Agricultural Biomasses: separately collected biowaste, organic waste Industrial side-streams: food industry, mature and sloughterhouse waste and garbage fish | Agricultural Biomasses: plant-based waste and residues, manure | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | Pretreatment (incl. crushing, packaging separation, chopping) of substrates to anaerobic digestion, sanitization, separation into different fractions: solid and liquid. The solid fraction is suitable for distribution to fields for organic farming and home gardens. | The raw materials of LuomuKymppi are plant-based waste and residues, manure and biowaste collected separately from households. In addition, grease and sewage sludge have been used in the manufacture of PeltoKymppi. The energy contained in the raw materials is utilised as biogas in the production of electricity and heat, and the nutrients are recycled into fertilisers. The safety of fertiliser products is ensured in hygiene by heating them to over 70 degrees for at least 1 hour. The treatment destroys e.g. salmonella, e-coli and weed seeds, as well as waste oats. | https://bio10.fi/?page_id=37 | LuomuKymppi B, LuomuKymppi A, PeltoKymppi A | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | LuomuKymppi B | 84 | 10.44 | 0.67 | 0.21 | 0.33 | 0.035 | 0.071 | 22.2 | https://bio10.fi/?page_id=137 | Static | 9 | Yes | Not known | Medium | Medium | EU Central | Finland | https://bio10.fi/?page_id=26 | CiNURGi project (https://interreg-baltic.eu/project/cinurgi/) and Bio10 website (https://bio10.fi/?page_id=137) | CiNURGi / ongoing project | IUNG | ||||||||||||||
T49 | Struvite from waste water by "Canal de Isabel II" process | Technology for P recovery as struvite starting from waste water with crystallization reactor | Urban Wastewater | Urban Wastewater: wastewater (from wase water treatment plant (WWTP)) MgCl2, NaOH | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | CMC 1: Virgin material substances and mixtures | Controlled precipitationof struvite in a rising fluidized bed reactor. The fluidization of the bed is achieved by recirculation pumping. The dewatered raw material (sludge liquor) is fed into the lower part of the reactor, where they are diluted with recirculation and injected with MgCl2 (32%) and NaOH (25%). Inside the reactor, struvite precipitation occurs in a controlled manner (small hard granules). At the top of the reactor, an integrated clarifier retains the granules inside the reactor. Struvite particles are collected from the bottom of the reactor, washed, dried, sorted by size and packaged for shipment. | The Nutrient Recovery facility consists of 2 groups of feed pumps, a crystallising reactor and its associated pumps, valves etc., a draining and drying product step, a product sorting and packaging step, a programmable logic controller (PLC) cabinet, an engine control centre, a MgCl2 storage tank and a NaOH storage tank. The process is based on the control of struvite precipitation in a rising fluidized bed reactor. The fluidization of the bed is achieved by recirculation pumping, which is responsible for maintaining a constant upward velocity in the reactor regardless of the flow. The inlet of the feed and the dosing of the reagent take place in the injection line to the reactor. The efficiency of the struvite crystallization reaction is usually around 90%. The draining of the dehydration and the clarification of the flotation are fed into the lower part of the reactor where they are diluted with recirculation and injected with MgCl2 (32%) and NaOH (25%). Inside the reactor the struvite (MgNH4PO4·6H2O) precipitates in a controlled way in small hard granules. At the top of the reactor, an integrated clarifier retains the granules inside the reactor. The effluent is sent to a tank from where it is pumped to the primary decantation of the WWTP. Struvite particles are collected from the bottom of the reactor, washed, dried, sorted by size and packaged for shipment.The Struvite Recovery System of the Madrid Sur WWTP is designed to recover phosphate from a combined feed, in the range from 50 to 120 m3/h maximum anaerobic digested sludge, dehydration overflows and flotation overflows. | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_252 | Crystal Green® (struvite) | Effluent for discharge | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | 5 | 12.2 | 9 | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_251 | 2 t/day | Static | 9 | Yes | No | High | Low | EU Southwest | Spain / Madrid; UE 27 | 1) The required permits include: a permit for sewage treatment and for the construction of a treatment plant on the site where it will be located, issued by the local authority. 2) Purchase of a license for Ostara's Pearl® Technology. | Canal de Isabel II https://www.canaldeisabelsegunda.es/ | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_252 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_251 https://www.ostara.com/products/crystal-green/ | NUTRIMAN / project completed | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||||
T50 | Struvite from digested sludge and wastewater by "NuReSys" process | Technology for P recovery as pelletized struvite starting from digested sludge and wastewater with "NuReSys" crystallisation process | Urban Wastewater | Industrial side-streams | Urban Wastewater: wastewater, sewage sludge | Urban Wastewater: dewatered sludge, digested sludge (digestate dewatering liquor, digestate, wastewater) | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | Phosphorus precipitation from wastewater treatment plants at the outlet, controlled struvite growth and struvite crystallization (stripper/crystaliser combination), gravimetric separation. or Phosphorus precipitation directly from digested sludge, using a stripper for pH control and a stirred tank reactor with MgCl2 addition for active struvite formation, gravimetric separation. | NuReSys technology for biological phosphate removal (preventing uncontrolled struvite formation) can be applied on digested sludge or dewatering liquids. The NuReSys technology wants to tackle these operational problems by controlling the struvite crystallization process. Advantages are scaling prevention (based on limiting free soluble phosphate) and improvement of dewatering of the bio solids, reducing the phosphorus load returning to the head of the municipal wastewater treatment plants (MWTP). This process allows continuous recovery of phosphorus in a reactor with complete mixing. The crystallization reactor is equipped with a simple blade impeller, and a specially developed and fully automated control algorithm ensures optimal pH (8-8,5), reagent dosing and variable mixing intensity. In this way, new crystalline matter grows on existing crystals and prevents unwanted scale formation on the impeller or reactor. The formed struvite granules are removed by intermittent blowing. The appropriate pH for struvite crystallization is guaranteed by an aeration system that induces CO2 stripping. The classical application of struvite precipitation is on the municipal wastewater treatment plants (MWTP) at the outlet of the dewatering or on industrial water wastewater treatment plants at the outlet of an UASB reactor. The process can run in two different modes. The first approach - a straight forward stripper/crystalliser combination can be installed. Struvite harvesting is quite simple because the struvite, at 1,7 specific density, can easily be separated from the effluent. The second approach directly applied on digested sludge is a stripper for pH control and stirred tank reactor with MgCl2 addition to promote active struvite formation. The produced struvite pellets is a pure, contaminant free product ready for direct reuse or by preference as commodity product to be blended in with other nutrients to obtain an equilibrated nutrient ratio. This pure crystalline product has non-detectable heavy metal content or well below admitted levels (Zn). The NuReSYS process achieved phosphorus reduction from 85% to approximately 96% and production of struvite particles with variable size from 2 to 6 mm. | https://nuresys.com/technology/ | Biostru© (struvite) | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | ≤1.00 | 5 | 12.2 | 9.04 | 98-100 | 1700 | https://bio-stru.com | 0,1-2,5 tons/day | Static | 9 | Yes | No | High | Low | EU Southwest | Belgium / Flanders | 1) Patented Integrated Phosphate Management (IPM) technology. 2) Loss of waste status. | NuReSys http://www.nuresys.com | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_294 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_293 | NUTRIMAN / project completed | NuReSys is currently one of the major phosphorus technology providers, with 9 operational units in Europe on municipal sludge processing and agro-industrial wastewater. | IUNG | ||||||||||||||
T51 | Struvite from digestate and manure by "REVAWASTE" process | Technology for P recovery as struvite starting from digestate coming from methanogenic reactor and manure with "REVAWASTE" crystallisation process | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: livestock manure and slurry | Agricultural Biomasses: pig manure digestate MgCl2, NaOH | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | CMC 1: Virgin material substances and mixtures | Introducing the digestate l (after anaerobic fermentation) into the crystallization unit, adding magnesium salt (usually MgCl2), mixing the digestate and reagents using a fluidized bed reactor, converting the digestate to struvite (magnesium ammonium phosphate). | The digestate leaving the methanogenic reactor (after anaerobic digestation) is introduced into a crystallisation unit and converted to struvite (magnesium ammonium phosphate). To carry out the reaction, it is necessary to add a magnesium salt (usually MgCl2) to the digestate. This technology allows a good mixing of the digestate and the reagents by means of the fluidised bed reactor. The reaction yields for struvite crystallisation are typically between 80-90%. The products obtained are a gas (a mixture of biogas and syngas) with which electric energy is produced and two fertiliser products, struvite and biochar (obtained as solid by-product in the thermo-chemical process). The technology is suitable for installation in waste treatment center. | Struvite | mixture of biogas and syngas (energy content 6.5 kWh·m-3 and 8.5 kWh·m-3, respectively), biochar | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | 5.0 | 12.2 | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_250 | 1 t/day | Static | 7 | Yes | No | High | Low | EU Southwest | Spain/province of Tarragona; EU 27 | 1) The technology is installed together in the waste treatment center where the digestate is generated. Therefore, the authorisation should bewaste treatment facility permits. 2) The cost of manufacturing the product will depend on the amount of waste. CAPEX: 0.5 M€ capacity for anaerobic digestion: 6,000 m3/y pig manure. 3) The installation exists on a pilot scale. 4)The fertiliser product is not placed on the market (TRL 6). 5) Complies with EU Fertilizer Regulations. In the absence of approval of the framework for the new facultative European regulation on fertilizing products. In many countries, struvite cannot currently be used as a biofertilizer, as it is classified as waste. So far, the product is accepted as a fertilizer in the UK and the Netherlands. | Fundación CARTIF https://www.cartif.es/ | https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/technology/id_258 https://nutriman.net/farmer-platform/product/id_250 | NUTRIMAN / project completed | IUNG | |||||||||||||||||||
T52 | Aerobic conversion (composting) | An aerobic conversion process relies on microorganisms that thrive under aerobic conditions, i.e. where plenty of oxygen is available and a sufficient amount of feedstock is present. An example is composting, which is a microbiological process in which heterogeneous organic material is oxidised and broken down into compost, CO2, H2O and heat in a set-up where air passes through a heap (pile, mound) of porous, solid material. Although composting can occur spontaneously in the field (for example, in mown verge grass), the process referred to here is controlled composting. It is often carried out with forced ventilation (through a ventilator) in a container, hall, or open air. The aim of composting is to produce a stable final product, free of pathogens and germinable weed seeds. The composting process proceeds through three phases: i) mesophilic 10-45°C, ii) thermophilic 45-70°C and iii) maturation (curing). As composting is a kind of biological combustion process, heat is emitted, which can also be used. The heat also causes water to evaporate, and the material becomes drier, and many pathogens and seeds of weeds are exterminated due to the high temperature (70°C). The process takes a few weeks. | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: agri-food sludge | Municipal Biowaste: digestate, compost | CMC 2: Plants, plant parts or plant extracts | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | Composting begins with the mixing of the compost matrices, which are placed in trays and turned periodically. Turning spontaneously initiates aerobic fermentation, where any pathogens are neutralised by the controlled temperatures generated by the process itself. Once the thermophilic phase is over, the curing phase begins, during which the product is placed in heaps for about 60 days to complete the natural process of stabilisation and humification of the organic matter. To be sold, the compost is sifted to 20-30 mm for better spreading with a conventional manure spreader. The final product is dark brown in colour and has the consistency of manure. It has the typical forest floor smell of composted products, although non-persistent. Econat® composted soil improver from agri-food chain scraps is made from biodegradable scraps exclusively from the agri-food industry, transformed into an environmentally sustainable product for modern agriculture, which is increasingly seeking to reduce the use of synthetic fertilisers. | Composted soil improver from agri-food chain scraps is a compost specifically for agricultural use, made from cuttings, prunings, bio-digestate from Caviro Extra's anaerobic biogas production process, and agri-food sludge. This fertiliser is produced by the natural decomposition of organic matter, which is transformed through a process of bio-oxidation. | ECONAT- ACFA- mixed composted soil improver | biogas | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 23-33 | 7,1-8,5 | 0,35-1 | 0,5-1 | https://enomondo.it/en/natural-fertilisers/acfa/ | Static/Mobile | 9 | Yes | Not known | Low | Medium | EU Southwest | Italy | https://caviroextra.it/ https://www.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=122145800768543680&id=61566310415065&_rdr https://enomondo.it/en/natural-fertilisers/ | https://mainstreambio-digital-toolkit.eu/catalogue_business_model/1689321771181x368089406492831300?lang=en_us&intro=yes&solution=business_models&business=feedstock&repository=audio_visual&tech=biochemical&technology=feedstock | MAINSTREAMBIO / project completed | Enomondo, a joint venture between Caviaro Extra and Herambiente, contributes to the valorization of agro-industrial and green waste through the production of rewenable energy and natural tertilizers ( ACM, ACV,ACFA). ACFA ECONAT has obtained the C.I.C. Quality Compost Premium Brand. | IUNG | |||||||||||||||||
T53 | Anaerobic digestion | Anaerobic digestion which convert winery waste and moweing waste into biogas and bioethanol. As a by-product, they obtain fertilizers. | Municipal Biowaste | Municipal Biowaste: winery waste | Municipal Biowaste: moweing waste | CMC 2: Plants, plant parts or plant extracts | The waste and by-products from CAVIRO’s wine production are combined with mowing waste material collected by in the local area. Feedstock is supplied to the anaerobic digestor. The outputs include biofuels as biogas and bioethanol. Another part is converted to thermal energy and electricity, creating a virtuous circle between industrial production and energy from renewable sources. Organic parts of biomass and waste from industrial farming are treated to produce natural fertilizers. The different types of natural fertilizers return to the field, closing a virtuous cycle. Packaging is designed to use more sustainable materials. | Composting begins with the mixing of the matrices which are placed in flooring and turned over periodically.The turning spontaneously triggers the aerobic fermentation in which any pathogens are inactivated by the controlled temperatures generated by the process itself. At the end of the thermophilic phase, the curing phase begins and the product is stored for about 60 days in heaps to end the natural stabilisation and humification process of the organic matter. The compost is sifted to obtain a finer and more homogeneous product. The final product has the consistency of soil and the smell of the undergrowth soil typical of composted products. The mixed composted soil improver ECONAT is obtained by enhancing the input biodegradable scraps and transforming it into an eco- sustainable product for modern agriculture which has an increasing tendency to reduce the use of synthetic fertilisers. | ECONAT- ACM- mixed composted soil improver | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 22-34 | 2-2,4 | 0,31-0,50 | 0,35-0,70 | https://enomondo.it/en/natural-fertilisers/acm/ | Static | 9 | Yes | Not known | High | Low | EU Southwest | Italy | https://caviroextra.it/ https://www.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=122145800768543680&id=61566310415065&_rdr https://enomondo.it/en/natural-fertilisers/ | https://mainstreambio-digital-toolkit.eu/catalogue_business_model/1689321771181x368089406492831300?lang=en_us&intro=yes&solution=business_models&business=feedstock&repository=audio_visual&tech=biochemical&technology=feedstock | MAINSTREAMBIO / project completed | Enomondo, a joint venture between Caviaro Extra and Herambiente, contributes to the valorization of agro-industrial and green waste through the production of rewenable energy and natural tertilizers ( ACM, ACV,ACFA). ACM ECONAT has obtained the C.I.C. Quality Compost Premium Brand. | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||||||
T54 | Aerobic conversion (composting) | The incoming cuttings and prunings are shredded and sifted to produce a fine fraction for further processing. Created by the natural decomposition of organic matter, which is transformed through a process of bio-oxidation. | Municipal Biowaste | Municipal Biowaste: green landscape waste (greenery raw materials) | Municipal Biowaste: green landscape waste (greenery raw materials) | CMC 2: Plants, plant parts or plant extracts | The incoming cuttings and prunings are shredded and sifted to produce a fine fraction for further processing. The composting process takes place in heaps in a sealed area, where they are periodically turned with a mechanical shovel to promote oxidation and spontaneous fermentation. After a period of approximately 120 days, the product is transferred to a covered area where it is cured before being refined by sieving. The resulting compost has the consistency of topsoil, a dark brown colour, and the typical forest floor smell of composted products. Econat® green composted soil improver makes it possible to valorise incoming ligno-cellulosic scraps by transforming them into an environmentally sustainable product suitable for both conventional and organic agriculture. It improves the soil by adding high quality humified organic matter, enhances the development of micro-organisms, and adapts to all types of crops, also aiding their root development. | The composted soil improver originates in the natural decomposition of the organic matter which is transformed through a bio-oxidation process. | ECONAT-ACV- green composted soil improver | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 22-26 | 1,2-1,8 | 0,17-0,26 | 0,83-1 | enomondo.it/en/natural-fertilisers/acv/ | Static/Mobile | 9 | Yes | Not known | Low | High | EU Southwest | Italy | availability of raw materials | https://caviroextra.it/ https://www.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=122145800768543680&id=61566310415065&_rdr https://enomondo.it/en/natural-fertilisers/ | https://mainstreambio-digital-toolkit.eu/catalogue_business_model/1689321771181x368089406492831300?lang=en_us&intro=yes&solution=business_models&business=feedstock&repository=audio_visual&tech=biochemical&technology=feedstock | MAINSTREAMBIO / project completed | Enomondo, a joint venture between Caviaro Extra and Herambiente, contributes to the valorization of agro-industrial and green waste through the production of rewenable energy and natural tertilizers ( ACM, ACV,ACFA). ACV ECONAT has obtained the C.I.C. Quality Compost Premium Brand | IUNG | |||||||||||||||||||
T55 | Valorization of by-products of the aquaculture industry | Valorization of by-products of the aquaculture industry, obtaining biobased fertilisers (BBF) | Blue Biomasses | Blue Biomasses: fish by-products, aquaculture sludge (fish sludge and dead fishes) | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | separation into solid and liquid fractions; solid fraction - biodrying (organic additive ) or combustion (recover P from ashes) and recover NH3 from biodrying (ammonium salts); liquid fraction - several concentration processes -ultrafiltration, reverse osmosis and freezing concentration | The sludge is separated into solid and liquid fractions. Solid fraction valorization is conducted by applying the biodrying process, aiming to reduce the water content and obtain a nutrient-rich biodried product to be used as an organic amendment. It is also expected the combustion of this product to recover phosphorus from the ashes to produce phosphoric acid. The feasibility of recovering the volatilized ammonia during the biodrying to produce ammonium salts will be also evaluated. The liquid fraction from sludge is being valorized by using several concentration processes, including an ultrafiltration (UF) system to separate solid particles present in the liquid fraction. The permeate produced by UF passes through the reverse osmosis (RO) system to concentrate the nutrients. The RO concentrate generated is subsequently processed in a freezing concentration (FC) unit, where the water is crystallized, and the nutrients are recovered in a nutrient-rich concentrate product. Moreover, a high-quality RO permeate with potential to be reused in the aquaculture industry facilities is also produced. | Bio-based fertilisers | high-quality permeate | Static | 5 | No | Not known | High | Medium | EU Southwest | Spain | BETA Technological Centre (UVIC-UCC) https://betatechcenter.com/ | https://sea2landproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/SEA2LAND_9.4-Practice-Abstracts-M18.pdf (p. 69) | SEA2LAND / project completed | IUNG | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||
T56 | Ammonia and carbon concentrated products from pig/cattle/poultry manure | Ammonia sulphate from pig and cattle manure | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: pig slurry and cattle manure | CMC 1: Virgin material substances and mixtures | 1. Pre-treatment: liquid manure stored and filtered. 2. Heated to 60°C. 3. NaOH added to raise pH to 10. 4. Stripping 5. Scrubbing (Stripped NH₃ bubbled through 50% H₂SO₄) 5. Collection of ammonium sulphtate. | 1. Ammonia volatilisation by heating and pH increase. 2. Air-stripping to carry NH₃ gas. 3. Chemical scrubbing with H₂SO₄ | https://www.fertimanure.eu/en/publication/consult/64 | liquid N and liquid K, solid amendment, | FR-LK, FR-BC | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | FR-AS | 0.3 | 0.3 | 16.2 | 0.3 | 0.3 | 4.5 | 0.0007 | 42.9 | 30.3 | 0,188 ton/year | Static/Mobile | 6 | Yes | Not known | Medium | Low | EU Southwest | France | PIlot scale | https://www.fertimanure.eu/en/publication/consult/64 | https://www.fertimanure.eu/en/publication/consult/64 | FERTIMANURE/project completed | FERTIMANURE | IUNG | ||||||||||||
T57 | Biochar from poultry manure | Drying and thermal decomposition (pyrolysis) of manure in oxygen-free environment to stable carbon-rich biochar | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: poultry manure | CMC 14: Pyrolysis And Gasification Materials | Dryin to 70% DM, slow pyrolysis in 550-700°C and N₂ flushing | Before the pyrolysis process, manures were dried to reach a DM content at least of 70% fresh weight. The pyrolysis pilot used an endless screw to move the substrate forward. The process was carried out as “slow pyrolysis process” with a temperature of 700°C for poultry manure and 550°C for solid phase of digestate. Residence time was between 25 to 30 min for both tested manures. Anaerobic conditions were ensured by continue injection of N₂ (between 15 to 20 NL/min) to reach an oxygen content below 2%. Pyrolysis by-products were biochar (FR-BC) and pyrolysis gases. The gases were evacuated to a flare where they were burned. | https://www.fertimanure.eu/en/publication/consult/64 | FR-BC | FR-AS, FR-LK | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | FR-BC | 70 | 37 | 2 | 2 | 6.25 | 3.75 | 1.77 | 0.83 | 96 | 4,2-7,2 ton/year | Mobile | 6 | Yes | Not known | Medium | Low | EU Southwest | France | PIlot scale | https://www.fertimanure.eu/en/publication/consult/64 | https://www.fertimanure.eu/en/publication/consult/64 | FERTIMANURE/project completed | FERTIMANURE | IUNG | ||||||||||||
T58 | Pyrolysis plant of cattle dung | Pilot plant process for BBFs prduction from cattle dung to biochar. | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: livestock manure and slurry | CMC 14: Pyrolysis And Gasification Materials | 65 ton/year | Cattle dung pre-treatment, thermochemical conversion to biochar | The targeted BBFs of the pilot plant are the phosphorous rich biochar produced from Thermo-Catalytic Reforming of dried cattle dung. | https://www.fertimanure.eu/en/publication/consult/64 | DE-BC, DE-AP | Heat & electricity for dryer, TCR and other parts | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | DE-BC - biochar | 52.3 | 39.5 | 1 | 3 | 9.56 | 2.3 | 0.7 | 0,25 | 99.6 | 65 tonnes/year | Static | 7 | Yes | Not known | Medium | Medium | EU Central | Germany | Thechnology is as a the pilot plant. | https://www.fertimanure.eu/en/publication/consult/64 | https://www.fertimanure.eu/en/publication/consult/64 | FERTIMANURE/project completed | IUNG | ||||||||||||
T59 | Pyrolysis plant of cattle dung | Pilot plant process for BBFs prduction from cattle dung to mono-ammonium phosphate. | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: livestock manure and slurry | CMC 14: Pyrolysis And Gasification Materials | 8 ton/year | Cattle dung pre-treatment, thermochemical catalytic reforming (TCR) of dried cattle dung and the mono-ammonium phosphate on perlite obtained from the MAP reactor. | The recovery of ammonia from the pyrolysis gas through scrubbing was only tested and demonstraded on a smaller-scale plant. | https://www.fertimanure.eu/en/publication/consult/64 | DE-AP, DE-BC | Heat & electricity for dryer, TCR and other parts | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | DE-AP - Ammonium phosphate on perlite | 0.09 | 0 | 12.3 | 20 | 0.005 | 0.36 | 0 | 0.99 | 8 tonnes/year | Static | 5 | No | Not known | Low | Low | EU Central | Germany | Thechnology is as a the pilot plant. | https://www.fertimanure.eu/en/publication/consult/64 | https://www.fertimanure.eu/en/publication/consult/64 | FERTIMANURE/project completed | IUNG | |||||||||||||
T60 | BBFs by stripping/scrubbing | Pilot plant process for BBFs prduction fromanimal slurry to ammonium sulfate/nitrate. | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: livestock manure and slurry | CMC 14: Pyrolysis And Gasification Materials | 285 - 85 300 tonne/year | 1. Manure Separation: Identical to BE-AN – mechanical separation into LF and SF. 2.Composting: SF is composted. 3. LF Processing: A portion of LF goes to the stripping-scrubbing unit. 4. Stripping Process: pH raised with NaOH and heated to encourage NH₃ volatilisation. 5. NH₃ Transfer: Ventilated air captures NH₃ and moves it to the scrubbing column. 6. Scrubbing: NH₃ gas is scrubbed with sulfuric acid (H₂SO₄), forming ammonium sulphate (BE-AS). 7. Product Recovery: BE-AS solution is collected. 8. LF Post-treatment: Scrubbed LF is rejoined with remaining LF and further processed biologically. | Using H₂SO₄ as the absorbing agent to produce a fertiliser with sulphur content. Ammonia volatilisation via chemical/thermal induction; absorption in sulphuric acid. Separation → pH/thermal conditioning → NH₃ transfer → scrubbing. Requirements for Optimal Performance: pH between 7.5–9; temperature 42–55 °C; adequate H₂SO₄ dosing | https://www.fertimanure.eu/en/publication/consult/64 | BE-AS, BE-AN, BE-AW | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | BE-AS Ammonium sulphate - liquid | 0.26 | 0.23 | 21 | 0.01 | 0.2 | 0.2 | 0.01 | 23 | 35 | 285 - 85 300 tonne/year | Mobile | 7 | Yes | Not known | Medium | Medium | EU Southwest | Belgium | Thechnology is as a the pilot plant. | https://www.fertimanure.eu/en/publication/consult/64 | https://www.fertimanure.eu/en/publication/consult/64 | FERTIMANURE/project completed | IUNG | |||||||||||||
T61 | BBFs by stripping/scrubbing | Pilot plant process for BBFs prduction fromanimal slurry to ammonium nitrate. | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: livestock manure and slurry | CMC 14: Pyrolysis And Gasification Materials | 285 tonne/year | 1. Pig and cattle manure is collected and separated via centrifugation into solid (SF) and liquid (LF) fractions. 2.The SF is composted separately. 3. A portion of the nitrogen-rich LF is directed to the ammonia stripping-scrubbing unit. 4. LF is treated by raising pH (using NaOH) and temperature (42–55 °C) to volatilise NH₃. 5. NH3 is removed by forced ventilation (1000–1800 m³/h, 0.2–0.8 m/s). 6. The volatilised NH3 gas is absorbed in nitric acid (HNO3), forming ammonium nitrate (BE-AN) 7.The resultant BE-AN solution is collected and stored. 8. Scrubbed LF is mixed with untreated LF and processed via biological nitrification-denitrification. | NH₃ recovery through thermal and chemical desorption and acid absorption. Centrifugation, pH/temperature conditioning, air stripping, scrubbing with HNO₃. Mechanical separation → chemical conditioning → NH₃ gas transfer → acid neutralisation. Requirements for Optimal Performance: pH between 7.5–9; temperature 42–55 °C, adequate NaOH dosing. | https://www.fertimanure.eu/en/publication/consult/64 | BE-AN, BE-AS, BE-AW | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | BE-AN Ammonium nitrate - liquid | 0.23 | 0.03 | 40 | 0.01 | 0.14 | 0.1 | 0.02 | 0.095 | 39 | 285 tonne/year | Mobile | 7 | Yes | Not known | Medium | Medium | EU Southwest | Belgium | Thechnology is as a the pilot plant. | https://www.fertimanure.eu/en/publication/consult/64 | https://www.fertimanure.eu/en/publication/consult/64 | FERTIMANURE/project completed | IUNG | |||||||||||||
T62 | Ammonia and acarbon concentrated products from pig/cattle/poultry manure | Pilot plant process for BBFs prduction from animal slurry directly on field. | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: livestock manure and slurry | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | 724 tonne/year | 1. Collected from an anaerobic digestion facility. 2. LF from digestate is heated to evaporate water and release NH₃.3. NH₃-rich vapor is condensed and captured in water. 4. Resulting in a weak ammonium water solution (BE-AW). | NH₃ captured in condensed water after LF evaporation. Thermal evaporation, NH₃ release, condensation. Digestate evaporation → NH₃ gas capture → water absorption → storage. | https://www.fertimanure.eu/en/publication/consult/64 | BE-AW, BE-AN, BE-AS | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | BE-AS Ammonium water - liquid | 1.9 | 0.1 | 3 | 1 | 0.2 | 1.8 | 724 tonne/year | Mobile | 7 | Yes | Not known | Medium | Medium | EU Southwest | Belgium | Thechnology is as a the pilot plant. | https://www.fertimanure.eu/en/publication/consult/64 | https://www.fertimanure.eu/en/publication/consult/64 | FERTIMANURE/project completed | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||
T63 | Struvite from zootechnical wastewater and digestates purification | Treatment of zootechnical wastewater and digestates to reduce emissions and struvite production | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses:zootechnical wastewater | Agricultural Biomasses: digestation waste | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | Clarification of the digested sludge in a solid-liquid separator, microfiltration, crystallization in a concentric reactor, increasing the pH by removing CO2 and alkalization, struvite precipitation, collection of the product from the bottom of the reactor. | Anaerobic digestion involves the mineralization of part of the organic nitrogen present in animal excrements to ammonium nitrogen and part of the organic phosphorus to inorganic orthophosphate (PO4 3-). Therefore, the waste from anaerobic digestion is an optimal matrix for the process of nitrogen and phosphorus recovery through precipitation and crystallization of struvite (ammonium magnesium phosphate hexahydrate - MgNH4 PO4 6H2 O). The digested sludge is clarified by a solid-liquid separator and collected in a tank. Then it is pumped to a cylindrical crystallization reactor (the main element of the process), concentric to the inverted conical reactor, where the next phase of struvite precipitation takes place (retention time was 7 hours). Struvite is collected from the bottom, while the clarified supernatant is discharged through the upper end. The blower forces air through a porous cup into a cylindrical crystallization reactor, which has the dual function of mixing and increasing pH by removing CO2. The alkaline pH of the wastewater increases the efficiency of the struvite precipitation process (alkalization with 30% sodium hydroxide (NaOH) solution in combination with the addition of 15% MgCl₂ solution). A 40-micron microfiltration system was installed before the precipitation and crystallization reactor to ensure that the initial crystallization process using the wastewater was free from suspended solids and coarse particles that would hinder the formation of struvite. | https://www.nutri-know.eu/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/GOI_Opuscolo_STRUVITE.pdf (p. 3) | Struvite | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | Static | 7 | No | Yes | High | Low | EU Southwest | Italy, Emilia-Romagna | 1) For areas where there is a large number of livestock farms 2) It promotes the relocation of excess nitrogen and phosphorus from areas with a high level of animal breeding to areas characterized by a demand for mineral fertilizers 3) The possibility of reducing the emission of ammonia, methane and nitrous oxide into the atmosphere both in the storage and distribution phases | Centro Ricerche Produzioni Animali - CRPA Soc. Cons. p. A. http://struvite.crpa.it/ | https://www.nutri-know.eu/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/GOI_Opuscolo_STRUVITE.pdf https://eufarmbook.eu/en/contributions/661ea295957f6433af637260 https://eufarmbook.eu/en/contributions/661f794ead7afadbfd522b0a https://eufarmbook.eu/en/contributions/6620df110beeac6e7e3858f9 https://eufarmbook.eu/en/contributions/661f7b42ad7afadbfd522bd0 https://eufarmbook.eu/en/contributions/661f748cad7afadbfd52292c | NUTRI-KNOW / project ongoing | LCA: https://www.nutri-know.eu/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/GOI_Opuscolo_STRUVITE.pdf (p. 5-7) https://eufarmbook.eu/en/contributions/661f7ea60beeac6e7e38160f | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||||||||
T64 | Ammonium sulfate by GAS LOOP | Air washing system from ammonia emissions in pig farming by producing ammonium sulphate solution using a GAS LOOP | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: ammonia emissions in pig farming | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | In a pig farm with an average live weight of 1,150 t (approximately 10,500 fattening places), 16.8 t N/year could be recovered, with a consequent reduction in emissions of 20.3 t NH3/year (1.94 kg NH3/animal place per year). | Chemical absorption of ammonia from air by counter-current washing with an acid reagent (H2SO4) in a tower with packing bodies. The formed, a stable ammonium sulphate (suspension (NH4)2SO4) is collected in a tank at the base of the washing tower. When the ammonium sulphate suspension reaches a nitrogen content of about 6%, it is partially extracted and the level is automatically restored with water from the water supply. | The device draws ammonia-rich air from the stable through suction channels located below the slatted floor. The treatment is based on the chemical absorption of ammonia by counter-current washing with an acid reagent in a tower with packing bodies. The ammonia-rich air rises in the tower sucked by a centrifugal fan, while a washing solution containing dilute sulfuric acid rains down from above. The sulfuric acid (H2SO4) reacts with ammonia (NH3) to form a stable suspension of ammonium sulphate ((NH4)2SO4) that accumulates in a tank at the base of the washing tower. The device was equipped with a pH control system for the washing solution because the absorbed ammonia has a buffering effect on the acid solution and the treatment efficiency would be compromised when neutral pH is reached. When the correct pH value of 4.5 is exceeded, a dosing pump is activated, which draws new acid until the pH is restored to a value of 4. When the ammonium sulphate suspension in the tank reaches a nitrogen content of approximately 6% (which corresponds to a 28% ammonium sulphate solution), it is partially extracted and the level is automatically restored with water from the water supply. Suitable filling bodies, by wetting and incorporating the acidic ammonia capture solution into the interstices, serve to increase the contact surface, increasing washing efficiency. A demister, located in the upper part of the tower, allows any droplets to condense, preventing them from being carried over. The treatment system has been implemented with sensors and logic for continuous operation (24 hours a day, 7 days a week). | https://www.nutri-know.eu/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/GAS-LOOP_CRPA_Opuscolo.pdf (p. 2) | Liquid ammonium sulfate | heat | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | 1.2 | 4.9 | 300 liters/ton of body weight per year | Static | 8 | Yes | Yes | Medium | Medium | EU Southwest | Italy, Reggio Emilia | In winter and summer, the removal of ammonia from the air is associated with poor efficiency. | Centro Ricerche Produzioni Animali - CRPA Soc. Cons. p. A. https://gasloop.crpa.it/ https://ammonia.crpa.it/ | https://www.nutri-know.eu/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/GAS-LOOP_CRPA_Opuscolo.pdf https://www.nutri-know.eu/operational-group/gasloop/ https://gasloop.crpa.it/nqcontent.cfm?a_id=22324 https://www.nutri-know.eu/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/SN_01_2022_p30_33.pdf https://eufarmbook.eu/en/contributions/66213953ad7afadbfd527ba6 https://eufarmbook.eu/en/contributions/66213a1e6711e677db51123f https://sway.cloud.microsoft/8e3pYfx2NrcN6HmU?ref=Link&loc=play https://eufarmbook.eu/en/contributions/66213aa4ad7afadbfd527c0e | NUTRI-KNOW / project ongoing | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||||||
T65 | Ammonium nitrate | Liquid fraction of manure (slurry) or digestate. Manure can be from pigs, cows or poultry. | Treated manure | Treated manure | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Ammonium (NH4+), present in manure and digestate, is in balance with ammonia (NH3), which is volatile. Under the influence of pH and temperature, the ratio of ammonia to ammonium can be increased so that the ammonia nitrogen can volatilize more quickly. By blowing in air, the volatile ammonia is removed from the liquid fraction and the nitrogen (N) can be recovered. The air from the stripper, enriched with ammonia, is chemically bound to nitric acid in the scrubber into ammonium nitrate. | Ammonium nitrate | 1.C.I | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 9.0-18.0 | 0.001-0.003 | 0.003-0.061 | 2-8 m³ liquid fraction/hour | 8 | No | Not know | Medium | EU Southwest | Flanders, Belgium | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||
T66 | Ammonium sulphate | Liquid fraction of manure (slurry) or digestate. Manure can be from pigs, cows or poultry. | Treated manure | Treated manure | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Ammonium (NH4+), present in manure and digestate, is in balance with ammonia (NH3), which is volatile. Under the influence of pH and temperature, the ratio of ammonia to ammonium can be increased so that the ammonia nitrogen can volatilize more quickly. By blowing in air, the volatile ammonia is removed from the liquid fraction and the nitrogen (N) can be recovered. The air from the stripper, enriched with ammonia, is chemically bound to nitric acid in the scrubber into ammonium nitrate. | Ammonium sulphate | 1.C.I | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 5.0-7.0 | 0.001-0.003 | 7-9 S; 23-25 SO3 | 67-85 fresh weight | 2-8 m³ liquid fraction/hour | 8 | 1 | Not know | Medium | EU Southwest | Flanders, Belgium | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||||||||
T67 | Animal Bone Char BIO-NPK-C | Biological by-products | Cattle bones and other inputs are an unexploited biomass | Cattle bones and other inputs are an unexploited biomass | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | The core treatment element of the animal bone char (ABC) BIO-NPK-C compound biofertiliser is the 3R zero emission and energy independent novel pyrolysis process where crude animal bone meal is high temperature treated and converted into refined animal bone char with unique characteristics that is economical high nutrient density 35 P2O5 content and fully macroporous structure, which material is then further biotech formulated. In the safe 3R process no chemicals are used and solely biological origin natural materials are applied. The standard factory output industrial capacity of the ABC BIO-NPK-C compound biofertiliser is 25,000 t/y per installation. The ABC BIO-NPK-C compound biofertiliser is creating high financial and non-financial values and market competitive benefits for the user. | Animal Bone Char BIO-NPK-C | Depending on compostion and porperties: PFCs 1.A.I, 3.A, or 6.B | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 50.0 DM | 50.0 DM | Formulated by user demand | 35 P2O5 | 25 000 tonnes output/year per unit, regionally decentralized, year round production | 8 | Not know | Medium | EU North/Central/Southwest/Southeast | Europe | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||
T68 | Biochar | Treated manure | Raw manure or digestate. Manure can be from pigs, cows or poultry. | Raw manure or digestate. Manure can be from pigs, cows or poultry. | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Biochar is produced by heating biomass in the total or partial absence of oxygen. Pyrolysis is the most common technology employed to produce biochar. The process of thermal decomposition of organic materials in an oxygen-free environment under the temperature range of 250-900°C. | Biochar | N.A. | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 39.3 organic C FM | 39.3 organic C FM | 1.5 | 1.1 | 3.7 | 0.28 | 0.00069 | 7.8 fresh weight | 8 | Not know | Medium | EU Southwest | Flanders, Belgium | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||||||
T69 | Champost | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses | Mixture of mushroom substrate (horse manure, straw, chicken manure, gypsum, water) and casing soil (peat and sugar beet scum) after growth of mushrooms and high temperature treatment. | CMC 10 | Champost | PFC 3A | 214 g | 6.3 g | 4 g P2O5/kg | 8.7 g K2O/kg | 9 | Not know | Medium | EU North/Central/Southwest/Southeast | Europe | https://vilt.be/nl/nieuws/champignontelers-kampen-met-groot-gebrek-aan-arbeidskrachten | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
T70 | Biochar | Biowaste | Two major fractions are garden and park waste & food and kitchen waste. Which are infinitely available | Two major fractions are garden and park waste & food and kitchen waste. Which are infinitely available | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | The stages of the process are: 1. Physical separation of improper materials (sieving/shorting). 2. Drying of the pretreated biowaste (BW) at least 85 dry solids 3. Pyrolysis of the pretreated BW and separation of the biochar from the rest of the products obtained. An alternative is to treat the BW by anaerobic digestion, and use the solid fraction of the digestate obtained as raw material for pyrolysis. In this case, it is necessary to previously dry said solid fraction. | Biochar | Depending on composition and properties: PFC 1.A.I or PFC 3.A. | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 37.4 organic C FM; 44.4 Organic C DM | 37.4 organic C FM; 44.4 Organic C DM | 2.8 N FM; 3.3 N DM from food waste | 1.4 P2O5 FM; 0.7 P DM (from food waste) | 0.9 K2O DM (from food waste) 0.75 K DM | 5.2 Ca DM (from food waste) | 0.5 Mg DM (from food waste) | 10-20 fresh weight | 8 | Not know | Medium | EU North/Central/Southwest/Southeast | Europe | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||||||
T71 | Composted animal manure | Treated manure | Raw manure or solid fraction of raw manure/digestate/activated sludge | Raw manure or solid fraction of raw manure/digestate/activated sludge | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | 4.3 M tonnes/year | Biothermal drying (composting) is a natural process in which living organisms (bacteria, funghi, protozoa, etc.) convert fresh organic matter under controlled conditions and in the presence of oxygen into homogeneous, stable and humus-rich (organic matter) compost. | Composted animal manure | N.A | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 4.1 OM | 4.1 OM | 2 | 3 P2O5 | 1.8 K2O | 5.7 CaO | 1.5 MgO | 1.8 SO3 | 45 fresh weight | 841 000 tonnes/year (current capacity of the 15 plants in Flanders) | 9 | 15 in Flanders | Not know | Medium | medium | EU Southwest | Flanders, Belgium | Potentially solid-liquid separation pre tratment | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||
T72 | Composted animal manure | Treated manure | Treated manure from cattle, pig and poultry Infinite source | Treated manure from cattle, pig and poultry Infinite source | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Solid-Liquid (SL) separation, and subsequent composting of the solid fraction obtained. - The SL separation stage may not be necessary depending on the humidity of the manure, since it is highly variable depending on the type (cattle manure, pig slurry, etc.). - Before composting, an anaerobic digestion (AD) stage can be carried out (with or without previous SL separation). The digestate is dewatered, and the solid fraction is composted. | Composted animal manure | N.A | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 35.0 organic C DM | 35.0 organic C DM | 1.6 N FM; 2.3 N DM | 0.8 P2O5 FM; 0.5 P DM | 1.4 K DM | 1.3-6.4 Ca DM | 0.4-0.9 Mg DM | 10-40 fresh weight | Centralised and decentralised production, capacity from farm-scale to >60,000 tonnes/yr | 9 | 1486 installations | Not know | Medium | EU North/Central/Southwest/Southeast | Europe | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||||
T73 | Composted bio-waste (food waste and green compost) | Biowaste | Food waste and green waste | Food waste and green waste | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | 3.2 M tonnes/year | Biothermal drying (composting) is a natural process in which living organisms (bacteria, funghi, protozoa, etc.) convert fresh organic matter under controlled conditions and in the presence of oxygen into homogeneous, stable and humus-rich (organic matter) compost. | Composted bio-waste (food waste and green compost) | 3.A | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 19.8 organic C FM; Avg.: 28.3; Italian law: >20 Organic C / dry weight. | 19.8 organic C FM; Avg.: 28.3; Italian law: >20 Organic C / dry weight. | 1.4 N FM; Average: 1.8-2.2 DM No limit according to Italian law. | 0.8 P2O5 FM; 0.8-1.4 P2O5 DM; No limit according to Italian law. | 1.1 K2O FM; 1.3-1.7 K2O DM. No limit according to Italian law. | 3.1 Ca | 0.7 | 25-32 fresh weight; Italian law: < 50 fresh weight | 870 000 tonnes/year | 9 | 294 | Not know | Medium | medium | EU Southwest | Italy | NATURLAND | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | https://www.naturland.de/es/productores/proyectos/investigacion-y-redes/fer-play.html | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||
T74 | Composted bio-waste (food waste and green compost) | Biowaste | Food waste and green waste | Food waste and green waste | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Biothermal drying (composting) is a natural process in which living organisms (bacteria, funghi, protozoa, etc.) convert fresh organic matter under controlled conditions and in the presence of oxygen into homogeneous, stable and humus-rich (organic matter) compost. | Composted bio-waste (food waste and green compost) | 3.A | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | Reg. (EU) 2019/1009 limit: > 7.5 Organic C / wet weight | Reg. (EU) 2019/1009 limit: > 7.5 Organic C / wet weight | According to Reg. (EU) 2019/1009 no limit applies | According to Reg. (EU) 2019/1009 no limit applies | According to Reg. (EU) 2019/1009 no limit applies | Reg. (EU) 2019/1009 limit: < 80 w.w. | 8 | About 2200 | Not know | Medium | EU North/Central/Southwest/Southeast | EU27 | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
T75 | Composted bio-waste (green compost) | Biowaste | Biowaste such as food and garden waste | Biowaste such as food and garden waste | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Bio-waste (food waste and garden waste) can be composted either aerobically or anaerobically therefore producing a fertiliser or soil enhancer. | Composted bio-waste (green compost) | 3.A | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 34.5 organic C FM; 59.5 OM (for organic compost) | 34.5 organic C FM; 59.5 OM (for organic compost) | 2.8 N (for organic compost) | 2.6 P2O5 FM; 1.2 P (for organic compost) | 2.4 K2O FM; 2.0 K (for organic compost) | 0.68 Ca (for organic compost) | 12.45 S (for organic compost) | 30 fresh weight | 17.6 M tonnes/year is produced in EU27. In 2016, in the Netherlands, over 75 kg of compost from biowaste was produced per person. In Flanders and Austria between 45-50 kg of compost was produced per person in 2016. | 9 | 3800 composting plants for biowaste treatment across the EU27, CH, NO & UK (88 of these plants solely treat biowaste) | Not know | Medium | EU North/Central/Southwest/Southeast | Europe | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||||
T76 | Composted bio-waste (green compost) | Biowaste | 5 M tonnes green waste/year in Germany | 5 M tonnes green waste/year in Germany | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Biothermal drying (composting) is a natural process in which living organisms (bacteria, funghi, protozoa, etc.) convert fresh organic matter under controlled conditions and in the presence of oxygen into homogeneous, stable and humus-rich (organic matter) compost. | Composted bio-waste (green compost) | 3.A | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 25.2 organic C FM; 36.0 DM | 25.2 organic C FM; 36.0 DM | 0.7 N FM | 0.2 P FM | 0.5 FM | 2.2 Ca FM | 0.3 | 0.06-0.12 S FM | 30 fresh weight | Year round production | 8 | Not know | Medium | EU Central | Germany | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||||
T77 | Composted digestate | Digestate | Co-digestion anaerobic plant using diverse feedstocks | Co-digestion anaerobic plant using diverse feedstocks | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | 180 M tonnes/year | For digestate to be composted, other feedstocks are generally used, such as garden waste. Practically, some AD plants compost their raw digestate, while other compost the solid fraction of the digestate after it undergoes a solid/liquid separation. Biothermal drying (composting) is a natural process in which living organisms (bacteria, funghi, protozoa, etc.) convert fresh organic matter under controlled conditions and in the presence of oxygen into homogeneous, stable and humus-rich (organic matter) compost. | Composted digestate | 3.A or 1.A.I/1.A.II - depending on nutient content | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 11.6 organic C FM; 40.0 OM DM | 11.6 organic C FM; 40.0 OM DM | 1.1 N FM; 2.1 N DM | 7 P2O5 FM; 0.6 DM | 7.0 K2O FM; 1.2 DM | 2.85 Ca DM | 0.49 | 0.24 DM | 50 fresh weight | Year round production | 9 | 19 000 AD plants. Composting unknown | Not know | Medium | EU North/Central/Southwest/Southeast | Europe | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||
T78 | Composted digestate from food waste and green waste | Digestate | 3 million tonnes of food waste and 0.4 million tonnes of green waste in Italy | 3 million tonnes of food waste and 0.4 million tonnes of green waste in Italy | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Biothermal drying (composting) is a natural process in which living organisms (bacteria, funghi, protozoa, etc.) convert fresh organic matter under controlled conditions and in the presence of oxygen into homogeneous, stable and humus-rich (organic matter) compost. | Composted digestate from food waste and green waste | 3.A | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 19.8 organic C FM; Average: 28.3; Italian law: >20 Organic C / dry weight. | 19.8 organic C FM; Average: 28.3; Italian law: >20 Organic C / dry weight. | 1.54 N FM; Average: 2.2 DM. No limit according to Italian law. | 0.8 P2O5 FM; 1.4 P2O5 DM; No limit according to Italian law | 1.1 K2O FM; 1.7 K2O DM. No limit according to Italian law. | 3.1 | 0.7 | 920 000 tonnes/year | 9 | 58 | Not know | Medium | EU Southwest | Italy | CIC | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | https://www.mater.polimi.it/en/cic-biowaste-italia-2/ | CETENMA | ||||||||||||||||||||
T79 | Composted sewage sludge | Sewage sludge | Sewage sludge is a renewable resource, it is never composted alone, but usually with green and food waste. | Sewage sludge is a renewable resource, it is never composted alone, but usually with green and food waste. | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Biothermal drying (composting) is a natural process in which living organisms (bacteria, funghi, protozoa, etc.) convert fresh organic matter under controlled conditions and in the presence of oxygen into homogeneous, stable and humus-rich (organic matter) compost. | Composted sewage sludge | 3.A | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 17.2 organic C FM; Average: 27.7; Italian law: >20 Organic C / dry weight. | 17.2 organic C FM; Average: 27.7; Italian law: >20 Organic C / dry weight. | 1.6 N FM; Average: 2.5 N DM; No limit according to Italian law. | Average: 38 fresh weight; Italian law: < 50 fresh weight | 427 000 tonnes/year, Decentralised production all year round | 9 | 62 | Not know | Medium | EU Southwest | Italy | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||||||||
T80 | Composted sewage sludge | Sewage sludge | Sewage sludge is a renewable resource, it is never composted alone, but usually with green and food waste. | Sewage sludge is a renewable resource, it is never composted alone, but usually with green and food waste. | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Biothermal drying (composting) is a natural process in which living organisms (bacteria, funghi, protozoa, etc.) convert fresh organic matter under controlled conditions and in the presence of oxygen into homogeneous, stable and humus-rich (organic matter) compost. | Composted sewage sludge | 3.A | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 17.2 organic C FM; Average: 27.7; Italian law: >20 Organic C / dry weight. | 17.2 organic C FM; Average: 27.7; Italian law: >20 Organic C / dry weight. | 1.6 N FM; Average: 2.5 N DM; No limit according to Italian law. | Average: 38 fresh weight; Italian law: < 50 fresh weight | 427 000 tonnes/year, Decentralised production all year round | 9 | 62 | Not know | Medium | EU Southwest | Italy | CIC | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | https://www.mater.polimi.it/en/cic-biowaste-italia-2/ | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||||||
T81 | Enriched biosolids with struvite | Digestate | Digested sludge from municipal treatment | Digested sludge from municipal treatment | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Struvite crystallisation process: struvite is produced in a CSTR with agitation and pH control. Mg salt is dosed according to the selected molar dosage ratio Mg/P. | Enriched biosolids with struvite | No regulation as it is discarded as waste | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 2.1 organic C FM; 1.8-2.0 | 2.1 organic C FM; 1.8-2.0 | 0.1 N FM | 0.2 P2O5 FM | 1.0 | 80-82 fresh weight; 44 g/m³ | 401.5 tonnes/year | 9 | 1 | Not know | Medium | EU Southwest | Nieuwegein, The Netherlands | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||||||
T82 | Feather meal | Biological by-products | Hygienized feathers | Hygienized feathers | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Feather meal is a byproduct of poultry processing. Poultry feathers are treated by thermal hydrolysis, dried and crushed. | Feather meal | 1.A.I | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 48.4 FM organic C; 92.7 OM | 48.4 FM organic C; 92.7 OM | 9.9 N FM; 11.0 N | 0.8 P2O5 FM; 0.4 P | 1.8 K2O FM; 1.6 K | 0.85 | 0.18 | 1.40 S | Year round production | 9 | Not know | Medium | EU Central | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||||||
T83 | Hair powder pellets | Biological by-products | Hygienized pig bristles | Hygienized pig bristles | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Hair powder pellets | 1.A.I | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 48.9 FM organic C; 93.6 OM | 48.9 FM organic C; 93.6 OM | 12.3 N FM | 1.1 P2O5 FM; 0.5 P | 0.3 K2O FM; 0.3 K | 0.99 | 0.09 | 1.79 S | Year round production | 9 | Not know | Medium | EU Central | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
T84 | Horn grit/horn chips | Biological by-products | Hygienized horns and hoofs | Hygienized horns and hoofs | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Horn grit/horn chips | 1.A.I | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 46.2 FM organic C; 88.5 OM | 46.2 FM organic C; 88.5 OM | 13.3 N FM | 0.8 P2O5 FM; 0.4 P | 0.3 K2O FM; 0.3 K | 1.32 | 0.15 | 2.26 S | Year round production | 8 | Not know | Medium | EU Central | Germany | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||||||
T85 | Hydrochar | Biowaste | Two major fractions are garden and park waste & food and kitchen waste. Which are infinitely available | Two major fractions are garden and park waste & food and kitchen waste. Which are infinitely available | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | The stages of the process are: 1. Physical separation of improper materials (sieving/shorting). 2. Mixing of the pre-treated biowaste (BW) with water and hydrothermal carbonization of the mixture. 3. Solid-Liquid separation of the carbonised media. 4. Treatment of the liquid fraction and dewatering-drying of the solid fraction. An alternative is to treat the BW by anaerobic digestion, and use the digestate (undried) as feedstock for hydrothermal carbonization. | Hydrochar | Depending on composition and properties: PFC 1.A.I or PFC 3.A. | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 2.05 N FM; 0.2-3.9 N DM | 3 P2O5 FM; 0 - 2.8 P DM | 0-0.29 K2O DM; 0-0.24 K DM | 5.7 | 1.3 | 0.1-0.7 S DM | 0.2 fresh weight | 8 | Some pilot scale plants. Some pilot-scale HTC (hydrothermal carbonization) plants have been constructed (Ingelia, HTCycle, Terranova Energy, Ava CO2). Some full-scale projects have been developed with different biomass wastes, such as sewage sludge, animal manure, biowaste, lignocellulosic biomass and mixed residues. | Not know | Medium | EU Southwest | Europe | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||||||
T86 | K-struvite | Urban wastewater | Urban wastewater is infinitely available | Urban wastewater is infinitely available | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Source-separated human urine is considered one of the most important target effluents to produce K-struvite. Urine is present in urban wastewater; however, the studies were performed with synthetic water (synthetic human urine). Based on the literature reports, it became clear that some aspects need further research to improve the technology. The precipitation of K-struvite is characterized by great complexity due to its solubility and the substances that inhibit the process. These problems have been greatly facilitated by modeling studies. However, solving these research problems in lab studies is a crucial issue if the technology is to be suitable for real effluents. In addition, to apply K-struvite as a slow-release fertilizer, technological improvements are required to produce high purity crystals and large dimensions (so that they can be easily recovered). The formation of fine crystals is the most frequent problem during precipitation applications. Although some laboratory tests have been carried out (with widely disparate technologies), efforts continue to improve this type of recovery and reduce operational inconvenience. Review about different proof of concept: Is K-Struvite Precipitation a Plausible Nutrient Recovery Method from Potassium-Containing Wastes? (Kabda¸slı et al., 2022). | K-struvite | 1.C.I.a.ii | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 8.1 P2O5 FM; 3.6 P DM | 14.7 K DM | Year round productivity | 3 | Not know | Medium | EU Central | None (Lab scale) | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
T87 | K-Struvite | Treated manure | Veal manure | Veal manure | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Precipitation of K-struvite in the liquid fraction obtained in the dewatering process consisting of raising the pH and subsequent addition of Mg2+. NH4+ competes with K+ to precipitate with PO43- and Mg2+, so the NH4+/K+ ratio of the liquid fraction is relevant. In this sense, some manures, are more appropriate than others. Growth of crystals, settling, dewatering, washing and drying of crystals. | K-Struvite | 1.C.I.a.ii | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 0.6 organic C FM | 0.6 organic C FM | 28.4 P2O5 FM; 12.5 P | 5.9 K2O FM; 5.2 K | 1.8 | 13.2 | 1500 tonnes/year | 9 | 1 in the Netherlands | Not know | Medium | EU Southwest | Putten, The Netherlands | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||||||
T88 | K-struvite | Digestate | Anaerobic digestion of several organic and biodegradable wastes | Anaerobic digestion of several organic and biodegradable wastes | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | 1. Dewatering of the digestate. 2. Precipitation of K-struvite in the liquid fraction obtained in the dewatering. Process consisting of raising the pH and subsequent addition of Mg2+. NH4+ competes with K+ to precipitate with PO43- and Mg2+, so the NH4+/K+ ratio of the liquid fraction is relevant. In this sense, some digestates, such as the digestate from manure, are more appropriate than others. 3. Growth of crystals, settling, dewatering, washing and drying of crystals. | K-struvite | 1.C.I.a.ii | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 0 | 0 | Not know | Medium | EU North/Central/Southwest/Southeast | Europe | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
T89 | digestate | Liquid fraction of Digestate | Co-digestion anaerobic plant using diverse feedstocks | Co-digestion anaerobic plant using diverse feedstocks | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Digestate is obtained after the anaerobic digestion of organic feedstocks in a reactor. In order to retrieve the liquid phase of the digestate, a phase separation process is required. It separates the liquid phase from the solid fraction of the digestate. Several technologies are available: belt press, sieve drum, screw press, sieve or decanter centrifuge, and possibly with the use of chemicals to boost separation. It is important to note that the separation process might impact the characteristic of the solid and liquid fractions. Furthermore, some plants also apply a treatment to the liquid fraction such as ammonia-stripping. The liquid fraction of digestate contains high residual of organic compounds. | Liquid fraction of digestate | 0 | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 2.0 organic C FM; 70.0 OM | 2.0 organic C FM; 70.0 OM | 0.5 N FM; 9.0 TKN | 0.01-1.4 P2O5; | 0.026 K2O FM; 5.2 K2O | 0.015 | 0.05 Mg | 0.03 | >95 fresh weight | 80-90 of the digestate is liquid fraction | 9 | 19 000 | Not know | Medium | EU North/Central/Southwest/Southeast | Europe | coldiretti | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | https://www.coldiretti.it/ | CETENMA | ||||||||||||||||||
T90 | Solid fraction of digestate | Digestate | Co-digestion anaerobic plant using diverse feedstocks | Co-digestion anaerobic plant using diverse feedstocks | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Digestate is obtained after the anaerobic digestion of organic feedstocks in a reactor. In order to retrieve the liquid phase of the digestate, a phase separation process is required. It separates the liquid phase from the solid fraction of the digestate. Several technologies are available: belt press, sieve drum, screw press, sieve or decanter centrifuge, and possibly with the use of chemicals to boost separation. It is important to note that the separation process might impact the characteristic of the solid and liquid fractions. Solid fractions of digestate contain more phosphorous. In this database, the data on the solid fraction of the digestate are gathered for the after source separation, and not for the further processing of the solid fraction using for instance composting methods. | Solid fraction of digestate | ambuguous (1.A.I or 1.A.II) | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 27.4 organic C FM; 23.0-95.0 OM | 27.4 organic C FM; 23.0-95.0 OM | 2.1 N FM; 1.2-3.0 N DM | 3 P2O5 FM; 0.4-3.5 P DM; | 21.0 K2O FM; 0.1-5.0 DM | 0.7-6.5 | 0.2-2.0 Mg DM | 0.4-2.0 | 15-25 fresh weight | 10-20 of the digestate is solid fraction | 9 | 19 000 | Not know | Medium | EU North/Central/Southwest/Southeast | Europe | ACR+ | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | https://www.acrplus.org/en | CETENMA | ||||||||||||||||||
T91 | Liquid fraction of digestate | Digestate | Co-digestion anaerobic plant using diverse feedstocks | Co-digestion anaerobic plant using diverse feedstocks | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Digestate is obtained after the anaerobic digestion of organic feedstocks in a reactor. In order to retrieve the liquid phase of the digestate, a phase separation process is required. It separates the liquid phase from the solid fraction of the digestate. Several technologies are available: belt press, sieve drum, screw press, sieve or decanter centrifuge, and possibly with the use of chemicals to boost separation. It is important to note that the separation process might impact the characteristic of the solid and liquid fractions. Furthermore, some plants also apply a treatment to the liquid fraction such as ammonia-stripping. The liquid fraction of digestate contains high residual of organic compounds. | Liquid fraction of digestate | 0 | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 2.0 organic C FM; 70.0 OM | 2.0 organic C FM; 70.0 OM | 0.5 N FM; 9.0 TKN | 0.01-1.4 P2O5; | 0.026 K2O FM; 5.2 K2O | 0.015 | 0.05 | 0.03 | >95 fresh weight | 80-90 of the digestate is liquid fraction | 9 | 19 000 | Not know | Medium | medium | EU North/Central/Southwest/Southeast | Europe | https://systemicproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/Factsheet-product-liquid-fraction-digestate.pdf | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | ||||||||||||||||||
T92 | Meat-, bonemeal | Biological by-products | Pasteurized, pressure sterilized, dried meat bone meal | Pasteurized, pressure sterilized, dried meat bone meal | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Meat- and bonemeal are byproducts from the rendering industry. Slaughterhouse waste is ground, heated, percolated and further ground. | Meat-, bonemeal | 1.A.I | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 48.1 FM organic C; 92.2 OM | 48.1 FM organic C; 92.2 OM | 9.0 N FM | 7.3 P2O5 FM; 3.6 P | 0.7 K2O FM; 0.6 K | 7.9 | 0.25 | 0.97 | 0 | Year round production | 9 | Not know | Medium | EU Central | Germany | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||||
T93 | Mineral concentrate | Treated manure | Liquid fraction of manure (slurry) or digestate. Manure can be from pigs, cows or poultry. | Liquid fraction of manure (slurry) or digestate. Manure can be from pigs, cows or poultry. | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Mineral concentrate is produced via membrane separation. After a solid-liquid separation, the liquid fraction is processed further to remove particles. The cleaned effluent enters reverse osmosis, where water is pushed under pressure through semi-permeable membranes, leading to a concentrate of minerals and a permeate (clean water). | Mineral concentrate | 1.C.I.b.ii | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 2.4 organic C FM; 1.0-10.0 OM | 2.4 organic C FM; 1.0-10.0 OM | 0.6-10 N | 0.4 P2O5 FM; 0.01-0.3 P | 9.5 K2O FM; 0.8-15 K | 97 fresh weight | 20 000-135 000 m³/year | 9 | 5 in Flanders in 2021 | Not know | Medium | EU Southwest | Flanders, Belgium | INAGRO | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | https://www.in-agro.com/ | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||||
T94 | Mineral concentrate | Treated manure | Liquid fraction of manure (slurry) or digestate. Manure can be from pigs, cows or poultry. | Liquid fraction of manure (slurry) or digestate. Manure can be from pigs, cows or poultry. | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | 20 000-135 000 m³/year | Mineral concentrate is produced via membrane separation. After a solid-liquid separation, the liquid fraction is processed further to remove particles. The cleaned effluent enters reverse osmosis, where water is pushed under pressure through semi-permeable membranes, leading to a concentrate of minerals and a permeate (clean water). | Mineral concentrate | 1.C.I.b.ii | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 2.4 organic C FM; 1.0-10.0 OM | 2.4 organic C FM; 1.0-10.0 OM | 0.6-10 | 0.4 P2O5 FM; 0.01-0.3 P | 9.5 K2O FM; 0.8-15 K | 97 fresh weight | 20 000-135 000 m³/year | 9 | 5 in Flanders in 2021 | Not know | Medium | EU Southwest | Flanders, Belgium | https://cdn.digisecure.be/vcm/2022928112135383_rapport-mestverwerking-2021.pdf | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||||
T95 | P-rich ashes | Digestate | Anaerobic digestion of several organic and biodegradable wastes | Anaerobic digestion of several organic and biodegradable wastes | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | 1. Dewatering and drying of the obtained digestate. 2. Dried digestate direct combustion. The ashes obtained will contain a large part of the heavy metals contained in the initial digestate. On the other hand, the P from the ashes will be in a less soluble form and available to plants. For this reason, the ashes can be treated in a second stage to recover the P from the ashes, concentrate it and separate it as much as possible from the contaminants. This can be done in two ways: a) Wet-chemical treatment of the ashes. Dissolution of the ashes in an acid medium and subsequent recovery. It also involves the dissolution of part of the heavy metals in the ashes, as well as the Fe and Al present or added as coagulants. These metals can be removed, through various techniques, thus purifying the final product. P recovery yields between 70 and 98. b) Thermal treatment of the ashes. Nutrients can be recovered from ashes by high temperature treatments. Volatile heavy metals such as Zn, Pb, Cd and Hg are separated from the product via the gas phase and further collected in the flue dust, and heavy metals with high boiling points such as Fe, Cu, Ni and Cr are separated in the form of a liquid alloy. P recovery yields between 80 and 98. | P-rich ashes | 1.C.I.a.i. | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 1.5 organic C FM; 1.0-3.0 Organic C DM | 1.5 organic C FM; 1.0-3.0 Organic C DM | 34 P2O5 FM; 0.6-1.3 P DM | 2.0 K2O FM; 1.3-2.5 K DM | 4.5-6.1 | 9.3-13.2 | 0.1-0.5 | 0.6-3.3 fresh weight | 4 | Not know | Medium | EU North/Central/Southwest/Southeast | Europe | https://www.cewep.eu/waste-to-energy-plants-in-europe-in-2019/ | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | ||||||||||||||||||||||
T96 | Solid fraction of digestate | Digestate | Co-digestion anaerobic plant using diverse feedstocks | Co-digestion anaerobic plant using diverse feedstocks | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Digestate is obtained after the anaerobic digestion of organic feedstocks in a reactor. In order to retrieve the liquid phase of the digestate, a phase separation process is required. It separates the liquid phase from the solid fraction of the digestate. Several technologies are available: belt press, sieve drum, screw press, sieve or decanter centrifuge, and possibly with the use of chemicals to boost separation. It is important to note that the separation process might impact the characteristic of the solid and liquid fractions. Solid fractions of digestate contain more phosphorous. In this database, the data on the solid fraction of the digestate are gathered for the after source separation, and not for the further processing of the solid fraction using for instance composting methods. | Solid fraction of digestate | ambuguous (1.A.I or 1.A.II) | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 27.4 organic C FM; 23.0-95.0 OM | 27.4 organic C FM; 23.0-95.0 OM | 2.1 N FM; 1.2-3.0 N DM | 3 P2O5 FM; 0.4-3.5 P DM; | 21.0 K2O FM; 0.1-5.0 DM | 0.7-6.5 | 0.2-2.0 | 0.4-2.0 | 15-25 fresh weight | 10-20 of the digestate is solid fraction | 9 | 19 000 | Not know | Medium | EU North/Central/Southwest/Southeast | Europe | https://systemicproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/Factsheet-product-liquid-fraction-digestate.pdf | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||
T97 | Composted digestate | Digestate | Co-digestion anaerobic plant using diverse feedstocks | Co-digestion anaerobic plant using diverse feedstocks | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | For digestate to be composted, other feedstocks are generally used, such as garden waste. Practically, some AD plants compost their raw digestate, while other compost the solid fraction of the digestate after it undergoes a solid/liquid separation. Biothermal drying (composting) is a natural process in which living organisms (bacteria, funghi, protozoa, etc.) convert fresh organic matter under controlled conditions and in the presence of oxygen into homogeneous, stable and humus-rich (organic matter) compost. | Composted digestate | 3.A or 1.A.I/1.A.II - depending on nutient content | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 11.6 organic C FM; 40.0 OM DM | 11.6 organic C FM; 40.0 OM DM | 1.1 N FM; 2.1 N DM | 7 P2O5 FM; 0.6 DM | 7.0 K2O FM; 1.2 DM | 2.85 | 0.49 | 0.24 | 50 fresh weight | Year round production | 9 | 19 000 AD plants. Composting unknown | Not know | Medium | medium | EU North/Central/Southwest/Southeast | Europe | ACR+ | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | https://www.acrplus.org/en | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||
T98 | Solid fraction of manure (after separation) | Treated manure | Pig and cattle manure | Pig and cattle manure | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | One of the most used techniques for manure treatment in Flanders is the separation of the manure in a liquid and a solid fraction. In this way, nitrogen and potassium are concentrated in the liquid fraction and most of the phosphorus and organic matter remains in the solid fraction. To separate manure different techniques are available and the choice depends on the type of manure, the desired end product, the volume of the manure to be separated, etc. In Flanders, centrifuges, screw presses and belt presses are mainly used. | Solid fraction of manure (after separation) | N.A. | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 21.9-24.5 organic C FM | 21.9-24.5 organic C FM | 0.6-1.3 | 0.4-1.8 P2O5 | 0.6 K2O FM; 0.5-0.7 K2O | 70-76 fresh weight | 300 000 tonnes/year | 9 | 127 | Not know | Medium | EU Southwest | Flanders, Belgium | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||||||
T99 | Spent mushroom substrate | Treated manure | Mixture of mushroom substrate and casing soil. Mushroom substrate is made out of chicken manure, horse manure and/or straw, lime and water. | Mixture of mushroom substrate and casing soil. Mushroom substrate is made out of chicken manure, horse manure and/or straw, lime and water. | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Spent mushroom compost or substrate ("champost" in Dutch) is a by-product of mushroom cultivation. After the cultivation of mushrooms, the mushroom substrate and casing is directly loaded on truck and ready for disposal. From then on, the mixture is called "spent mushroom compost". | Spent mushroom substrate | 3.A | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 21.4 OM | 21.4 OM | 0.6 N | 0.4 P2O5 | 0.9 K2O | 4.5 | 0.24 MgO | 53-69 fresh weight | 570 000 tonnes mushroom substrate/year 270 000 tonnes champost/year 76 000 tonnes organic champost/year | 8 | 30 mushroom farmers | Not know | Medium | EU Southwest | Flanders, Belgium | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||||
T100 | Stabilised sludge | Urban wastewater | Urban wastewater is infinitely available | Urban wastewater is infinitely available | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | 4.1 M tonnes dry solids/year | Stabilised sludge is a sludge that undergoes a stabilisation process in which the contaminants present in the sludge are reduced into less potent forms. There are many "stabilisation" processes (anaerobic digestion being the most popular). Therefore, there is a certain variability in the characteristics of the obtained fertilisers. In addition, the characteristics of the stabilised sludge also depend on the collected wastewater and on the WWTP (wastewater treatment plant). | Stabilised sludge | N.A. | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 7.3 organic C FM | 7.3 organic C FM | 1.0 N FM; 4.0 N DM | 2 P2O5 FM; 3 P DM | 1.5 K DM | 0.5 | 1.0 Mg | 1.0 S | 75 fresh weight | 4.1 M tonnes dry solids/year | 9 | Not know | Medium | EU North/Central/Southwest/Southeast | Europe | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | ||||||||||||||||||||
T101 | Struvite | Urban wastewater | Urban wastewater is infinitely available. Partly also possible from organic waste and slaughterhouse waste digestate. | Urban wastewater is infinitely available. Partly also possible from organic waste and slaughterhouse waste digestate. | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Struvite crystallisation process: struvite is produced in a CSTR with agitation and pH control. Mg salt is dosed according to the selected molar dosage ratio Mg/P. | Struvite | 1.C.I.a.ii | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 0.6 organic C FM; 1.0 OM DM | 0.6 organic C FM; 1.0 OM DM | 5.7 N DM | 28.6 P2O5 FM; 12.6 P DM | 10 Mg | 0 | 250 tonnes/year | 9 | 1 | Not know | Medium | EU Southwest | The Netherlands | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||||||
T102 | Struvite | Urban wastewater | Urban wastewater is infinitely available | Urban wastewater is infinitely available | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | 990-1250 tonnes/year | 1. Removal of the P contained in the wastewater through a biological or chemical (precipitation with Fe or Al) process in the wastewater treatment plant (WWTP). The P goes into the sludge stream, partly assimilated in the biomass, and partly dissolved. 2. The further treatment will depend on whether or not the WWTP has an anaerobic digestion (AD) stage. 2.1. In WWTPs without AD, the removal of P is chemical in most cases. In this case, the soluble P fraction in the sludge is low, and may not be enough for the subsequent struvite precipitation step. In that case, pretreatments such as elutriation can be applied, adding volatile fatty acids to release the cellular P, or acidification to redissolve the precipitated P with Fe or Al. 2.2. In the WWTPs with AD, the removal of P from the water would have been biological or a combination of the two procedures in most cases. In this case, in AD, a large part of the P contained in the cells is released, increasing the concentration of soluble P in the digestate. This way, the application of the struvite precipitation process to the digestate is favoured. 3. Dewatering of the sludge stream (whether or not it comes from AD). 4. Precipitation of struvite in the liquid fraction obtained in the dewatering. Process consisting of raising the pH and subsequent addition of Mg2+. 5. Growth of crystals, settling, dewatering, washing and drying of crystals. Struvite precipitation can also be done by acting on the digestate before dewatering, and also on the solid fraction obtained after dewatering. These processes have a higher P recovery potential than treatment of the liquid fraction from dewatering, but will produce precipitates with more impurities, which must be washed and purified. | Struvite | 1.C.I.a.ii | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 2.1 organic C FM; 0.3-6.2 organic C DM | 2.1 organic C FM; 0.3-6.2 organic C DM | 5.7 N DM | 15.4 P2O5 FM; 7.5-13.5 P DM | 0.06-0.47 K DM | 0.5-6.7 Ca DM | 5.9-13.1 | 23-48; avg. 36 fresh weight | 990-1250 tonnes/year | 9 | 31 struvite production units in EU | Not know | High | EU North/Central/Southwest/Southeast | Europe | https://www.phosphorusfacts.eu/images/download/Kabbe_Tech_implementation-Table_20170208.pdf | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||
T103 | Struvite | Sewage sludge | Sewage sludge from urban or industrial wastewater is infinitely available | Sewage sludge from urban or industrial wastewater is infinitely available | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | The treatment to produce struvite begins with the collection of the wastewater. The streams from the wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) used for the production of struvite are the sludge supernatants. These streams present the higher phosphate and ammonia concentration in the WWTP. These influents are introduced into a crystalliser with the addition of magnesium chloride and sodium hydroxide. The addition of magnesium chloride is necessary to provide sufficient Mg2+ ions for the precipitation of the struvite. The amount added depends on the magnesium concentration in the reactor and in the feed, and on the molar Mg/P molar ratio. The dosing of the soda is carried out to raise and maintain the pH at an optimal value to promote crystallisation and precipitation. To promote fluidisation of the struvite in the crystalliser, air is also introduced through the lower part of the reactor. After some time with the crystalliser in "production" mode, some of the struvite formed must be extracted. | Struvite | 1.C.I.a.ii | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 1.6 organic C FM; 0.4 OM DM | 1.6 organic C FM; 0.4 OM DM | 14.4 P2O5 FM; 16.0 P2O5 DM | 0.13 Ca | 0.13 M | 10 fresh weight | Year round production | 8 | Not know | Medium | EU Southwest | Spain | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
T104 | Struvite | Industrial wastewater | Potato processing wastewater | Potato processing wastewater | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Struvite crystallisation process: struvite is produced in a CSTR with agitation and pH control. Mg salt is dosed according to the selected molar dosage ratio Mg/P. | https://nuresys.com/technology/ | Struvite | 1.C.I.a.ii | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 0.6 organic C FM; 1.0 OM DM | 0.6 organic C FM; 1.0 OM DM | 5.7 N DM | 28.6 P2O5 FM; 12.6 P DM | 10 | static | 9 | 1 | Not know | Medium | medium | EU Southwest | Nieuwkerke, Belgium | nuresys | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | https://nuresys.com/ | CETENMA | ||||||||||||||||||||
T105 | Struvite | Industrial wastewater | Potato processing wastewater | Potato processing wastewater | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Struvite crystallisation process: struvite is produced in a CSTR with agitation and pH control. Mg salt is dosed according to the selected molar dosage ratio Mg/P. | Struvite | 1.C.I.a.ii | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 0.6 organic C FM; 1.0 OM DM | 0.6 organic C FM; 1.0 OM DM | 5.7 N DM | 28.6 P2O5 FM; 12.6 P DM | 10 | 9 | 1 | Not know | Medium | EU Southwest | Warneton, Belgium | Nuresys | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
T106 | Struvite | Digestate | Digested sludge from municipal treatment | Digested sludge from municipal treatment | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Struvite crystallisation process: struvite is produced in a CSTR with agitation and pH control. Mg salt is dosed according to the selected molar dosage ratio Mg/P. | Struvite | 1.C.I.a.ii | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 5.8 organic C FM; 10.0 max DM | 5.8 organic C FM; 10.0 max DM | 5.7 N DM | 28.6 P2O5 FM; 12.6 P DM | 0.1 | 73 tonnes/year | 9 | 1 | Not know | Medium | EU Southwest | Leuven, Belgium | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
T107 | Struvite | Urban wastewater | Urban wastewater is infinitely available | Urban wastewater is infinitely available | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | 990-1250 tonnes/year | 1. Removal of the P contained in the wastewater through a biological or chemical (precipitation with Fe or Al) process in the wastewater treatment plant (WWTP). The P goes into the sludge stream, partly assimilated in the biomass, and partly dissolved. 2. The further treatment will depend on whether or not the WWTP has an anaerobic digestion (AD) stage. 2.1. In WWTPs without AD, the removal of P is chemical in most cases. In this case, the soluble P fraction in the sludge is low, and may not be enough for the subsequent struvite precipitation step. In that case, pretreatments such as elutriation can be applied, adding volatile fatty acids to release the cellular P, or acidification to redissolve the precipitated P with Fe or Al. 2.2. In the WWTPs with AD, the removal of P from the water would have been biological or a combination of the two procedures in most cases. In this case, in AD, a large part of the P contained in the cells is released, increasing the concentration of soluble P in the digestate. This way, the application of the struvite precipitation process to the digestate is favoured. 3. Dewatering of the sludge stream (whether or not it comes from AD). 4. Precipitation of struvite in the liquid fraction obtained in the dewatering. Process consisting of raising the pH and subsequent addition of Mg2+. 5. Growth of crystals, settling, dewatering, washing and drying of crystals. Struvite precipitation can also be done by acting on the digestate before dewatering, and also on the solid fraction obtained after dewatering. These processes have a higher P recovery potential than treatment of the liquid fraction from dewatering, but will produce precipitates with more impurities, which must be washed and purified. | Technology - NuReSys | Struvite | 1.C.I.a.ii | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 2.1 organic C FM; 0.3-6.2 organic C DM | 2.1 organic C FM; 0.3-6.2 organic C DM | 5.7 N DM | 15.4 P2O5 FM; 7.5-13.5 P DM | 0.06-0.47 K DM | 0.5-6.7 Ca DM | 5.9-13.1 | 23-48; avg. 36 fresh weight | 990-1250 tonnes/year | static | 9 | 31 struvite production units in EU | Not know | Medium | medium | EU North/Central/Southwest/Southeast | Europe | Nuresys | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | https://nuresys.com/ | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||
T108 | Tenebrio molitor (insect) frass | Digestate | Wheat bran | Wheat bran | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | The Tenebrio molitor (beetle larva) in its breeding process and through the digestion of the vegetable feed that is provided, generates this frass. | Tenebrio molitor (insect) frass | N.A. potentially 1.A.I | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 42.3 organic C FM | 42.3 organic C FM | 4.6 N FM; 5.0-5.3 | 4 P2O5 FM; 4.2-4.3 P2O5 DM | 2 K2O FM; 2.6-2.8 K2O DM | 0.8-0.9 | 0.9-1 | 10 fresh weight | Decentralized production | 8 | 37 farms (Spain) | Not know | Medium | EU Southwest | Spain, but also EU | ASAJA, APROINSECTA | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | https://www.asajamurcia.es/, https://www.aproinsecta.org/ | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||
T109 | Untreated (raw) digestate incl. animal manure | Digestate | Co-digestion anaerobic plant using diverse feedstocks, including manure, which are finite sources | Co-digestion anaerobic plant using diverse feedstocks, including manure, which are finite sources | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Decentralised year round capacity | Digestate is obtained after the anaerobic digestion of organic feedstocks in a reactor. The organic material is digested by different groups of microorganisms, which convert large organic compounds in smaller molecules to finally produce methane, carbon dioxide and other gases in small portion. After a period of time in the digester, the remaining organic material is taken out of the reactor and is what is called digestate. Manure was used to produce biogas. The final digestate is spread on the soils without any pre- treatment. | Untreated (raw) digestate incl. animal manure | 1.A.II | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 9.8-15.9 organic C FM | 9.8-15.9 organic C FM | 0.6 N FM | 0.07 P FM | 0.2 K FM | 54 | Decentralised year round capacity | static | 9 | 26 co-digestion plants | Not know | Medium | medium | EU North | Sweden | EBA | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | https://www.europeanbiogas.eu/ebas-digestate-factsheet-the-value-of-organic-fertilisers/ | CETENMA | ||||||||||||||||||
T110 | Untreated (raw) digestate incl. animal manure | Digestate | Co-digestion anaerobic plant using diverse feedstocks, including manure, which are finite sources | Co-digestion anaerobic plant using diverse feedstocks, including manure, which are finite sources | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Digestate is obtained after the anaerobic digestion of organic feedstocks in a reactor. The organic material is digested by different groups of microorganisms, which convert large organic compounds in smaller molecules to finally produce methane, carbon dioxide and other gases in small portion. After a period of time in the digester, the remaining organic material is taken out of the reactor and is what is called digestate. Manure was used to produce biogas. The final digestate is spread on the soils without any pre- treatment. | Untreated (raw) digestate incl. animal manure | 1.A.II | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 0.8-1.0 | 0.8-1.0 | 0.5-0.6 Mt DM/year | 0.17-0.2 Mt DM/year | 0.6-0.7 Mt DM/year | 7.3-9.5 | 11.8-13.7 | 221-2397 M tonnes/year | 9 | 20 000 | Not know | Medium | EU North/Central/Southwest/Southeast | Europe | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | ||||||||||||||||||||||
T111 | Untreated (raw) digestate without animal manure | Digestate | Co-digestion anaerobic plant using diverse feedstocks, excluding manure, which are finite sources | Co-digestion anaerobic plant using diverse feedstocks, excluding manure, which are finite sources | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | 26.5-310.1 M tonnes/year | Digestate is obtained after the anaerobic digestion of organic feedstocks in a reactor. The organic material is digested by different groups of microorganisms, which convert large organic compounds in smaller molecules to finally produce methane, carbon dioxide and other gases in small portion. After a period of time in the digester, the remaining organic material is taken out of the reactor and is what is called digestate. Manure was used to produce biogas. The final digestate is spread on the soils without any pre- treatment. | Untreated (raw) digestate without animal manure | N.A. some processes can comply with 1.A.II if Corg > 5 | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 1.2 organic C FM; 4.2 OM DM | 1.2 organic C FM; 4.2 OM DM | 0.5 N FM | 0.1 P2O5 | 0.2 K2O | 0.32 Ca | 0.02 MgO | 0.07 SO3 | 95 fresh weight | 26.5-310.1 M tonnes/year | 9 | 2400 | Not know | Medium | Medium | EU North/Central/Southwest/Southeast | Europe | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | ||||||||||||||||||
T112 | Vivianite | Urban wastewater | Urban wastewater is infinitely available | Urban wastewater is infinitely available | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Few small-scale (laboratory) studies evaluated the feasibility of vivianite production from urban wastewater. However, the proposed technologies are very different and do not follow the same treatment process: microbial activity (Geobacter metallireducens strain GS-15 and Geobacter and Wastewater biomass) (Azam & Finneran (2014); Wang et al. (2018)); Sequential Batch Reactor (SBR) (Li et al., 2017) and Membrane Bioreactor with iron dosing and acidogenic co-fermentation (Li et al., 2018). Design of the studies varies as much as the results. Among these investigations, unfortunately, the purity, size, structure and other specific parameters of the recovered vivianite are not evaluated, nor is it presented how to separate and purify the vivianite. A review of potentials of phosphorous recovery as vivianite from wastewater (Wu et al.m 2019) concluded "Phosphorus recovery from vivianite as an innovative practice has been creatively considered. However, studies on vivianite formation and phosphorus recovery from wastewater are inadequate and still in their infancy." | Vivianite | 1.C.I.a.ii | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 12.1 P2O5 FM; 5.3 DM | Variable | Variable | Variable | Year round productivity | 4 | 0 | Not know | Medium | EU Southwest | None (Lab scale) | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||||||||
T113 | Vivianite | Treated manure | Treated manure from cattle, pig and poultry Infinite source | Treated manure from cattle, pig and poultry Infinite source | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Vivianite is formed to a greater or lesser extent in aerobic digesters, especially if some Fe coagulant has previously been added (chemical phosphorus removal in WWTP for example) or to control the formation of H2S in the biogas. Its formation can also be promoted from the addition of Fe (II or III) and subsequent separation (mainly magnetically) of the mineral from the digested sludge. Therefore, in the case of manure as raw material, the production process would imply the previous anaerobic digestion of the manure. The procedures to promote the production of vivianite and its recovery from a digested sludge are still at a low TRL level. | Vivianite | 1.C.I.a.i. | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 1.0 N DM | 25.1 P2O5 FM; 9.8 - 12.3 P DM | 45447 | 0 | Not know | Medium | EU North/Central/Southwest/Southeast | Europe | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
T114 | Vivianite | Industrial wastewater | Infinite industrial wastewater | Infinite industrial wastewater | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Some laboratory-scale studies have studied the possibility of producing vivianite from industrial wastewater. However, a review of potentials of phosphorous recovery as vivianite from wastewater (Wu et al. 2019) concluded "Phosphorus recovery from vivianite as an innovative practice has been creatively considered. However, studies on vivianite formation and phosphorus recovery from wastewater are inadequate and still in their childhood." | Vivianite | 1.C.I.a.i. | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 23 P2O5 FM; 10.2 ± 0.02 | Year round production | 4 | Only lab and pilot scale | Not know | Medium | EU Central | FERPLAY DATABASE | FERPLAY | CETENMA | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
T115 | Blood hydrolysate | DRY BLOOD HYDROLYSATES | Industrial side-streams | porcine originating blood by local slaughterhouses | blood from other animal | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | 400 L/week processing | Filtration: The incoming blood is filtered using a metallic strainer to remove large impurities like hair, small stones, cartilage, and bone chips. Homogenization: The filtered blood undergoes mechanical homogenization at 600 bar pressure to break down red blood cell membranes and release hemoglobin-rich intercellular material. Hydrolysis: The homogenized liquid is subjected to chemical and/or enzymatic hydrolysis using different enzyme cocktails (exo- and endopeptidases). This process occurs over 3-6 hours at temperatures ranging from 50°C to 60°C and with stirring rates between 100-400 rpm. This step breaks down protein chains, releasing enzymes, active peptides, and free amino acids. Neutralization: The resulting hydrolysate is neutralized to a pH of 9 for improved stability at room temperature. | Once the blood from slaughterhouses has arrived at SAV facilities, the process begins. Overall, the blood hydrolysis process consists in a filtration with a metallic strainer to remove some of the major impurities that could interfere with the process (hair, small stone, cartilage, bone chips…). Afterwards, a mechanical homogenization at 600 bar pressure is done, to physically break every erythrocyte cell membrane and for intercellular material release, which are hemoglobin rich. Once the blood has been homogenized, the entire liquid is subjected to chemical and/or enzymatic hydrolysis (different enzyme cocktails, exo and endopeptidase) at different digestion times (3-6 hours), where chains are broken and enzymes, active peptides and free amino acids are released; Also, ranges of temperature (50oC-60oC) and stirring rate (100-400 rpm) will also be evaluated to develop a cost-effective process. After that a neutralization process will be carried out at pH 9 for longer stability at room temperature. | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | >90 (p/p) | 51,3 (p/p) | 18,9 (p/p) | 2,57 (p/p) | 1,44 (p/p) | 8 | Yes | Not known | Medium | Low | EU Southwest | Spain | Regarding the liquid blood hydrolysate, the main barriers identified are the high water content and therefore lower than expected nutrient concentration, and the need for a preservation method. | SAV | bioSOILUTION | CETENMA | ||||||||||||||||||||||
T116 | Anaerobic digestion | Anaerobic digestion plant of BioKymppi Oy | Municipal Biowaste | Industrial side-streams | Blue Biomasses | Municipal biowaste, Food industry by-products, fish by-products (minor) | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | 20 000 t/year | Anaerobic digestion, digestate separation with a screw press | Digestate solid fraction, Digestate liquid fraction | Energy | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | Digestate liquid fraction | 72 | 0.53 | 0.06 | 0.21 | 0.2 | 0.7 | 4.8 | 1000 | 7500 t/year | Static | 9 | Yes | No | Low | High | EU North | Finland | BioKymppi Oy | CiNURGi-project, company's website https://bio10.fi/ | CiNURGi | LUKE | ||||||||||||
T117 | Composting | Fast composting reactor by Biopallo Oy | Industrial side-streams | Municipal Biowaste | Different types of raw materials | Composting support material | CMC 3: Compost | 50 t/day (reactor modul potential) | Composting | Short residence time composting reactor | Compost | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | Mobile | 8 | No | No | Low | Medium | EU North | Finland | Technology is in pilot phase | Biopallo Oy | CiNURGi and previous projects, company's website https://www.en.biopallo.com/ | CiNURGi, also previous projects | LUKE | |||||||||||||||||||||||
T118 | Anaerobic digestion | Anaerobic digestion plant, Biopir Oy | Agricultural Biomasses | Pig slurry | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | 20 000 t/year | Anaerobic digestion, settling, screw separation | Digestate solid fraction, digestate liquid fraction | Energy | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | Digestate solid fraction | 2.5 | 1.5 | 1.6 | 30 | 450 | 800 t/year | Static | 9 | Yes | Yes | Low | High | EU North | Finland | Biopir Oy | CiNURGi | CiNURGi, other previous projects | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||
T119 | Anaerobic digestion | Anaerobic biogas plant, Ab Jeppo biogas Oy | Agricultural Biomasses | Industrial side-streams | Pig slurry, agro-food wastes, food industry by-products | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | 150 000 t/year | Anaerobic digestion, wet and dry digestion, screw separation | Digestate from wet process, digestate solid fraction, digestate liquid fraction | energy | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 1.4 | 10.8 | 2.9 | 5.5 | 3.7 | 1010 | 140 000 t/year | Static | 9 | Yes | No | Low | High | EU North | Finland | Ab Jeppo biogas Oy | CiNURGi, other previous projects, company's website https://jeppobiogas.fi/ | CiNURGi | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||
T120 | NPHarvest ammonium salt precipitation, phosphorus precipitation | NPHarvest Nutrient Catcher | Urban Wastewater | Urban wastewater, other wastewaters | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | CMC 12: Precipitated phosphate salts and derivates | Recovery process includes N stripping with hydrophobic membranes and P precipitation with lime | Ammonium salt, P-Ca precipitate | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | Ammonium salt | 10-20 | 6 | No | Yes | High | High | EU North | Finland, Sweden | Technology in a pilot phase | NPHarvest | https://www.npharvest.fi/en/index.html | CiNURGi | https://aaltodoc.aalto.fi/items/b86a3f21-88ba-4d99-af29-a8c4af5c6b00 (PhD thesis); https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2023.137227 (LCA) | LUKE | |||||||||||||||||||||||
T121 | Groot Zevert Vergisting | Anaerobic digestion plant | Agricultural Biomasses | Industrial side-streams | Pig manure | Agro-food industry waste (waste from dairy and feed industry, glycerin) | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | 94 000 t/year | Anaerobic digestion, digestate separation with centrifuge, concentration of liquid fraction with reverse osmosis, purification of water (from RO) with ion exchange. Solid fraction tretmen in Re-P-eat -process. | Currently, the digestate is separated trough a decanter in a solid and liquid fraction. The liquid fraction is used as a N-fertilizer on agricultural land in the Netherlands. The solid fraction is, after a hygienization step (60 minutes at 70 °C), exported to neighbouring countries where it is used as an organic P-fertilizer. Part of the digestate is also applied directly on the field in Germany. In collaboration with Nijhuis and Wageningen UR, GZV will implement a system for NK recovery from the liquid fraction (GENIUS) and P recovery from the solid fraction (RePeat). The GENIUS and Re-P-eat processes In GENIUS-NK process, the digestate is separated into a solid and a liquid fraction by means of a decanter. The N-rich liquid fraction will be processed into a nitrogen-potassium (NK-) concentrate and clean water through a combination of DAF and membrane filtration system: micro filtration, reverse osmosis (RO) and ion-exchange(IX). The P-rich solid fraction will be treated with a P-stripper called “Re-P-eat” through a process of acid (H2SO4) and base Ca(OH2) addition. The products of this process will be mineral calciumphosphate (CaP) and a P-poor organic soil conditioner | P-fertiliser (Calsium phosphate), P-poor soil improver, NK-concentrate | Energy, water | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | P-fertiliser | 45 | 2.4390243902439024 | 7.44390243902439 | 0.5060975609756098 | 82 | The GENIUS installation converted one tonne of digestate into 0.15 tonnes solid fraction, 0.25 tonnes RO concentrate, 0.45 tonne of sludge and 0.15 tonnes dischargeable water | Static | 7 | Yes | Yes | High | Medium | EU Southwest | The Netherlands | NL22 | Groot Zevert Vergisting | https://systemicproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/Factsheet-1-GZV.pdf; https://systemicproject.eu/plants/demonstration-plants/groot-zevert-the-netherlands/, https://systemicproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/D2.6-Report-on-LCA_vfin3_220227.pdf | SYSTEMIC | LUKE | ||||||||||||
T122 | AM Power | Anaerobic digestion plant | Municipal Biowaste | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses | Food waste | Manure, maize | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | CMC 2: Plants, plant parts or plant extracts | 180 000 t/year | Anaerobic digestion, digestate separation wih centrifuge, drying of the solid fraction, concentration of liquid fraction with evaporation, treatment of ammonia water (from evaporator) with reverse osmosis | Currently the process works as follows: • Organic wastes are collected and homogenized in a mixing unit to a substance with a dry matter (DM) content of approximately 20%. • Homogenized feedstock is hydrolysed in a separate unit (with a retention time of 3 days) and fed to a thermophilic digester. • Digestate (9% DM) is sent to a centrifuge for solid/liquid separation. Coagulation and flocculation are favoured by the addition of polymer and iron sulphate. • The solid fraction that contains 90-95% of the initially separated total phosphorous (P) is dried, while the liquid fraction is sent to a flotation and reverse osmosis (RO) unit. Drying of solid fraction is accomplished by recycling waste heat from CHP engines and it requires around 2600 kWh. The resulting product is exported to France. • Before the RO, a flotation step (DAF) reduces the DM content of the liquid fraction to 1.6 - 1.7% DM. The RO step requires the addition of acid (H2SO4 ) to the influent to ensure a good membrane separation. The resulting concentrate is rich in nitrogen and potassium (N and K) and is used as a fertilizer on local agricultural land. | P-rich biosolids, NK-conentrate | Energy, water | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | Digestate: | 43 | 32.2 | 3.0000000000000004 | 3.7302222222222223 | 1.1066666666666665 | 90 | not available | Static | 7 | Yes | Yes | High | High | EU Southwest | Belgium | BE25 | AM Power | https://systemicproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/Factsheet-2-AM-Power-1.pdf, https://systemicproject.eu/plants/demonstration-plants/ampower-flanders-belgium/ https://systemicproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/D2.6-Report-on-LCA_vfin3_220227.pdf | SYSTEMIC | LUKE | ||||||||||
T123 | Acqua & Sole | Anaerobic digestion plant | Urban Wastewater | Municipal Biowaste | Sewage sludge | Digestate (food waste based) | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | 72 000 t/year | Anaerobic digestion, ammonia stripping using biogas. NH3-gas is scrubbed with H2SO4 into ammonium sulphate. | Digestate, ammonium sulphate | Energy | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | Digestate: | 32.2 | 7.7 | 2.51136 | 0.6889 | 10.5 | 119 200 t/year digestate, 4000 t/year ammonium sulphate | Static | 7 | Yes | Yes | Medium | High | EU Southwest | Italy | Acqua & Sole | https://systemicproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/Factsheet-3-AS.pdf, https://systemicproject.eu/plants/demonstration-plants/acquasole-italy/, https://systemicproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/D2.6-Report-on-LCA_vfin3_220227.pdf | SYSTEMIC | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||
T124 | Waterleau NewEnergy | Anaerobic digestion plant | Industrial side-streams | Agricultural Biomasses | Residues from agro-food industry (grain waste, potato waste, glucerine, sludge industrial waste water treatment, other), manure | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | 120 000 t/year | Anaerobic digestion, separation with a centrifuge, solid fraction drying, liquid fraction biological aerobic treatment and evaporation (to transfer N to gas phase and to produce K-rich concentrate). NH3-gas is condenced with water into ammonium solution. | The feedstock is heated/mixed up to 40°C and is digested for 30 days (+10 days in the post digester). The digestate is hygienized (1hour 70°C) and separated by a centrifuge. The solid fraction is dried in a Hydrogone® dryer. This is an indirect dryer which can evaporate 1-1,8 tonnes of water per hour. This water goes, together with the liquid fraction of the digestate (15m³/h) to an biological aerobic water treatment for small removal of COD. In the next step (evaporator) ammonium is transferred to the gas phase and a (K rich) solution is concentrated. The ammonia rich gas condenses with the water vapour and anammonium solution is recovered. The dried digestate is exported to France, the concentrated liquid fraction is exported also outside Belgium as fertilizer and ammonium water is used as exhaust gas treatment | Ammonium solution, K-concentrate, dried digestate | Energy | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 15 NH4-N (fresh) | 1200 t/year | Static | 8 | Yes | Yes | High | High | EU Southwest | Belgium | BE2 | Waterleau NewEnergy | https://systemicproject.eu/plants/demonstration-plants/waterleau-new-energy-be/, https://systemicproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/fact-sheet-Waterleau-New-Energy-pending2.pdf, https://systemicproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/D2.6-Report-on-LCA_vfin3_220227.pdf | SYSTEMIC | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||
T125 | BENAS | Anaerobic digestion plant | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses | Energy crops (maize and corn), poultry manure | gypsum | CMC 2: Plants, plant parts or plant extracts | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | Ammonium sulphate: 4000 t/year, calcium carbonate 1000 t/year, digestate75000 t/yea, production of fibres 1100 t/year; | Anaerobic digestion, ammonia stripping and scribbing of the digestate to produce ammonium sulphate and calcium carbonate, digestate is separated with a screw press to recover fibress and liquid fraction. | Innovation: G (Halle), an engineering company and partner of SYSTEMIC, invented a novel N stripping- and recovery unit. In this approach, ammonia and carbon dioxide are stripped from digestate without chemicals and thereafter brought into contact with gypsum to form ammonium sulphate and calcium carbonate. Digestate leaving the N-stripper is separated by means of a screw press to recover organic fibres with a low ammonium content. The remaining digestate is fed back to the main digester. In 2021, BENAS invested in a fibre moulding and paper making machine for on-site production of, amongst others, biodegradable mulch mats and pots. | Ammonium sulphate, digestate, calcium carbonate | Fibres, energy | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | PFC 2 Liming material | 4.5 (fresh) | 5.8 (fresh) | 25 | 100000 t/year | Static | 7 | Yes | Yes | High | High | EU Central | Germany | Benas-GNS | https://systemicproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/Factsheet-5-GNS.pdf, https://systemicproject.eu/plants/demonstration-plants/benas-germany/, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.127408, https://systemicproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/D2.6-Report-on-LCA_vfin3_220227.pdf | SYSTEMIC | Techno-economic assessment can be found: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.127408; LCA can be found: https://systemicproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/D2.6-Report-on-LCA_vfin3_220227.pdf | LUKE | |||||||||||||||
T126 | S360 | Sanitation 360, Urine stabilisation and drying | Urban Wastewater | Separately collected urine | 21 L per m2 per day | Addition of stabiliser, urine drying | Use of a urine stabilizer for nutrient retention and odour control. Employing a uniquely designed drying system that concentrates the urine and thereby increases the nutrient concentration (factor > 25x) to an NPK (nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium) ratio of 15-2-4. Blending and drying to produce solid fertilizer pellets that can be used with conventional farming equipment. | Dry-fertilizer | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | 15 (fresh) | 2 (fresh) | 4 (fresh) | Static/Mobile | 6 | Yes | Yes | Medium | Medium | EU North | Sweden | SE21 | EU fertiliser legislation does not recognise separated urine as CMC, and the product does not fall into any of the PFCs | The technology to produce the solid urine fertiliser was developed at the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences (SLU) and Sanitation360 (S360), a spinoff from SLU started in 2019. To increase urine collection and to close the circular value, Touch Down (TD), local toilet rental company, and Gotlands Bryggeri, local beer brewer, joined to close the circular value chain. | https://p2green.eu/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/Set-up-operation-and-validation-of-Pilot-Regions-1.pdf; https://sanitation360.se/ | P2GreeN | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||||||
T127 | The Vuna Process | Urban Wastewater | Separately collected urine (also applicable for livestock urine) | Scalable, from 300 users per day | Nitrification, active carbon filtration, conentration and pasteurisation | The urine is the stabilised by nitrification in a biological reactor. This step removes bad odours. To remove all micropollutants, this effluent is filtered in an activated carbon filter. The liquid is then pasteurised and concentrated in an industrial distiller. The two outputs are reusable distilled water and ready to use fertiliser, Aurin. | Aurin | distilled water (can be used to flush the toilets) | 0.1 (fresh) | 4.2 (fresh) | 0.17 (fresh) | 1.5 (fresh) | 0.32 (fresh) | Static/Mobile | 6 | Yes | Yes | Medium | High | EU Central | Germany | EU fertiliser legislation does not recognise separated urine as CMC, and the product does not fall into any of the PFCs | Vuna Nexus | https://p2green.eu/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/Set-up-operation-and-validation-of-Pilot-Regions-1.pdf; https://www.vunanexus.com/aurin | P2GreeN | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||||||
T128 | Fecal compost | Municipal Biowaste | Municipal Biowaste | Agricultural Biomasses | Fecal matter (dry toilet waste), green waste | Biochar (tree cuttings) | CMC 2: Plants, plant parts or plant extracts | CMC 13: Thermal oxidation materials and their derivatives | Sanitisation in aerated container: microbial activity facilitates temperatures of >65°C for >7 days and eliminates pathogens. Composting: De- & Recomposition of solid matter mixed with additional bulk material by automated auger to produce a soil nurturing recycling-fertiliser. Screening of inadequate material. | Compost | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | Static/Mobile | 7 | Yes | Yes | Medium | High | EU Central | Germany | DE9 | EU fertiliser legislation does not recognise fecal compost as CMC | Goldeimer | https://p2green.eu/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/Set-up-operation-and-validation-of-Pilot-Regions-1.pdf | P2GreeN | LUKE | |||||||||||||||||||||||
T129 | Anaerobic digestion | Anaerobic digestion plant of Emomylly Oy | Agricultural Biomasses | Industrial side-streams | Pig manure | Agro-food industry waste | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | 14 500 t/year | Anaerobic digestion, digestate separation with a screw press | Digestate solid fraction, digestate liquid fraction | Energy | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | Solid fraction | 45 | 2.9499999999999997 | 1.25 | 1 | 20 | Solid fraction: 800 t; liquid fraction 12 700 t/y | Static | 9 | Yes | No | Low | High | EU North | Finland | FI19 | Emomylly Oy | Luke has mass balances calculated for this installation | RavinneEmo | LUKE | ||||||||||||||
T130 | Pelletizing/ Animal proteins, vegetable by-products/ Monterra 2–14–4 | Name in LEX4BIO: MO14 | Industrial side-streams | Industrial side-streams: food industry by-products (Animal proteins, vegetable by-products) | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | Monterra 2–14–4 MeMon (Powder) | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 24.1 (TOC) | 2.49 | 6.74 | 16.55 | 91.7 | Powder | 9 | Yes | Yes | Medium | EU Southwest | Netherlands | Hernandez-Mora, A., Duboc, O., Lombi, E., Bünemann, E.K., Ylivainio, K., Symanczik, S., Delgado, A., Zahra, N.A., Nikama, J., Zuin, L. and Doolette, C.L., 2024. Fertilization efficiency of thirty marketed and experimental recycled phosphorus fertilizers. Journal of Cleaner Production, 467, p.142957. https://lex4bio.eu/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/Deliverable-3.4.pdf Not sure if this is the extact tested prodiuct: https://seminte-ingrasaminte-turba.ro/product/ingrasamant-organic-monterra-basic-2-14-4ca/ | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | |||||||||||||||||||||||||
T131 | Pelletizing/ Pelletizing of meat & bone meal/ Biorga Vianos | Pelletising (Sphero technology)/ Name in LEX4BIO: MB1 | Industrial side-streams | Industrial side-streams: food industry by-products (MBM) | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | Sphero granules technology: With Sphero technology, the smallest particles of the individual nutrients are dissolved and intensively mixed together. The mixture is then pressed through a perforated plate, and the strands are subsequently cut. This creates perfectly cylindrical granules. Each fertilizer grain is the same size and contains the same nutrient composition. Sphero technology affects the nutrients by naturally modifying the organic components and creating synergies within the mixture. This ensures optimal plant absorption of the active ingredients. The cylindrical granules also offer excellent physical properties for users: They are extremely stable, preventing dust, and their uniform size makes them ideal for pouring and spreading. | Biorga Vianos (Powder) | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 70 (Manufacturer's declaration) | 34.3 TOC; (Total C: 36.21) | 8.13 | 6.34 | 12.9 | 97.6 | 9 | Yes | Yes | Low | EU Central | Switzerland | https://docs.hauert.com/ch/datasheets/biorga-vianos-20-kg_de.pdf Hernandez-Mora, A., Duboc, O., Lombi, E., Bünemann, E.K., Ylivainio, K., Symanczik, S., Delgado, A., Zahra, N.A., Nikama, J., Zuin, L. and Doolette, C.L., 2024. Fertilization efficiency of thirty marketed and experimental recycled phosphorus fertilizers. Journal of Cleaner Production, 467, p.142957. https://lex4bio.eu/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/Deliverable-3.4.pdf Dong, Y., Das, S., Parsons, J.R., Praetorius, A., de Rijke, E., Helmus, R., Slootweg, J.C. and Jansen, B., 2023. Simultaneous detection of pesticides and pharmaceuticals in three types of bio-based fertilizers by an improved QuEChERS method coupled with UHPLC-q-ToF-MS/MS. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 458, p.131992. Das, S., Helmus, R., Dong, Y., Beijer, S., Praetorius, A., Parsons, J.R. and Jansen, B., 2023. Organic contaminants in bio-based fertilizer treated soil: Target and suspect screening approaches. Chemosphere, 337, p.139261. | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | |||||||||||||||||||||||||
T132 | Pelletizing/ Hygienization and pelletizing of chicken manure and grape residue / Optisol Universal | Name in LEX4BIO: OPU (Das et al., 2023 mentioned Pyrolysis and Pelletizing as the technologies.) | Agricultural Biomasses | Industrial side-streams | Agricultural Biomasses: Chicken Manure Industrial side-streams: food industry by-products (grape residue) | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | "The delivered chicken manure must rest, or rather, work, for at least two to three months. Trained employees ensure that it is repeatedly processed, allowing the heat generated by fermentation to escape. This homogenization process is important because it promotes the drying process and helps naturally eliminate potential germs. The raw material requires only 15 percent residual moisture content for processing into fertilizer pellets. The raw material is dried and dedusted in a belt dryer at around 90 degrees Celsius. A filter ensures that no emissions are released into the environment. Right at the beginning of its homogenization and drying process, the chicken manure is reinforced with grape pomace from the Valais vineyards. These are particularly important for the consistency of the pellets and act as a kind of adhesive in the fertilizer production process. After the homogenization process, the chicken manure is dried in a rotary machine, filtered, and transported to a press via an automatic conveyor belt. Depending on the application or customer requirements, organic or mineral fertilizer components are added to the raw material. This process, based on sustainable processes, produces an environmentally friendly fertilizer for professional agriculture and viticulture in Switzerland over several months." | Optisol Universal (Granular) | PFC 1(B) Organo-mineral fertilizer | 68.7 (Agostini et al., 2024); 60 - 65 (Manufacturer's declaration) | 32.5 TOC (Total C: 37.3 in Wester-Larsen et al., 2022) | 3.01 | 1.96 | 2.5 (Manufacturer's declaration) | 8.03 | 0.4 (Manufacturer's declaration) | 89.3 | https://www.optisol.ch/sites/optisol.ch/files/2018-01/Optisol_Content_Organisch-Bio_1.jpg | "At the Optisol production facility in Vétroz, around 6,000 m3 of chicken manure are received each year and processed into around 3,000 tonnes of fertilizer" | 9 | Yes | Yes | Low | EU Central | Switzerland | Wester-Larsen, L., Müller-Stöver, D.S., Salo, T. and Jensen, L.S., 2022. Potential ammonia volatilization from 39 different novel biobased fertilizers on the European market–a laboratory study using 5 European soils. Journal of Environmental Management, 323, p.116249. https://www.optisol.ch/sites/optisol.ch/files/Produktbl%C3%A4tter/_deutsch/Optisol_Produktblatt_Universel_de.pdf Hernandez-Mora, A., Duboc, O., Lombi, E., Bünemann, E.K., Ylivainio, K., Symanczik, S., Delgado, A., Zahra, N.A., Nikama, J., Zuin, L. and Doolette, C.L., 2024. Fertilization efficiency of thirty marketed and experimental recycled phosphorus fertilizers. Journal of Cleaner Production, 467, p.142957. Agostini, L., Bünemann, E.K., Jakobsen, C., Salo, T., Wester-Larsen, L. and Symanczik, S., 2024. Prediction of nitrogen mineralization from novel bio-based fertilizers using chemical extractions. Environmental Technology & Innovation, 36, p.103781. Das, S., Helmus, R., Dong, Y., Beijer, S., Praetorius, A., Parsons, J.R. and Jansen, B., 2023. Organic contaminants in bio-based fertilizer treated soil: Target and suspect screening approaches. Chemosphere, 337, p.139261. Dong, Y., Das, S., Parsons, J.R., Praetorius, A., de Rijke, E., Helmus, R., Slootweg, J.C. and Jansen, B., 2023. Simultaneous detection of pesticides and pharmaceuticals in three types of bio-based fertilizers by an improved QuEChERS method coupled with UHPLC-q-ToF-MS/MS. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 458, p.131992. | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||||
T133 | AshDec incineration/ Sewage sludge ash and sodium carbonate to CaNaPO4 powder/Na AshDec | Name in LEX4BIO: ADC | Urban Wastewater | Urban Wastewater: sewage sludge | sodium compounds (e.g. Na2CO3) | CMC 13: Thermal oxidation materials and their derivatives | CMC 12: Precipitated phosphate salts and derivates | The processing capaciry is 15.000 t per year. | AshDec® is a thermochemical process designed to convert the low plant available phosphorus compound in the ash (Ca3(PO4)2) to the highly plant available compound CaNaPO4 while reducing the heavy metal content.The core process encompasses feeding ash to a rotary kiln where it is mixed with sodium compounds (e.g. Na2CO3) and a reducing agent, preferably sewage sludge. The material is treated at around 900 °C for 15-20 min. Sodium ions replace calcium ions in the phosphates and formcitrate-soluble CaNaPO4 compounds. Simultaneously, sodium reacts with silicon dioxide present in the ash and forms sodiumsilicates.As reducing agent, preferably sewage sludge is added to reduce theoxidized heavy metals. A noticeable high amount of heavy metalsin their elemental form evaporate at the prevalent temperatures. | https://nutriman.net/sites/default/files/2020-03/398_INFOSHEET_TECHNOLOGY_AshDec.pdf https://www.phosphorusplatform.eu/images/Conference/ESPC2-materials/Hermann%20poster%20ESPC2.pdf | AshDec-Metso Outotec (Powder) | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | 0.5 TOC | 8.05 | 0.33 - 0.8 | 9.5 | 1.5 | 100 | https://nutriman.net/sites/default/files/2020-03/398_INFOSHEET_TECHNOLOGY_AshDec.pdf | 7 | Yes | Yes | High | EU Central | Germany | *https://nutriman.net/sites/default/files/2020-03/398_INFOSHEET_TECHNOLOGY_AshDec.pdf Hernandez-Mora, A., Duboc, O., Lombi, E., Bünemann, E.K., Ylivainio, K., Symanczik, S., Delgado, A., Zahra, N.A., Nikama, J., Zuin, L. and Doolette, C.L., 2024. Fertilization efficiency of thirty marketed and experimental recycled phosphorus fertilizers. Journal of Cleaner Production, 467, p.142957. Pradel, M., Lippi, M., Daumer, M.L. and Aissani, L., 2020. Environmental performances of production and land application of sludge-based phosphate fertilizers—a life cycle assessment case study. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 27, pp.2054-2070. Raniro, H.R., Soares, T.D.M., Adam, C. and Pavinato, P.S., 2022. Waste‐derived fertilizers can increase phosphorus uptake by sugarcane and availability in a tropical soil#. Journal of Plant Nutrition and Soil Science, 185(3), pp.391-402. | LEX4BIO and Nutriman/ project completed | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||||
T134 | Pyrolysis/ Pyrolyzed chicken manure/ Poultry litter biochar | Name in LEX4BIO: MBC | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: livestock manure (chicken manure) | Agricultural Biomasses: biochar from pyrolsys (Poultry litter biochar) | CMC 14: Pyrolysis And Gasification Materials | energy-free carbonization technology (EFCaR system). This system can self-generate enough heat for carbonization. | Poultry litter biochar (granular) | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 31.5 TOC; 36.34 Total C | 2.94 | 3.06 | 5.03 | 18.05 | 98.3 | Granular | 7 | No | No | Low | Japan? | Hernandez-Mora, A., Duboc, O., Lombi, E., Bünemann, E.K., Ylivainio, K., Symanczik, S., Delgado, A., Zahra, N.A., Nikama, J., Zuin, L. and Doolette, C.L., 2024. Fertilization efficiency of thirty marketed and experimental recycled phosphorus fertilizers. Journal of Cleaner Production, 467, p.142957. https://lex4bio.eu/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/Deliverable-3.4.pdf Müller, B., Herrmann, M.N., Lewandowski, I., Müller, T., Hartung, J. and Bauerle, A., 2024. The Effect of Biobased N and P Fertilizers in a Winter Wheat–Ryegrass Crop Rotation. Agronomy, 14(10), p.2424. Ueda, K., 2019. Energy-Effective Carbonization Technology. Phosphorus Recovery and Recycling, pp.367-376. | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
T135 | Pyrolysis and fermentation/ Fermented biochar and high-quality clay and rock flour/ Palaterra 6:3:6 | Name in LEX4BIO: PAL | Industrial side-streams | Industrial side-streams: wood industry by-products (80% wood biochar pyrolyzed at >600 C) | Industrial side-streams: 10% organic wastes such as residues from food production and 10% mineral compounds such as rock flour | CMC 4: Fresh crop digestate | a fermented biochar containing 80% wood biochar pyrolyzed at >600 C, 10% organic wastes such as residues from food production and 10% mineral compounds such as rock flour; inoculated with a mixture of microorganisms followed by fermentation, which is referred to as “loading” process). Granulating (1–4 mm) | Palaterra | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 81 (Agostini et al., 2024) | 42.8 (Total C) | 5.39 | 0.96 | 5.49 | 90.7 | https://ars.els-cdn.com/content/image/1-s2.0-S0378429024002399-mmc1.docx | 9 | Yes | Yes | High | EU North | Denmark | Wester-Larsen, L., Müller-Stöver, D.S., Salo, T. and Jensen, L.S., 2022. Potential ammonia volatilization from 39 different novel biobased fertilizers on the European market–a laboratory study using 5 European soils. Journal of Environmental Management, 323, p.116249. | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | |||||||||||||||||||||||
T136 | Fermentation and distillation/ wheat and maize residues/ Agrana Bioagenasol 5.5:2.5:1.5 | Name in LEX4BIO: BA6 | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: crop residue (wheat and maize residues) | Industrial side-streams: bioethanol residues amended with molasses, potato fruit water and maize steeping water. | CMC 4: Fresh crop digestate | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | This product is derived from the fermentation and distillation of wheat, corn, triticale, barley, and other sugar-rich materials. It includes soluble distillers' grains with molasses, grape marc, Potato Nitrogen Concentrate, and corn steep liquor. The process involves drying the residues after alcohol extraction, resulting in a nutrient-rich by-product containing yeast biomass. Additional components like residual molasses (mechanically separated during saccharification) and grape marc (fermentation industry residues) further enrich the final product. | Agrana Bioagenasol | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 94.9 (Agostini et al., 2024) | 48.1 (Total C) | 6.14 | 1.36 | 1.43 | 90.7 | https://ars.els-cdn.com/content/image/1-s2.0-S0378429024002399-mmc1.docx | 9 | Yes | Yes | High | EU Central | Austria | Wester-Larsen, L., Müller-Stöver, D.S., Salo, T. and Jensen, L.S., 2022. Potential ammonia volatilization from 39 different novel biobased fertilizers on the European market–a laboratory study using 5 European soils. Journal of Environmental Management, 323, p.116249. https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0782/9497/4745/files/SchedaTecnica_Bioagenasol.pdf?v=1708413344 | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||||||
T137 | Drying and pelletizing/ Malt germ, malt, minerals and vinasse/ Maltaflor BIO | Name in LEX4BIO: MAL | Industrial side-streams | Industrial side-streams: food industry by-products (Mixture of malt germ, malt, minerals, and vinasse vegetable) | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | Organo-mineral fertilizer based on malt sprouts, vinasse from sugar beets processing and minerals. | Maltaflor BIO | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 80 (Manufacturer's declaration); 83 (Agostini et al., 2024) | 36.6 (Total C) | 5.26 | 0.42 | 4.29 | 95.5 | https://maltaflor.de/maltaflor-bionic/ | 9 | Yes | Yes | Low | EU Central | Germany | Müller, B., Wester-Larsen, L., Jensen, L.S., Salo, T., Garrido, R.R., Arkoun, M., D'Oria, A., Lewandowski, I., Müller, T. and Bauerle, A., 2024. Agronomic performance of novel, nitrogen-rich biobased fertilizers across European field trial sites. Field Crops Research, 316, p.109486. Albert, S. and Bloem, E., 2025. Antibiotic contamination of fresh organic fertilizers and processed bio‐based fertilizer products. Agrosystems, Geosciences & Environment, 8(1), p.e70059. Agostini, L., Bünemann, E.K., Jakobsen, C., Salo, T., Wester-Larsen, L. and Symanczik, S., 2024. Prediction of nitrogen mineralization from novel bio-based fertilizers using chemical extractions. Environmental Technology & Innovation, 36, p.103781. https://maltaflor.de/maltaflor-bionic/ | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
T138 | Hydrolysis/ Organic fertilizer based on horn meal from pigs’ bristles/ Daka Øgro N15 (or Øgro N14?) | Name in LEX4BIO: OG2 | Industrial side-streams | Industrial side-streams: food industry by-products (horn meal from pigs’ bristles) | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | Daka Øgro N15 (or Øgro N14) | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 95 (Manufacturer's declaration); 94 (Agostini et al., 2024) | 51.4 (Total C) | 14.79 | 0.32 | 0.01 | 94 | https://ars.els-cdn.com/content/image/1-s2.0-S0378429024002399-mmc1.docx | 9 | Yes | Yes | High | EU North | Denmark | Wester-Larsen, L., Müller-Stöver, D.S., Salo, T. and Jensen, L.S., 2022. Potential ammonia volatilization from 39 different novel biobased fertilizers on the European market–a laboratory study using 5 European soils. Journal of Environmental Management, 323, p.116249. | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | |||||||||||||||||||||||||
T139 | Pelletizing/ Feather meal/ Monterra Bio 13–0–0 | Name in LEX4BIO: MO13 | Industrial side-streams | Industrial side-streams: food industry by-products (Feather meall) | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | Monterra Bio 13–0–0 | Monterra Bio 13–0–0 | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 85 (Manufacturer's declaration); 98.4 (Agostini et al., 2024) | 52.9 (Total C) | 15.32 | 0.22 | 1 (Manufacturer's declaration) | 0.1 (Manufacturer's declaration) | 0.7 (Manufacturer's declaration) | 92.7 | https://ars.els-cdn.com/content/image/1-s2.0-S0378429024002399-mmc1.docx | 9 | Yes | Yes | High | EU Southwest | Netherlands | Wester-Larsen, L., Müller-Stöver, D.S., Salo, T. and Jensen, L.S., 2022. Potential ammonia volatilization from 39 different novel biobased fertilizers on the European market–a laboratory study using 5 European soils. Journal of Environmental Management, 323, p.116249. https://memon.nl/?jet_download=0810ebe2650f4bc50b5079e4c37417d05910a330 | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | |||||||||||||||||||||
T140 | Incineration/ Incineration and granulation of sunflower husks/ Ecoplant Humi | Name in LEX4BIO: EPH | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: crop residues (sunflower husks)+ humic substances | Agricultural Biomasses: ash from biomass combustion | CMC 13: Thermal oxidation materials and their derivatives | EcoPlant-Humi® is certified for use in organic farming, meeting standards such as those set by Ecocert and Organic Standard, which align with EEC regulations 834/2007 and 889/2008. | Granular | Ecoplant Humi (Granular) | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | 1.2 TOC (total C is 5.75 in Lex4Bio deliverable 3.4-D16-WP3) | 0.13 | 1.95 | 25 | 10.45 | 7.2 | 5.5 | 97.1 | 1000 | 8 | Yes (Orij Group Ltd.) | Yes | Low | EU Southeast | Ukraine | ecoplant.ua https://meedia.balticagro.ee/Admin/Public/QC+Ecoplant-Humi.pdf Hernandez-Mora, A., Duboc, O., Lombi, E., Bünemann, E.K., Ylivainio, K., Symanczik, S., Delgado, A., Zahra, N.A., Nikama, J., Zuin, L. and Doolette, C.L., 2024. Fertilization efficiency of thirty marketed and experimental recycled phosphorus fertilizers. Journal of Cleaner Production, 467, p.142957. https://lex4bio.eu/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/Deliverable-3.4.pdf | LEX4BIO and Nutriman/ project completed | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||||
T141 | Incineration/ Incineration of poultry litter/ BMC Circular PK fertilizer | Name in LEX4BIO:PLA | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: livestock manure and slurry (Turkey litter) | Agricultural Biomasses: ash from biomass (ash Turkey litter) | CMC 13: Thermal oxidation materials and their derivatives | "The PK fertilizer boasts consistent quality because BMC Moerdijk only processes poultry manure. This poultry manure is sourced from farms that meet the EU requirements for keeping poultry. After inspection and receipt, the delivered poultry manure is first mixed well. This manure is then thermally processed in a controlled process at a temperature of over 850°C for two seconds. The PK fertilizer is then stored separately to avoid cross-contamination with poultry manure. The quality of both the poultry manure and the PK fertilizer is examined periodically by an external laboratory using European approved methods for analysing fertilizers." | BMC Moerdijk - Circular PK fertilizer (Powder) | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | 0.5 TOC (0.61 Total C) | 0.01 | 5.23 | 13 (Manufacturer's declaration) | 15.75 | 5 (Manufacturer's declaration) | 6 (Manufacturer's declaration) | 92.1 | Powder | 9 | Yes (BMC Moerdijk) | Yes | Low | EU Southwest | Netherlands | https://www.bmcmoerdijk.nl/en/circular-pk-fertilizer/ Hernandez-Mora, A., Duboc, O., Lombi, E., Bünemann, E.K., Ylivainio, K., Symanczik, S., Delgado, A., Zahra, N.A., Nikama, J., Zuin, L. and Doolette, C.L., 2024. Fertilization efficiency of thirty marketed and experimental recycled phosphorus fertilizers. Journal of Cleaner Production, 467, p.142957. https://lex4bio.eu/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/Deliverable-3.4.pdf Das, S., Helmus, R., Dong, Y., Beijer, S., Praetorius, A., Parsons, J.R. and Jansen, B., 2023. Organic contaminants in bio-based fertilizer treated soil: Target and suspect screening approaches. Chemosphere, 337, p.139261. Dong, Y., Das, S., Parsons, J.R., Praetorius, A., de Rijke, E., Helmus, R., Slootweg, J.C. and Jansen, B., 2023. Simultaneous detection of pesticides and pharmaceuticals in three types of bio-based fertilizers by an improved QuEChERS method coupled with UHPLC-q-ToF-MS/MS. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 458, p.131992. | LEX4BIO and Nutriman/ project completed | LUKE | |||||||||||||||||||||
T142 | Pyrolysis/Drying and pyrolysis of sewage sludge | Name in LEX4BIO: BAG | Industrial side-streams | Urban Wastewater: Sewage sludge | Urban Wastewater: biochar from sludge pyrolysis | CMC 14: Pyrolysis And Gasification Materials | It is a fully automated, continuous process that dries and pyrolyzes biomass. Superheated steam-dryer: A compact, energy-efficient system using 200°C superheated steam in an oxygen-free environment to dry wet biomass odor-free, with heat recovery for local or district heating. High-temperature slow pyrolysis: Dried biomass is heated to 650°C in an oxygen-free oven for 20 minutes, eliminating pollutants and producing thermal energy and hygienized, stable, carbon-rich biochar (over 90% stable carbon content). | https://aquagreen.dk/technology/ | Granular sewage sludge based biochar | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | 13.6 TOC | 0.76 | 5.23 | 99.4 | 7 | Yes | No | Medium | EU North | Denmark | Hernandez-Mora, A., Duboc, O., Lombi, E., Bünemann, E.K., Ylivainio, K., Symanczik, S., Delgado, A., Zahra, N.A., Nikama, J., Zuin, L. and Doolette, C.L., 2024. Fertilization efficiency of thirty marketed and experimental recycled phosphorus fertilizers. Journal of Cleaner Production, 467, p.142957.
TechnologyConfidential Deliverable 2.1 LEX4BIO | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | |||||||||||||||||||||||||
T143 | Pelletizing/Hygienization and pelletizing of MBM, apatite, vinasse, chicken manure, and K2SO4/Bio 8-4-2 yara | Name in LEX4BIO: BIO | Industrial side-streams | Agricultural Biomasses | Industrial Side-streams: Apatite, Vinasse, K2SO₄ | Agricultural Biomasses: Meat and Bone Meal, Chicken Manure. | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | Bio 8-4-2 yara | Bio 8-4-2 yara | PFC 1(B) Organo-mineral fertilizer | 69.4 | 38.2 (Total C) | 7.85 | 4.25 | 2.13 | 8 (this value corresponds to the Fertikal organic fertilizer 4-3-3+1MgO+ME) | 1 (this value corresponds to the Fertikal organic fertilizer 4-3-3+1MgO+ME) | 1 (this value corresponds to the Fertikal organic fertilizer 4-3-3+1MgO+ME) | 94.1 | https://ars.els-cdn.com/content/image/1-s2.0-S0378429024002399-mmc1.docx | 9 | Yes | Yes | High | EU North | Finland | Wester-Larsen, L., Müller-Stöver, D.S., Salo, T. and Jensen, L.S., 2022. Potential ammonia volatilization from 39 different novel biobased fertilizers on the European market–a laboratory study using 5 European soils. Journal of Environmental Management, 323, p.116249. https://www.yara.fi/contentassets/933fda523d41435ca01181ddbd46f4b1/yara_lannoitevalikoima2021_fi_1910_web.pdf https://www.hankkija.fi/tuotantopanokset/luomutuotanto/lannoitteet/ia-biokierratyslannoitteella-kolmannes-lisaa-satoa-2035381/ | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||
T144 | Drying/Hygienization, drying, pressing of Chicken manure/Fertikal organic | Drying and processing (extrusion process)/ Name in LEX4BIO: FEK | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: livestock manure (Chicken manure) | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | Fertikal organic | Fertikal organic fertilizer (4-1-2) | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 68 (Manufacturer's declaration); 69.7 (Agostini et al., 2024) | 38.5 (Total C) | 4.37 | 1.44 | 2.21 | 90.1 | https://ars.els-cdn.com/content/image/1-s2.0-S0378429024002399-mmc1.docx | 9 | Yes | Yes | High | EU Southwest | Belgium | Wester-Larsen, L., Müller-Stöver, D.S., Salo, T. and Jensen, L.S., 2022. Potential ammonia volatilization from 39 different novel biobased fertilizers on the European market–a laboratory study using 5 European soils. Journal of Environmental Management, 323, p.116249. https://www.fklfertilizers.be/products/npk-4-3-3/ | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
T145 | Pelletizing/Hygienization and pelletizing of MBM, blood and feather meal/ECOLAN® AGRA ORGANIC 13-0-0 | Name in LEX4BIO: ECO | Industrial side-streams | Industrial side-streams: food industry by-products (blood and feather meal) | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | ECOLAN® AGRA ORGANIC 13-0-0 | ECOLAN® AGRA ORGANIC 13-0-0 | PFC 1(B) Organo-mineral fertilizer | 85 (Manufacturer's declaration); 92.2 (Agostini et al., 2024) | 50.8 (Total C) | 13 | 89.2 | https://ars.els-cdn.com/content/image/1-s2.0-S0378429024002399-mmc1.docx | 9 | Yes | Yes | High | EU North | Finland | Wester-Larsen, L., Müller-Stöver, D.S., Salo, T. and Jensen, L.S., 2022. Potential ammonia volatilization from 39 different novel biobased fertilizers on the European market–a laboratory study using 5 European soils. Journal of Environmental Management, 323, p.116249. https://kierratyslannoitteet.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/ecolan-agra-13-0-01.pdf | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | |||||||||||||||||||||||||
T146 | Anaerobic digestion / Sewage sludge and biowaste/ Peltoravinne | biogasification and hygienised/ Name in LEX4BIO: PRV | Urban Wastewater | Urban Wastewater: Sewage sludge | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | "Sewage sludge. The raw material has been treated in a biogasification process and sanitized. food waste.The product meets the requirements of the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry Regulation No. 24/11 for fertilizer products. The product is not approved for use on fresh vegetables, herbs and root spices, home gardens or seedling production (withdrawal period 5 years). The product is not suitable as such as a growing medium, for pasture use or for the production of grass fodder." | Peltoravinne | PFC 1(B) Organo-mineral fertilizer | 22.3 TOC | 2.93 | 2.85 | 25.1 | 9 | Yes | No | Low | EU North | Finland | Hernandez-Mora, A., Duboc, O., Lombi, E., Bünemann, E.K., Ylivainio, K., Symanczik, S., Delgado, A., Zahra, N.A., Nikama, J., Zuin, L. and Doolette, C.L., 2024. Fertilization efficiency of thirty marketed and experimental recycled phosphorus fertilizers. Journal of Cleaner Production, 467, p.142957. https://www.envor.fi/client/envor/userfiles/peltoravinne-1-2022.pdf | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||
T147 | Drying/ Drying, granulating and pelletizing of broiler litter/ Arvo 4-1-3-1 | Name in LEX4BIO: AV4 | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: livestock manure (Broiler litter) | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | Drying, mixing, pelletizing and granulation (Side streams that have to be treated according to the (EY) N:o 1069/2009 and (EU) 142/2011 are treated in the dryer, possible other raw materials are added and the mix is pelletised and granulated) | Arvo 4-1-3-1; Biolan Oy (marketed by Novarbo Oy); Granules | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 43.6 (Total C) | 4.46 | 1.12 | 3 (Manufacturer's declaration) | 1 (Manufacturer's declaration) | 89.3 | https://www.novarbo.fi/media/novarbo/esitteet/novarbo_lannoitteet_fi_web.pdf | 9 | Yes | No | Low | EU North | Finland | Wester-Larsen, L., Müller-Stöver, D.S., Salo, T. and Jensen, L.S., 2022. Potential ammonia volatilization from 39 different novel biobased fertilizers on the European market–a laboratory study using 5 European soils. Journal of Environmental Management, 323, p.116249. https://www.novarbo.fi/media/novarbo/esitteet/novarbo_lannoitteet_fi_web.pdf Kinsella, D., Forrestal, P., Robles, A. and Edayilam, N., 2023. D1. 1–Report on EU nutrient recovery technologies and derived products. | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
T148 | Drying/Drying, granulating and pelletizing of Broiler litter, blood meal + potassium sulfate/ Arvo 8-1-5-2 | Name in LEX4BIO: AV8 | Agricultural Biomasses | Industrial side-streams | Agricultural Biomasses: livestock manure (Broiler litter) Industrial side-streams: food industry by-products (blood meal) | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | ??? | Arvo 8-1-5-2; Biolan Oy (marketed by Novarbo Oy) | PFC 1(B) Organo-mineral fertilizer | 42.3 (Total C) | 7.87 | 1 | 5 | 2 | 92 | 660 | https://www.novarbo.fi/media/novarbo/esitteet/novarbo_lannoitteet_fi_web.pdf | 8 | Yes | Not known | Low | EU North | Finland | Wester-Larsen, L., Müller-Stöver, D.S., Salo, T. and Jensen, L.S., 2022. Potential ammonia volatilization from 39 different novel biobased fertilizers on the European market–a laboratory study using 5 European soils. Journal of Environmental Management, 323, p.116249. https://www.novarbo.fi/media/novarbo/esitteet/novarbo_lannoitteet_fi_web.pdf | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||||||
T149 | Pelletizing with Sphero technology/ Animal horns/ Biorga Hornmeal | Name in LEX4BIO: BIH | Industrial side-streams | Industrial side-streams: food industry by-products (Animal horns) | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | The SPHERO® technology refers to a type of underwater pelletizing system. | https://corona-serwis.com/download/automatik_%20peeletizing%20systems/sphero.pdf | Biorga Hornmeal, Hauert | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 94.2 (Agostini et al., 2024); 80 Manufacturer's declaration | 47.6 Total C | 15.47 | 89.2 | 9 | Yes | No | Medium | EU Central | Switzerland | Wester-Larsen, L., Müller-Stöver, D.S., Salo, T. and Jensen, L.S., 2022. Potential ammonia volatilization from 39 different novel biobased fertilizers on the European market–a laboratory study using 5 European soils. Journal of Environmental Management, 323, p.116249. https://docs.hauert.com/ch/datasheets/h-b-hornmehl-gedampft_de.pdf https://corona-serwis.com/download/automatik_%20peeletizing%20systems/sphero.pdf Agostini, L., Bünemann, E.K., Jakobsen, C., Salo, T., Wester-Larsen, L. and Symanczik, S., 2024. Prediction of nitrogen mineralization from novel bio-based fertilizers using chemical extractions. Environmental Technology & Innovation, 36, p.103781. | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||
T150 | Drying and pelletizing / broiler litter + seaweed/ Biolan luonnonlannoite 4-1-3 | Name in LEX4BIO: BIL | Agricultural Biomasses | Blue Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: livestock manure and slurry (broiler litter) Blue Biomasses: seaweed | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | Side streams that have to be treated according to the (EY) N:o 1069/2009 and (EU) 142/2011 are treated in the dryer, possible other raw materials are added and the mix is pelletized and granulated. "Seaweed powder has been added to enhance the plants' ability to absorb trace elements." | Biolan luonnonlannoite 4-1-3 | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 84 (Agostini et al., 2024); 83 (Manufacturer's declaration) | 43.5 Total C | 4.6 | 1 (Manufacturer's declaration) | 2.7 (Manufacturer's declaration) | 1.7 (Manufacturer's declaration) | 0.8 (Manufacturer's declaration) | 0.6 (Manufacturer's declaration) | 89.4 | https://www.biolan.fi/tuotteet/biolan-luonnonlannoite.html | 9 | Yes | No | Low | EU North | Finland | https://www.biolan.fi/tuotteet/biolan-luonnonlannoite.html Wester-Larsen, L., Müller-Stöver, D.S., Salo, T. and Jensen, L.S., 2022. Potential ammonia volatilization from 39 different novel biobased fertilizers on the European market–a laboratory study using 5 European soils. Journal of Environmental Management, 323, p.116249. Kinsella, D., Forrestal, P., Robles, A. and Edayilam, N., 2023. D1. 1–Report on EU nutrient recovery technologies and derived products. Agostini, L., Bünemann, E.K., Jakobsen, C., Salo, T., Wester-Larsen, L. and Symanczik, S., 2024. Prediction of nitrogen mineralization from novel bio-based fertilizers using chemical extractions. Environmental Technology & Innovation, 36, p.103781. | LEX4BIO/ project completed; NOVAFERT/Ongoing | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||||
T151 | Evaporation/ Potato cell water/ Boost NPK | Name in LEX4BIO: BO1 | Industrial side-streams | Industrial side-streams: food industry by-products (by-product of the production of potato protein) | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | Potato cell water comes from the processing of potatoes (e.g., for starch), and evaporationremoves water to concentrate the nutrients. | Boost NPK (Soilfood Oy); concentrated and liquid fertiliser | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 40.9 Total C | 7.93 | 0.21 FRESH W (Manufacturer's declaration) | 2.8 FRESH W (Manufacturer's declaration) | 0.026 FRESH W (Manufacturer's declaration) | 0.17 FRESH W (Manufacturer's declaration) | 0.34 FRESH W (Manufacturer's declaration) | 18.4 | https://soilfood.fi/maatalous/tuotteet/soilfood-boost-npk/ | 9 | Yes | No | Low | EU North | Finland | Wester-Larsen, L., Müller-Stöver, D.S., Salo, T. and Jensen, L.S., 2022. Potential ammonia volatilization from 39 different novel biobased fertilizers on the European market–a laboratory study using 5 European soils. Journal of Environmental Management, 323, p.116249.
Soilfood Boost NPK | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||||||
T152 | Anaerobic digestion / Vinasse from sugar production/ Boost NKS | Name in LEX4BIO: BO4 | Industrial side-streams | Industrial side-streams: food industry by-products (Vinasse from sugar production) | Industrial side-streams: digestate vinasse | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | Anaerobic digestion of vinasse from sugar production/ Soilfood Boost NKS premium (concentrated and liquid fertiliser) | Boost NKS premium; Soilfood Oy (concentrated and liquid fertiliser) | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 45.5 FRESH W (Manufacturer's declaration) | 34.2 Total C | 5.74 | 0 | 12.58 | 0.92 FRESH W (Manufacturer's declaration) | 0.07 FRESH W (Manufacturer's declaration) | 2.4 FRESH W (Manufacturer's declaration) | 62 | https://soilfood.fi/maatalous/tuotteet/soilfood-boost-nks-premium/ | 9 | Yes | Not known | Medium | EU North | Finland | Müller, B., Wester-Larsen, L., Jensen, L.S., Salo, T., Garrido, R.R., Arkoun, M., D'Oria, A., Lewandowski, I., Müller, T. and Bauerle, A., 2024. Agronomic performance of novel, nitrogen-rich biobased fertilizers across European field trial sites. Field Crops Research, 316, p.109486.
Soilfood Boost NKS PremiumWester-Larsen, L., Müller-Stöver, D.S., Salo, T. and Jensen, L.S., 2022. Potential ammonia volatilization from 39 different novel biobased fertilizers on the European market–a laboratory study using 5 European soils. Journal of Environmental Management, 323, p.116249. | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||||
T153 | Anaerobic digestion and composting/ Municipal organic food waste/Bio vækst compost | Name in LEX4BIO: BVC | Municipal Biowaste | Municipal Biowaste: i.e. household food waste, restaurant food waste, supermarket food waste | Municipal Biowaste:compost | CMC 3: Compost | Organic fertilizer based on composted municipal organic food waste. | Bio vækst compost | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 52.7 (ignition loss) | 26.4 Total C | 2.82 | 1.38 | 0.95 | 8.37 CaCO3 | 0.15 | 0.27 | 55.7 | 7 | Yes | Yes | Low | EU North | Denmark | https://biovaekst.dk/onewebmedia/2017_aug-2018jul_BioV_KOD_Kompost_Deklaration.pdf | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | |||||||||||||||||||||
T154 | Drying/ Poultry manure/ Fertilex | Drying in low temperature and pelletizing/ Name in LEX4BIO: FEL | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: livestock manure (Poultry manure) | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | "Fertilex pellets are produced in low-temperature drying, where the heat source is the heat produced by the chickens themselves." | Fertilex | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 70-90 (Manufacturer's declaration); 76.6 (Agostini et al., 2024) | 38.9 (Total C) | 4.51 | 1.08 | 2.16 | 9.9 (CaO) | 1.1 | 92.5 | 650-700 | https://fertilex.fi/en/for-farmers | 20 000 t/year | Static | 9 | Yes | Yes | Low | EU North | Finland | Wester-Larsen, L., Müller-Stöver, D.S., Salo, T. and Jensen, L.S., 2022. Potential ammonia volatilization from 39 different novel biobased fertilizers on the European market–a laboratory study using 5 European soils. Journal of Environmental Management, 323, p.116249. https://fertilex.fi/en Müller, B., Wester-Larsen, L., Jensen, L.S., Salo, T., Garrido, R.R., Arkoun, M., D'Oria, A., Lewandowski, I., Müller, T. and Bauerle, A., 2024. Agronomic performance of novel, nitrogen-rich biobased fertilizers across European field trial sites. Field Crops Research, 316, p.109486. Agostini, L., Bünemann, E.K., Jakobsen, C., Salo, T., Wester-Larsen, L. and Symanczik, S., 2024. Prediction of nitrogen mineralization from novel bio-based fertilizers using chemical extractions. Environmental Technology & Innovation, 36, p.103781. https://fertilex.fi/en/for-farmers | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | |||||||||||||||||||
T155 | Struvite precipitation/Sewage water/ PhosphorCare | Name in LEX4BIO: PCS | Urban Wastewater | Urban Wastewater: Sewage water | Urban Wastewater: precipitated phosphorus salts | CMC 12: Precipitated phosphate salts and derivates | In 2024 it was decided to close down production of phosphate because it was not a cost-effective case anymore due to rising prices on the chemistry involved in the production and that sales prices were not correspondingly high. | https://www.aarhusvand.com/cases/energy-optimization/phosphorcare-from-wastewater-to-valuable-fertilizer/ | PhosphorCare | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | 0.3 TOC | 10.44 | 23.3 | 54.8 | https://www.aarhusvand.com/cases/energy-optimization/phosphorcare-from-wastewater-to-valuable-fertilizer/ | 9 | Yes | No | Medium | EU North | Denmark | https://www.aarhusvand.com/cases/energy-optimization/phosphorcare-from-wastewater-to-valuable-fertilizer/ Hernandez-Mora, A., Duboc, O., Lombi, E., Bünemann, E.K., Ylivainio, K., Symanczik, S., Delgado, A., Zahra, N.A., Nikama, J., Zuin, L. and Doolette, C.L., 2024. Fertilization efficiency of thirty marketed and experimental recycled phosphorus fertilizers. Journal of Cleaner Production, 467, p.142957. | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
T156 | Evaporation/ Potato cell water/ liquid AKV K2 | Name in LEX4BIO: PCW | Industrial side-streams | Industrial side-streams: food industry by-products (by-product of the production of potato protein) | Industrial side-streams: | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | K-2 is a fertilizer product, a by-product of potato protein production, made by mixing K-30 and K-45 juice types, removing the protein, and evaporating water to increase the dry matter content from 4% to 40%. K-2 is still in liquid and pumpable form. | AKV K2 (liquid and pumpable form) | PFC 1(B) Organo-mineral fertilizer | 55.9 (Agostini et al., 2024) | 33 Total C | 4.51 | 1.18 | 19.17 | 3 kg/m3 | 8 kg/m3 | 33.9 | "20,000m3 of protamylasse are used as a fertiliser" | 9 | Yes | Yes | High | EU North | Denmark | https://www.akv.dk/agro/pulp-og-k-2/k-2-godning/ Müller, B., Wester-Larsen, L., Jensen, L.S., Salo, T., Garrido, R.R., Arkoun, M., D'Oria, A., Lewandowski, I., Müller, T. and Bauerle, A., 2024. Agronomic performance of novel, nitrogen-rich biobased fertilizers across European field trial sites. Field Crops Research, 316, p.109486. Wester-Larsen, L., Müller-Stöver, D.S., Salo, T. and Jensen, L.S., 2022. Potential ammonia volatilization from 39 different novel biobased fertilizers on the European market–a laboratory study using 5 European soils. Journal of Environmental Management, 323, p.116249. | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | |||||||||||||||||||||
T157 | Anaerobic digestion/ Agro and food waste + seaweed/ liquid Solrød digestate | Name in LEX4BIO: SDG | Agricultural Biomasses | Industrial side-streams | Blue Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: agricultural processing residues Industrial side-streams: food industry by-products Blue Biomasses: seaweed | Agricultural Biomasses: digestate agricultural processing residues Industrial side-streams: digestate food industry by-products Blue Biomasses: i.e. digestate seaweed | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | CMC 4: Fresh crop digestate | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | Liquid organic fertilizer based on fermented agricultural and food industry by-products, amended with seaweed. At the biogas plant, seaweed is processed in a cyclone where a stirrer separates sand (which sinks) from the seaweed (which floats), reducing sand content. Seaweed is co-digested at the biogas plant, alongside industrial biomass waste from nearby companies, livestock manure (from cows and pigs) and sorted organic household waste. | liquid Solrød digestate | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 78.2 (Agostini et al., 2024) | 28.4 Total C | 10.79 | 1.58 | 2.89 | 3.8 | Lybæk, R. and Kjær, T., 2023. Study of cast seaweed harvesting technologies used in the bay of Køge and their implications for effective biogas production: Applying a circular bio-economy approach. Sustainable Chemistry and Pharmacy, 35, p.101169. | annually produces around 209,000 tn of fertilizer | 9 | Yes | Yes | High | EU North | Denmark | Müller, B., Wester-Larsen, L., Jensen, L.S., Salo, T., Garrido, R.R., Arkoun, M., D'Oria, A., Lewandowski, I., Müller, T. and Bauerle, A., 2024. Agronomic performance of novel, nitrogen-rich biobased fertilizers across European field trial sites. Field Crops Research, 316, p.109486. Lybæk, R. and Kjær, T., 2023. Study of cast seaweed harvesting technologies used in the bay of Køge and their implications for effective biogas production: Applying a circular bio-economy approach. Sustainable Chemistry and Pharmacy, 35, p.101169. | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||
T158 | Drying and Hypersonic Flocculation/ Super Heated Steam/ Fish sludge/ Mira fertilizer Terramarine AS | Drying and Hypersonic Flocculation of feed residues and fish feces | Blue Biomasses | Blue Biomasses:aquaculture sludge (feed residues and fish feces) | None | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | It is primarily in land-based and closed aquaculture facilities where sludge can be efficiently collected and processed. Bioretur’s dryer is based on Super Heated Steam. A scrubber reduces odors and condenses vapor. The dryer ensures the safest and cleanest hygienization of the sludge available in the market. It transforms fish sludge into hygienized and storage-stable powder with 90% dry solids content. | https://bioretur.no/en/complete-sludge-treatment/ | Mira fertilizer Terramarine AS and Bioretur | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | https://ars.els-cdn.com/content/image/1-s2.0-S0378429024002399-mmc1.docx | 9 | Yes | Not known | Medium | EU North | Norway | https://bioretur.no/en/drying-of-fish-sludge/
Circular Economyhttps://www.terramarine.no/#products https://businessnorway.com/solutions/bioretur-converts-fish-waste-to-fertiliser | national project | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
T159 | Anaerobic Digestion/ fish sludge/ liquid digestate | Liquid digestate after anaerobic digestion from Cermaq hatchery by Sterner treatment technology | Blue Biomasses | Blue Biomasses:aquaculture sludge (feed residues and fish feces) | Blue Biomasses: digestate (liquid digestate of fish sludge) | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | Fish sludge collected from the RAS system at Cermaq Hatchery undergoes a multi-step treatment process to convert organic waste into digestate using Sterner Treatment Technology. The process involves the following stages:Drum filter; Gravimetric thickening by conical sedimentation (4-5% DM); Wet grinding before biological hydrolysis; Biogas production in anaerobic baffle (ABR) biogas reactor. | https://www.sterneras.no/en/sludge-treatment/ | Liquid digestate of fish sludge | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 52 | 37.1 total C | 1.7 g/L | 0.09 g/L | 0.02 g/L | 0.3 g/L | 0.04 g/L | 0.5 | 7 | Yes | Yes | Medium | EU North | Norway | Brod, E., Henriksen, T.M., Ørnsrud, R. and Eggen, T., 2023. Quality of fish sludge as fertiliser to spring cereals: Nitrogen effects and environmental pollutants. Science of the Total Environment, 875, p.162541.
Sludge Treatment (EN) | national research project Kretsløp SIS | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||||
T160 | Anaerobic Digestion/ fish sludge/ dried digestate | a mixture of digestate and undigested fish sludge (dried digestate+fish sludge) from Cermaq hatchery by Sterner treatment technology | Blue Biomasses | Blue Biomasses:aquaculture sludge (feed residues and fish feces) | Blue Biomasses: digestate (liquid digestate of fish sludge) | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | Fish sludge collected from the RAS system at Cermaq Hatchery undergoes a multi-step treatment process to convert organic waste into digestate using Sterner Treatment Technology. The process involves the following stages: Chemical polymer is added to digestate (1.5-2% DM) before dewatering by screw press (35% DM); Dewatered digestate is dried at 50 °C. The product was a mixture of dried digestate and fish sludge. | https://www.sterneras.no/en/sludge-treatment/ | Dried digestate of fish sludge | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 64 | 34.9 total C | 6 | 3 | 0.02 | 6.6 | 0.39 | 74 | 7 | Yes | Yes | Medium | EU North | Norway | Brod, E., Henriksen, T.M., Ørnsrud, R. and Eggen, T., 2023. Quality of fish sludge as fertiliser to spring cereals: Nitrogen effects and environmental pollutants. Science of the Total Environment, 875, p.162541.
Sludge Treatment (EN) | national research project Kretsløp SIS | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||||
T161 | Struvite precipitation/sewage sludge/ Crystal Green® | Name in LEX4BIO: CGO | Urban Wastewater | Urban Wastewater: Sewage sludge | Urban Wastewater: precipitated phosphorus salts | CMC 12: Precipitated phosphate salts and derivates | Crystal Green is produced using Ostara's patented nutrient recovery technologies | https://www.ostara.com/nutrient-recovery/nutrient-recovery-solutions/ | Granular Crystal Green® | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | 1.5 | 0.3 TOC | 10.15 | 22.8 | 54.8 | https://www.ostara.com/products/crystal-green/ | 9 | Yes | Yes | High | EU Southwest | Netherlands | https://www.ostara.com/products/crystal-green/ Hernandez-Mora, A., Duboc, O., Lombi, E., Bünemann, E.K., Ylivainio, K., Symanczik, S., Delgado, A., Zahra, N.A., Nikama, J., Zuin, L. and Doolette, C.L., 2024. Fertilization efficiency of thirty marketed and experimental recycled phosphorus fertilizers. Journal of Cleaner Production, 467, p.142957. Das, S., Helmus, R., Dong, Y., Beijer, S., Praetorius, A., Parsons, J.R. and Jansen, B., 2023. Organic contaminants in bio-based fertilizer treated soil: Target and suspect screening approaches. Chemosphere, 337, p.139261. Dong, Y., Das, S., Parsons, J.R., Praetorius, A., de Rijke, E., Helmus, R., Slootweg, J.C. and Jansen, B., 2023. Simultaneous detection of pesticides and pharmaceuticals in three types of bio-based fertilizers by an improved QuEChERS method coupled with UHPLC-q-ToF-MS/MS. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 458, p.131992. Jama-Rodzeńska, A., Gałka, B., Szuba-Trznadel, A., Jandy, A. and Kamińska, J.A., 2023. Effect of struvite (Crystal Green) fertilization on soil element content determined by different methods under soybean cultivation. Scientific Reports, 13(1), p.12702. Frick, H., Bünemann, E.K., Hernandez-Mora, A., Eigner, H., Geyer, S., Duboc, O., Santner, J., Recena, R., Delgado, A., Arkoun, M. and Tóth, Z., 2025. Bio-based fertilisers can replace conventional inorganic P fertilisers under European pedoclimatic conditions. Field Crops Research, 325, p.109803. Müller, B., Herrmann, M.N., Lewandowski, I., Müller, T., Hartung, J. and Bauerle, A., 2024. The Effect of Biobased N and P Fertilizers in a Winter Wheat–Ryegrass Crop Rotation. Agronomy, 14(10), p.2424. | LEX4BIO/ project completed | LUKE | |||||||||||||||||||||||
T162 | Pyrolysis/ash derived from industrial sewage sludge/ PolFerAsh | Name in Novafert: PolFerAsh | Urban Wastewater | Urban Wastewater: Sewage sludge | Urban Wastewater: ash from sludge pyrolysis | CMC 14: Pyrolysis And Gasification Materials | PolFerAsh is a technology that used industrial sewage sludge to produce Monommonium Phosphate (MAP) that is a solid material with a pH of 5. "A patented method of phosphorus recovery from SSA with the use of nitric and phosphoric acid, developed by the Cracow University of Technology, is characterized by an efficiency of 80–96%." | http://generalchemistry.chemeng.ntua.gr/uest/chania2023/posters/CostEstimationPayment/647a808e65666mvOsd/4321_gorazda_Chania_23_poster.pdf | PolFerAsh FERTILISER NP (Ca-Mg) 17-20 (7-2.4) | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | 17% NH3 | 7.8% P2O5 soluble in water; Total P2O5 19.91% | 7.39 | 2.36 | http://generalchemistry.chemeng.ntua.gr/uest/chania2023/posters/CostEstimationPayment/647a808e65666mvOsd/4321_gorazda_Chania_23_poster.pdf | 9 | Yes | Yes | Medium | EU Central | Poland | https://www.novafert.eu/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/D1.1_Report-on-EU-nutrient-recovery-technologies-and-derived-products.pdf Smol, M., Kulczycka, J., Lelek, Ł., Gorazda, K. and Wzorek, Z., 2020. Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) of the integrated technology for the phosphorus recovery from sewage sludge ash (SSA) and fertilizers production. Archives of Environmental Protection, 46(2). http://uest.ntua.gr/naxos2018/proceedings/pdf/62_NAXOS2018_Gorazda_etal.pdf http://generalchemistry.chemeng.ntua.gr/uest/chania2023/posters/CostEstimationPayment/647a808e65666mvOsd/4321_gorazda_Chania_23_poster.pdf | Novafert | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
T163 | Chemical Treatment/ sulphur dioxide from the installation to produce sulphuric acid/ K2S2O3 Potassium thiosulfate | Name in Novafert: Claus desulfurization process | Industrial side-streams | Industrial side-streams: chemical industry by-products (sulphur dioxide (SO₂) from the sulphuric acid production process) | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | The Claus desulfurization process is an industrial method used to remove hydrogen sulfide (H₂S) from gas streams. Stage I: A technology for the production of potassium sulfate (IV) was developed. Stage II: Potassium thiosulfate was produced from potassium (IV) sulfate and sulphur from the Claus desulfurization process. | liquid | PFC 3(B): Inorganic soil improver | 9 | Yes | Not known | Medium | EU Central | Poland | https://www.novafert.eu/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/D1.1_Report-on-EU-nutrient-recovery-technologies-and-derived-products.pdf | Novafert | LUKE | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
T164 | Drying and shredding and chemical-physical treatment process/sewage sludge, biodegradable waste, and selected animal by products/ FuelCAI® | Name in Novafert: FuelCAI® | Urban Wastewater | Industrial side-streams | Urban Wastewater: Sewage sludge | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | FuelCAI® uses sewage sludge, biodegradable waste, and selected animal by products to produce organo-mineral fertiliser, which is a powder product that has a high pH of 12.6 and is suitable for acidic soil. "The essence of OrCal®’s quick and effective action is its active calcium hydrate and solubility in water – 1.7g/1000ml, which is excellent, almost 100 times better than the solubility of calcium carbonates (chalk and dolomites) – 0.02g/1000ml. The OrCal® action rate is due to the shorter reaction of OH- ion formation than in dolomite- and chalk-based calcium fertilisers." Steps are: Drying, Placement of the substrate in the intake trough,shredding of the substrate in the shredder, adding optional nutrients such as micro- and macro-elements, | https://evergreensolutions.pl/en/fuelcal-technology/ Zakrzewski, J. and Chabelski, T., 2016. Technologia FuelCal przetwarzania odpadowych biomas na wieloskładnikowe nawozy organiczno-mineralne i wapniowo-organiczne OrCal®. Inżynieria Ekologiczna. | OrCal® ; powder | PFC 1(B) Organo-mineral fertilizer | 35.8 | 1.5 | 0.48 | 0.20 | 22.12 | Zakrzewski, J. and Chabelski, T., 2016. Technologia FuelCal przetwarzania odpadowych biomas na wieloskładnikowe nawozy organiczno-mineralne i wapniowo-organiczne OrCal®. Inżynieria Ekologiczna. | 9 | Yes | Not known | High | EU Central | Poland | https://www.novafert.eu/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/D1.1_Report-on-EU-nutrient-recovery-technologies-and-derived-products.pdf
European Food Safety Authority (EFSA), 2009. FuelCal® technology as new alternative method of disposal or use of animal by‐products. EFSA Journal, 7(2), p.972.
Result product OrCal® FuelCal® technologyZakrzewski, J. and Chabelski, T., 2016. Technologia FuelCal przetwarzania odpadowych biomas na wieloskładnikowe nawozy organiczno-mineralne i wapniowo-organiczne OrCal®. Inżynieria Ekologiczna. | Novafert | LUKE | |||||||||||||||||||||||
T165 | heating-dispersing /Cattle manure/ AGROLINIJA-S liquid | Name in Novafert:liquid fertiliser AGROLINIJA-S | Agricultural Biomasses | Agricultural Biomasses: Cattle manure | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | "Natural organic fertilizer made from cattle bedding compost and leonardite humates using innovative HTD® technology. It combines biologically active microorganisms, humic and fulvic acids, macro- and microelements, and amino acids into a single complex of biologically active components, in which all nutrient components are present in a form readily available to plants." | Liquid organic fertilizer - biostimulant - AGROLINIJA-S | 54% (3.7% in Novafert) | 3.75 (0.17% in Novafert) | 1.96 (0.07% in Novafert) | 7.15 (1% in Novafert) | 5.6 | https://golden-hectare.com/products/agrolinija-s-bio-dunger-konzentrat-25-liter | 9 | Yes | Not known | Medium | EU Central | Poland | https://www.novafert.eu/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/D1.1_Report-on-EU-nutrient-recovery-technologies-and-derived-products.pdf https://golden-hectare.com/products/agrolinija-s-bio-dunger-konzentrat-25-liter | Novafert | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||
T166 | Drying and chemical reaction /Sewage sludge, ashes from biomass combustion/ BIOROL Natural Fertiliser | Name in Novafert: BIOROL Natural Fertiliser | Urban Wastewater | Industrial side-streams | Urban Wastewater: Sewage sludge | Industrial side-stream: ash from biomass combustion | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | "In the Biorol technology, the composition of the waste mixture used in the process has been standardized to achieve the best qualitative characteristics of the Biorol natural fertilizer. For the purpose of the Biorol technology, a program for quantitative dosing of waste into the process with variable morphology of input materials has been developed. The whole process is monitored with regard to process parameters such as temperature, pressure, humidity of the mixture and the product, granule size, and efficiency. For safety reasons, the heating medium in the installation does not come into direct contact with the dried material. An unquestionable advantage of the Biorol Technology is the innovative design of the drying plant. The solution, in the form of a special design of the blades inside the drying plant, counteracts the “sticky phase” during the sludge and ash mixture drying process. The applied solution reduces the need for thermal energy during the reduction of the hydration of the mixture. The design of the drying plant is air-tight, which minimizes the accumulation of dust on the machinery and process equipment in the building and prevents odor nuisance. Granulation of the produced Biorol fertilizer enables safe transport and storage and easy control of its application to the soil." | https://www.eko-technologie.info/en/technology/#:~:text=The%20Biorol%20Technology%20is%20a,ashes%20generated%20by%20biomass%20combustion. | BIOROL Natural Fertiliser; AgriRol | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | 35 | 1.2 | 2.6 | https://www.bio-rol.pl/nawoz-organiczny/ | 9 | Yes | Not known | High | EU Central | Poland | https://www.novafert.eu/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/D1.1_Report-on-EU-nutrient-recovery-technologies-and-derived-products.pdf
Technologyhttps://www.bio-rol.pl/nawoz-organiczny/ | Novafert | LUKE | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
T167 | Biomass gasification | Biomass and/or waste gasification for syngas production and biochar | Agricultural Biomasses | Urban Wastewater | Municipal Biowaste | agricultural residues and municipal biowaste | urban wastewater | CMC 14: Pyrolysis And Gasification Materials, CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Biochar production as a bioproduct of gasification process | Biochar to be used as soil amendment and substrate to alternative fertilizers | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 70 | 1.00 | 0.18 | 2.45 | 1 | 0.85 | 9 | Yes | Yes | Medium | EU Southeast | Greece | HELLABIOM | MainstreamBio | Q-PLAN | ||||||||||||||||||||||
T168 | Hydrothermal Carbonization (HTC) | Hydrothermal Carbonization of waste biomass to char | Agricultural Biomasses | Municipal Biowaste | Blue Biomasses | Agricultural residues like corn sotver, rice husk, hyacinth, etc. | Food waste, algae, poultry, dairy manure | CMC 13: Thermal oxidation materials and their derivatives | Biomass waste --> HTC --> Liquid Solid separation --> Wet cake --> drying --> Hydrochar --> Soil amendment | Hydrochar as soil amendment | PFC 3(B): Inorganic soil improver | 45.4 | 21 | 9.2 | 7.6 | 8 | Yes | Yes | Medium | EU North | Germany, Ireland | AHT Clean Tec | https://www.mdpi.com/1996-1944/14/15/4114# | MainstreamBio | Q-PLAN | |||||||||||||||||||||||
T169 | Manure Compost | Manure Compost | Municipal Biowaste | Livestock farming manure | May some agricultural residues to enrich manure content | CMC 3: Compost | Biomass composting process | Manure Compost | PFC 3(B): Inorganic soil improver | 29.7 | 24.6 | 0.71 | 0.05 | 2.11 | 9 | Yes | Yes | Low | EU North/Central/Southwest/Southeast | Ireland and actually in every country | Looop company, Vermont compost company, etc. +++ | https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Chemical-Composition-of-Poultry-Manure_tbl1_317831776 | MainstreamBio | Q-PLAN | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
T170 | Slurry as fertilizer | Slurry fraction from mechanical solid-liquid separation from various liquid waste treatment facilities | Municipal Biowaste | Urban Wastewater | Slurry, wastewater | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Wastewater --> slurry --> Mechanical solid-liquid separation --> solid franction --> fertilizer | Solid state slurry based fertilizer | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 12.1 | 4.27 | 0.23 | 0.08 | 36 | 8 | Yes | Yes | Medium | EU Central | Denmark, Netherlands, Spain, Belgium, Poland | Slurryseparation, fertilizermanufacturingsolutions, etc. | https://www.researchgate.net/figure/The-chemical-composition-of-the-slurry_tbl1_335914812 | MainstreamBio | Q-PLAN | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
T171 | Biomass pyrolysis | Biomass and/or waste pyrolysis for biochar and biooils production | Agricultural Biomasses | agricultural residues and municipal biowaste | Industrial side streams may be used | CMC 14: Pyrolysis And Gasification Materials, CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Biochar production as a bioproduct of pyrolysis process | Biochar to be used as soil amendment and substrate to alternative fertilizers | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 70 | 1 | 0.18 | 2.45 | 1 | 0.85 | 9 | Yes | Yes | Medium | EU Central | Germany, Denmark, UK, Hungary, Estonia and other countries | Haiqenvtech, PYREG, Huarui Carbon, etc. | MainstreamBio | MainstreamBio | Q-PLAN | |||||||||||||||||||||||
T172 | Sewage sludge fertlizer | Sewage sludge from Waste Water Treatment Plants is being processed with anaerobic digestion and it is used as a fertilizer | Urban Wastewater | Municipal Biowaste | Industrial side-streams | Wastewater, landfill leachate | Industrial side streams | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | Wastewater --> WWTP --> sewage sludge --> Anaerobic digestion --> digestate --> fertilizer | Sewage sludge digestate as fertilizer | PFC 1(B) Organo-mineral fertilizer | 35 | 7.3 | 2.7 | 0.8 | 1.8 | 0.3 | 9 | Yes | Yes | Medium | EU North/Central/Southwest/Southeast | Almost all | Many public and private organisations | https://www.researchgate.net/figure/MSW-compost-and-sewage-sludge-composition-on-a-dry-matter-basis_tbl1_274067405 | MainstreamBio | Q-PLAN | |||||||||||||||||||||
T173 | Digestate as a fertilizer | Anaerobic digestion of biomass for biogas production and digestate utilization as a fertilizer | Agricultural Biomasses | Municipal Biowaste | Blue Biomasses | Livestock manure, crops residues | CMC 4: Fresh crop digestate | Biomass waste --> Anaerobic digestion --> biogas --> digestate --> fertilizer | Digestate as fertilizer from biogas | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 5.7 | 0.49 | 0.06 | 0.42 | 0.13 | 0.05 | 9 | Yes | Yes | Medium | EU North/Central/Southwest/Southeast | All | A lot of them | https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Chemical-composition-of-digestate-measured-in-100-g-of-digestate_tbl1_332975435 | MainstreamBio | Q-PLAN | ||||||||||||||||||||||
T174 | Struvite precipitation | Struvite precipitation | Urban Wastewater | Municipal Biowaste | Waste water | CMC 12: Precipitated phosphate salts and derivates | waste water (high concentration of N, P) + base + Mg source --> struvite --> fertlizer | Struvite fertilizer | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | 5.4 | 12.5 | 0.31 | 9.5 | 8 | Yes | Not known | Medium | EU North | England, Switzerland, Germany, etc. | Certainteed Gypsum, Ostara Nutrient Recovery Technologies, entex GmbH, etc. | https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Chemical-composition-of-the-pure-struvite-and-precipitation-obtained-under_tbl1_259319787 | MainstreamBio | Q-PLAN | |||||||||||||||||||||||||
T175 | Dry sewage sludge fertlizer | Sewage sludge from Waste Water Treatment Plants is being processed with thermal drying and it is used as a fertilizer | Urban Wastewater | Municipal Biowaste | Industrial side-streams | Wastewater, landfill leachate | Industrial side streams | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | Wastewater --> WWTP --> sewage sludge --> Thermal drying --> fertilizer | Sewage sludge dry substrate as fertilizer | PFC 1(B) Organo-mineral fertilizer | 35 | 7.3 | 2.7 | 0.8 | 1.8 | 0.3 | 9 | Yes | Yes | Medium | EU North/Central/Southwest/Southeast | Almost all | Many public and private organisations | https://www.researchgate.net/figure/MSW-compost-and-sewage-sludge-composition-on-a-dry-matter-basis_tbl1_274067405 | MainstreamBio | Q-PLAN | |||||||||||||||||||||
T176 | Liquid NPK fertilizer | Liquid NPK fertilizer derived from vacuum evaporation of various liquid waste | Urban Wastewater | Municipal Biowaste | Industrial side-streams | Various wastewater streams rich in N,P content | Urban waste water, industrial streams | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Wastewater --> Vacuum evaporation --> N,P recovery --> Water evaporation --> Liquid NPK fertilizer | Liquid NPK alternative fertilizer from vacuum evaporation | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | depending on the input | depending on the input | depending on the input | depending on the input | depending on the input | depending on the input | depending on the input | depending on the input | 8 | Yes | Not known | High | EU Central | Germany, France, Spain, Denmark, etc. | Biogastechnik Süd GmbH, KMU LOFT Cleanwater SE, Körting Hannover GmbH, etc. | MainstreamBio | Q-PLAN | ||||||||||||||||||||
T177 | Aqua2N | Urban Wastewater | Urban Wastewater | Reject water from sludge dewatering | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | 1) Precipitation of nitrogen-rich compound from the reject water after dewatering of wastewater sludge 2) Centrifugation to separate precipitates 3) Acidification (with sulfuric acid) of solid phase to separate precipitation agent and form Ammonium Sulfate, *Can add evaporation step to concentrate final product of ammonium sulphate from ~20% to ~40% | Liquid ammonium sulphate fertiliser (EasyMining has not branded the fertilizer with a name) | Treated reject water from wastewater sludge dewatering, precipitation agent | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | 8,4 | 9,6 | 1 | 7 | Yes | Yes | Medium | EU North | Denmark | Easymining | https://www.ri.se/en/expertise-areas/projects/cinurgi-eu-interreg-bsr | CiNURGi | RISE | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||
T178 | Ash2Phos | Urban Wastewater | Urban Wastewater | Dewatered wastewater sludge | CMC 13: Thermal oxidation materials and their derivatives | CMC 1: Virgin material substances and mixtures | Dewatered sludge drying and mono-incineration to ash (CMC13) followed by chemical treatment with acid (HCl) and lime (CMC 1) resulting in end product calcium phosphate (Ca5(PO4)3OH) | RevoCaP | Ferric chloride, aluminium chemicals, sand | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer | 17.9 | 0 | 36.8 | 95 | 8 | Yes | Yes | Medium | EU North | Sweden, Germany | EasyMining | https://www.ri.se/en/expertise-areas/projects/cinurgi-eu-interreg-bsr | CiNURGi | RISE | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
T179 | Ekobalans Pellets | EkoBalalans Recycled Fertilizer | Agricultural Biomasses | Municipal Biowaste | Industrial side-streams | Liquid pig manure, household food waste, slaughterhouse waste and other food industry byproducts | Digestate from pig manure, municipal biowaste, slaughterhouse waste and food industry byproducts | CMC 5: Digestate other than fresh crop digestate | CMC 15: Recovered high purity materials | Addition of polymer, separation with a Fournier rotary press, drying, addition of ammonium sulfate crystals, mixing, pelletising. | Ekobalans Kretslopps NPK++ | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 24 | 8 | 1 | 2 | 1 | 0.2 | 6 | 8 | Yes | No | Medium | EU North | Sweden | Söderåsens Bioenergi AB | https://www.ri.se/en/expertise-areas/projects/cinurgi-eu-interreg-bsr ; https://ekobalans.se/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/EkoBalans-Kretsloppsgo%CC%88dsel-product-data-sheet.pdf | CiNURGi | RISE | |||||||||||||||||||
T180 | Organic Pellets | Pelletized Organic Fertilizer | Industrial side-streams | Agricultural Biomasses | Slaughterhouse residues (meat- and bonemeal, bonemeal) (Biofer 10-3-1, and most of their other Biofer products) Blood meal for Biofer N15 | Chicken manure (Not sure which product), Vinass (Biofer 9-3-4 and Biofer 6-3-12) | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | Components are purchaced seperatetly, mixed in specified rations, then pelletized and packaged | Biofer 10-3-1, they have multiple product formulations that they sell (https://gyllebogodning.se/produkter/), data here is for Biofer 10-3-1. | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 10 | 2.6 | 1 | 4.4 | 0.2 | 0.5 | https://gyllebogodning.se/produkt/biofer-10-3-1/ | Static | 9 | Yes | Yes | Low | High | EU North | Sweden | Gyllebo gödning | https://www.ri.se/sv/expertisomraden/projekt/vaxtnaring-i-osakra-tider | Växtnäring i osäkra tider, CiNURGi | RISE | ||||||||||||||||||
T181 | Pelleted manure | Pelleted complete digested pig manure | Agricultural Biomasses | Industrial side-streams | Digested pig manure | Slaughterhouse ABPs | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | CMC 1: Virgin material substances and mixtures | Pig manure and slaughterhouse ABP waste is co-digested, digestate is dewatered with a screw press, the liquid is evaporated after acidification with sulfuric acid, the concentrate is added to the solid fraction and then together dried in a belt dryer and then pelleted. | See bottom of this file for a diagram | Alviksgårds Biogödsel | Condensate water from the evaporator, low amount of N in the water but unclear on the concentration. Should be used for irrigation or potentially if low enough N content it can be released. | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | 26.7 | 7 | 1 | 2.2 | 1.4 | 0.9 | 7.8 | 95 | Static | 9 | Yes | No | High | Low | EU North | Sweden | Alviks gård | https://www.ri.se/sv/expertisomraden/projekt/vaxtnaring-i-osakra-tider https://purac.se/referenser/alviksgarden-lulea/ | Växtnäring i osäkra tider | RISE | ||||||||||||||
T182 | Pelleted Organic Fertilizer | Industrial side-streams | Slaughterhouse residues, Meat- and bonemeal (Most of their AgroPellets formulations), blood meal for AgroPellets N14. | Vinass (AgroPellets 8-3-5-3, 6-5-2-1, 6-3-8-4, ) Chicken Manure (AgroPellet 4.4-1-5-2) | CMC 10: Derived products within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1069/2009 | CMC 6: Food industry by-products | CMC 1: Virgin material substances and mixtures | Components are purchaced seperatetly, mixed in specified rations, then pelletized and packaged | AgroPellets, there are multiple products they sell with various formulations and CMCs. AgroPellets 10-3-1 is a very common fertilizer bought. | PFC 1(A) Organic fertilizer | 9,7 | 3.5 | 0,9 | 7,5 | 0,2 | 0,9 | 9 | Yes | Low | High | EU North | Sweden | Ekoväx (http://www.ekovax.se) | https://www.ri.se/sv/expertisomraden/projekt/vaxtnaring-i-osakra-tider | Växtnäring i osäkra tider | RISE | ||||||||||||||||||||||
T183 | High-temperature composting by Rootzone Africa process | Rootzone organic compost by heat composting with closed system | Industrial side-streams | Municipal Biowaste | Urban Wastewater | Coffee husks, food processing waste, municipal organic solid waste | sludge | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | A single container (BFP unit) has the capacity to compost 18 tons of organic waste at a time | Sorting, crushing and mixing wastes, heat controlled aerobic composting, maturing, screening, bagging | Heat Controlled Composting takes place in an isolated bioreactor, whereby microorganism is degrading and transforming biomass into a mixture of mineralized and organic composition. The aerobic composting process is activated by blowing in oxygen over the biomass using an aerator and if higher moisture is needed. After 24-48 hours, the biomass will reach +70° C and is kept at this temperature for the next 24 hours, whereby any pathogenic bacteria, protozoa and weed seeds has been destroyed and the biomass is completely sterilized. Then the biomass is left to mature. The composting process is constantly monitored by the control system which monitors and controls temperature and oxygen content. Within another 3 days the material has become a dark brown colored and sweet smelling humus with high organic matter. Once the matter has stabilized at an ambient temperature the product has matured and is ready for screening. | Rootzone Organic Compost | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | The annual production capacity of a single container (BFP unit) is 6-800 tons of bio-fertilizer per year or 2-15 tons of bio-fertilizer per week | Static/Mobile | 9 | Yes | Not known | Medium | Medium | AU | Kenya, Uganda | Rootzone Africa Limited https://rootzoneafrica.com/ | https://rootzoneafrica.com/ https://rootzoneafrica.com/bio-fertilizer-technology/ https://rootzone.dk/products-services/bio-fertilizer | Rootzone Africa | IUNG | ||||||||||||||||||||||
T184 | Insect composting in Rwanda | Composting using insects Black Soldier fly larvae | Municipal Biowaste | Agricultural Biomasses | Coffee pulp, food waste, organic waste | CMC 11: By-products within the meaning of Directive 2008/98/EC | Food waste is mixed with coffee pulp and treated with black soldier fly larvae, which transform it into nutrient-rich compost in just 10 days. | Organic Compost | PFC 3(A): Organic soil improver | Static | 7 | Yes | No | Low | High | AU | Rwanda | Sucafina Rwanda https://group.sucafina.com/, The Bug Picture https://thebugpicture.com/, COPED GRUP https://copedgroup.rw/ | https://group.sucafina.com/news/sustainable-development/page-3/making-biofertilizer-rwanda/ https://group.sucafina.com/news/sustainable-development/page-4/get-your-hands-dirty-earth-day/ | RWACOF | IUNG | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||
T185 | Solid organo-mineral fertiliser from composted biomass and mineral inputs by "FOMI-CAPAD" process | Technology for producing solid organo-mineral fertiliser by co-composting of organic biomass and mineral nutrient sources through the "FOMI-CAPAD" process | Organic waste (crop residues, animal manure) | Agro-industrial waste | Mineral nutrient additives (e.g., phosphates, sulphates) | Agricultural Biomasses: livestock manure | Agricultural Biomasses: composted manure | The FOMI factory in Burundi processes approximately 150–500 tonnes of raw organic materials per day, depending on season and sourcing logistics. | (1) sourcing of locally composted livestock manure and imported mineral nutrients (NPK blends) at the Maramvya factory; (2) mixing of organic and mineral components to achieve target nutrient ratios (e.g., NPK 9‑22‑4 CaO MgO); (3) granulation or pelletizing to ensure uniform size and ease of application; (4) drying and cooling to reduce moisture content and stabilize product; (5) packaging for bulk or bagged distribution across Burundi, Rwanda, Uganda, and Eastern D.R. Congo. | The FOMI-citad process is based on co-composting locally sourced livestock manure with imported mineral nutrients to produce standardized organo-mineral fertilizers adapted to burundi's soils and cropping systems. after sourcing, organic and mineral components are mixed in predefined nutrient ratios (e.g., NPK 9‑22‑4 + CaO + MgO), then granulated or pelletized for consistent size and nutrient content. the granules are dried, cooled, and packaged for distribution across burundi and the greater great lakes region. the process operates under controlled conditions to ensure moisture reduction, pathogen elimination, and product stability. production is handled at the maramvya facility, which scaled from 150–200 t/day in 2019 to 500 t/day in 2021, supported by iso-certified practices and quality control protocols. | https://fomi.bi/?p=8850 | FOMI Imbura (granular NPK) and FOMI Bukivuge (organic-mineral compost) | PFC 1(C) Inorganic fertilizer and PFC 1(D) Organo-mineral fertilizer | Total Nitrogen (N): 20–25% (Form: primarily as ammonium (NH₄⁺) and nitrate (NO₃⁻)) | 50 | 30 | 9-22 | 22-24 | 4-22 | 4-13 | 2 | 0 | 9 | FOMI’s ammonium nitrate production plant is fully operational in Bujumbura, Burundi. The facility processes organic waste and mineral components to produce high-quality ammonium nitrate fertilizers for national and regional distribution. The installation is recognized and supported through public-private collaboration with CAPAD, and serves as a key supplier of inorganic fertilizers within EAFF member regions. | FOMI’s ammonium nitrate production prioritizes efficient nutrient recovery and minimal environmental impact. The process follows closed-loop principles to prevent nitrogen losses, particularly ammonia volatilization. While a full Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) has not been published, operational practices indicate reduced greenhouse gas emissions compared to conventional nitrogen production. The use of organic waste as input contributes to resource efficiency and supports circular economy objectives. Mass and nutrient balance data are internally monitored, and soil and water safety assessments are part of national regulatory compliance. | Medium – The FOMI ammonium nitrate production process involves mechanical separation, chemical transformation, and thermal control. It integrates several steps such as slurry separation, ammonia stripping, and acid scrubbing, requiring moderate engineering and chemical handling skills but not to the extent of full-scale high-complexity systems. | Burundi, Eastern DR Congo, Rwanda, and Tanzania – The technology is implemented and operated by FOMI in Burundi, with distribution networks extending to Eastern DR Congo, Rwanda, and Tanzania through partnerships with farmer organizations such as CAPAD and affiliated cooperatives. | Burundi | FOMI Société par Actions (FOMI S.A.) – a fertilizer production enterprise based in Burundi, responsible for manufacturing and distributing the product. | Confédération des Associations des Producteurs Agricoles pour le Développement (CAPAD) – a national farmers’ organization in Burundi that collaborates with FOMI to support implementation, farmer outreach, and adoption of the fertilizer technology. | Projet d’Appui à la Productivité Agricole au Burundi (PAPAB) – A completed project that supported fertilizer adoption and technology transfer through FOMI in Burundi. The project facilitated improved soil fertility practices and enhanced access to quality fertilizers among smallholder farmers. | EAFF |